|
I liked his confident (and correct) put down of Vivax's leader logic.
On January 28 2017 07:57 Tumblewood wrote:
can't even give you townie cred for winning an argument against vivax. come on, v, get a real reason to scumread rtani
His follow up also seems genuine to me. If he had entered the thread with that comment as scum, I would have expected him to use that as justification for having more suspicion/uncertainty on Vivax.
On January 28 2017 08:37 Tumblewood wrote:Show nested quote +On January 28 2017 08:07 Vivax wrote:On January 28 2017 07:57 Tumblewood wrote:
can't even give you townie cred for winning an argument against vivax. come on, v, get a real reason to scumread rtani Reading between the lines this means that you're fine with superbia and swika but not fine with me not being fine with rtanisoul? no, I think you may be even townier for being this bad but I also politely request you be less bad also I am just examining super and swika, and rtani to an extent, just now
|
On January 28 2017 09:35 Grackaroni wrote:I liked his confident (and correct) put down of Vivax's leader logic. Show nested quote +On January 28 2017 07:57 Tumblewood wrote:
can't even give you townie cred for winning an argument against vivax. come on, v, get a real reason to scumread rtani His follow up also seems genuine to me. If he had entered the thread with that comment as scum, I would have expected him to use that as justification for having more suspicion/uncertainty on Vivax. Show nested quote +On January 28 2017 08:37 Tumblewood wrote:On January 28 2017 08:07 Vivax wrote:On January 28 2017 07:57 Tumblewood wrote:
can't even give you townie cred for winning an argument against vivax. come on, v, get a real reason to scumread rtani Reading between the lines this means that you're fine with superbia and swika but not fine with me not being fine with rtanisoul? no, I think you may be even townier for being this bad but I also politely request you be less bad also I am just examining super and swika, and rtani to an extent, just now
This is really good Gracky. I think you can both go to town pile.
|
On January 28 2017 08:35 Tumblewood wrote:Show nested quote +On January 28 2017 00:42 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 23:56 RtaniSoul wrote:
mrt erased my post @.@
short version:
silverika lex has a townread on for the way he's responded to a few people, including sl (i'm deferring to him on that cause no real opinion), and i like super, so suggestion is:
RtaniSoul, silverika, Super
lex thought including tumble might give more insight on tumble's nominations (yes, that was the great townie test >>) idk personally how valuable a strat that is. my experience with resistance is pretty slight. but assuming he's right on silverika it would probably tell us something
random other bit, lex thinks sl may be town for *bad* reasons lol ^^ so he's in our slight column somewhere if we were keeping better track >> I like the above list and would easily approve it. Super is a townread and RtaniSoul is the leader, we know we are town so this give good info. ~SilverWolf77 not liking this justification at all. would've preferred a simple "I'm on it sooooo" to trusting rtani for being the leader. does not feel logicked out but does act like it was
would it have been better if he jsut RNGed it?
he put a town read of ours and us on the mission. if the mission were to be sabotaged we would instantly think its the leader who did so its basically win-win FOPOV
|
On January 28 2017 09:19 Grackaroni wrote:I'm going to explain why before I get hit with the burden of proof. 
*insert post about burden of proof here*
|
On January 28 2017 11:25 Silverika wrote:Show nested quote +On January 28 2017 08:35 Tumblewood wrote:On January 28 2017 00:42 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 23:56 RtaniSoul wrote:
mrt erased my post @.@
short version:
silverika lex has a townread on for the way he's responded to a few people, including sl (i'm deferring to him on that cause no real opinion), and i like super, so suggestion is:
RtaniSoul, silverika, Super
lex thought including tumble might give more insight on tumble's nominations (yes, that was the great townie test >>) idk personally how valuable a strat that is. my experience with resistance is pretty slight. but assuming he's right on silverika it would probably tell us something
random other bit, lex thinks sl may be town for *bad* reasons lol ^^ so he's in our slight column somewhere if we were keeping better track >> I like the above list and would easily approve it. Super is a townread and RtaniSoul is the leader, we know we are town so this give good info. ~SilverWolf77 not liking this justification at all. would've preferred a simple "I'm on it sooooo" to trusting rtani for being the leader. does not feel logicked out but does act like it was would it have been better if he jsut RNGed it? he put a town read of ours and us on the mission. if the mission were to be sabotaged we would instantly think its the leader who did so its basically win-win FOPOV
I understand your logic, and there's nothing inherently wrong with it... not sure it's wise to put so much faith in superbia this early though
then again I haven't filtered him at all yet sooo we'll be back after this commercial interruption
actually, a question: who would you put in the third slot in a you/super/??? team?
|
yeah I see no reason to TR superbia for what he's done this game... he's instituted some official unofficial rules, but that sort of stuff is NAI in my book. also he's been gone for the last 15 hours now out of ~30, so could you please explain (sw/ika), why you think he's town?
|
yeah we're probably rejecting this lol ><
though i don't actually see the problem with super spending a friday night out and then going to bed tumble xP it's more the cheerleader (at least for me) and i think lex is townreading a lot of people not on the team like tumble and possibly (not certain) grack
aaannnyyywwaaay
|
he keeps making me post like a little tina slave :/
"we should post...but i'm gonna go shower"
not a mindreader pfffttt
|
On January 28 2017 20:56 RtaniSoul wrote:
yeah we're probably rejecting this lol ><
though i don't actually see the problem with super spending a friday night out and then going to bed tumble xP it's more the cheerleader (at least for me) and i think lex is townreading a lot of people not on the team like tumble and possibly (not certain) grack
aaannnyyywwaaay
I'm not necessarily townreading grack >> he's making sense and I'm not used to him making sense so I have no idea what it means.
|
Oh so the votes will happen hidden? No matter, i approved the team anyway.
|
Tina is saying sharkie is mafia for being such a cheerleader.
I'm saying that if he is, the team is clean because he's so in-your-face with his support that it wouldn't make much sense for him to connect himself so much to the team if there's scum on it.
|
On January 28 2017 22:48 sharkie wrote:
Oh so the votes will happen hidden? No matter, i approved the team anyway.
do you even know what is going on this game?
could you explain why you like this team beyond the cursory?
|
I burst out laughing at most sharkie posts actually he's like an innocent child
|
ugh I don't TR anybody on this team (coming the closest on rtani but I really can't read rsoul). gonna reject and try again until further notice
|
On January 29 2017 01:37 Tumblewood wrote:
ugh I don't TR anybody on this team (coming the closest on rtani but I really can't read rsoul). gonna reject and try again until further notice
I actually don't like how all you've done is come into this thread and cast shade on everyone on the first mission. I consider this scummy because it's exactly what I did in my last game of this as scum because the first team was all town. You remind me of that plus the fact that you are over justifying your intent to reject it. You don't really have reasoning except you don't townread anyone but you also don't have reasons to scumread them. This is just wishy washy and scummy because like I said, if this is an all town team, you don't want it.
Even if the mission was sabotaged, we would get information from it but if we don't send it, where are we gonna be going forward? I would like to have some information, even if there is scum sent. If the mission passes, we just resend the same team and a mutually agree'd 4th member and continue from there.
How else do you expect to get information regarding who is scum and town since we can't lynch and discussion only gets us so far without mission passed or sabatoged. We could get some from approved or rejected if everyone wants to come in here and say if they approved or rejected and why but that really isn't as concrete as a sabatoged or passed mission would be.
~SilverWolf77
------
as for the town read on superbia, start from 125 and onward. he has been aggressive to start with and pushing early reads. not only that the reads and reasons that superbia has given match up with our own. not only that hes been pushing cut and dry ideas that will solve the game,
i mean ive been disuccing with SW and we are already ready to call the scum team: calix (HTS)/TW/sharkie (CH)
CH was already a scum read from early on and shrakie has done nothing to improve it
calix has been overly passive already and HTS has not done much before that. yes its her first game of resistance but i would be expecting a lot more from her already.
TW is explained via silverwolfs post above.
that being said, this is my day off so i will be spending it with silverwolf and might not be around
|
|
|
On January 28 2017 14:47 Tumblewood wrote:
yeah I see no reason to TR superbia for what he's done this game... he's instituted some official unofficial rules, but that sort of stuff is NAI in my book. also he's been gone for the last 15 hours now out of ~30, so could you please explain (sw/ika), why you think he's town?
Mafia
|
On January 28 2017 21:20 RtaniSoul wrote:Show nested quote +On January 28 2017 20:56 RtaniSoul wrote:
yeah we're probably rejecting this lol ><
though i don't actually see the problem with super spending a friday night out and then going to bed tumble xP it's more the cheerleader (at least for me) and i think lex is townreading a lot of people not on the team like tumble and possibly (not certain) grack
aaannnyyywwaaay I'm not necessarily townreading grack >> he's making sense and I'm not used to him making sense so I have no idea what it means.
Fun fact:
I have the lowest non-zero vote on mafia percentage of all recent mafia players at 1/9. My closest competition at the moment is Onegu, who put forth a valiant effort with a 0/7 showing.
|
On January 29 2017 03:10 Superbia wrote:
Town ^
Also I agree with this read.
The Ikawolf post was townie.
|
On January 29 2017 01:09 Tumblewood wrote:Show nested quote +On January 28 2017 22:48 sharkie wrote:
Oh so the votes will happen hidden? No matter, i approved the team anyway. do you even know what is going on this game? could you explain why you like this team beyond the cursory?
well in real life resistance I see who voted what
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
