EPTNewbie Student Mafia XXV - Page 4
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
| ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
On January 09 2017 04:12 beentheredonethat wrote: errrr im not the cop im vanilla town Get lynched. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
If he's town he needs a game ban after this for griefing and borderline game throwing. I have asked ME for reads twice now and he's ignored me. I say we lynch him after btdt. B0ston after that. If these 3 are the scumteam, I wouldn't be surprised. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
On January 09 2017 04:49 MichaelEhrmantraut wrote: Why have you been pressuring me for a read ? I don't understand it. I'll give you my read, when I have one. Instead go read the thread and look at people who claimed they had a read and haven't given one. You are actually behaving exactly like squishy when it comes to asking people for reads. Have you ever played forum mafia before? Asking for reads is a big part of the game and the fact that you don't like be asked and don't want to contribute to the game is either scum and/or someone who shouldn't be playing. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
| ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
On January 09 2017 05:41 MichaelEhrmantraut wrote: Well KSC hasn't given any reads. But I don't think he claimed anything, I skimmed through everyone's filters. Onegu actually said that he was going to defend SW as town ( and i thought he didn't ) but he actually did. So quite a bit of oversight from me. I didn't dodge the question, I just said I don't have concrete reads. And why is it necessary to have reads after the day 1 shit ? If anything it just confuses me. Like why did you not give an argument for why SW is town. or why did you match grack's stubbornness with your own. I am being blunt on the issue, this game is for noobs. Thanks for the support. Just because it's for noobs doesn't excuse not playing. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
On January 09 2017 05:26 beentheredonethat wrote: Also guys calling for bans for griefing: I genuinely thought it's a good idea and had no idea that Grack was the actual doctor. Keep in mind he completely unnecessary claimed Doc at a point where it was just dumb (or scum-motivated!) to do so. Which led me to the decision of counter-claiming because I thought: 1. If he's doctor, he's dead N1, so lynch D1 isn't bad 2. If he's not doctor, we got scum down I took a risk. It did not pay off. You can, as I said, continue to tilt which is going to be absolutely great for scum, or you can try to get people to talk and continue to find scum. Your choice. For your first point, there's no guarantee he'd be shot. He could be roleblocked and scum could shoot elsewhere looking for the other PR. You did their job for them by getting Grack killed if you are town which is crap play. No excuse since you aren't new to the game. It hurts town in every way. For your second, you didn't even scum read him. You could easily say you don't believe the claim and see how he reacts or you could let the situation be resolved by: a) nightkill confirming him as doctor-best move b) finding out who he's targeting at night and if they are alive next day c) seeing how long he lives himself | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
| ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
| ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
| ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
| ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
On January 09 2017 09:31 reps)squishy wrote: I cannot see him making that up if he were scum... I can. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
On January 09 2017 09:40 MichaelEhrmantraut wrote: That is irrelevant, I ask how do you know SW is town, you just claimed it. Don't put it back on me, I say we lynch ika this night. Then you can lynch me the next night. Fuck this guy. We are not lynching ika as long as I'm alive. I'll lynch you first. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
Have you seen all the BS he's spewing? I'm the doc, no I'm the cop, no I'm a VT, no I'm the cop, no I'm a VT, no I was roleblocked. Scum could easily hold back a roleblock and then claim it, trying to look town with it. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
| ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
Did scum also go for Vivax or did they mess up and not submit a kill? If scum is all new people or not active, that could be the case. I do find it odd that Vivax would be a scum kill given all of the people scumreading him but I guess it's possible they shot him as well. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
Vivax did vote for ME and KelsierSC, suspected darthfoley, Squishy as well. I'd need to filter dive to see if there is anything else there. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
| ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
At dr but later I'll filter dive and do a Town to scum list. | ||
|
SilverWolf77
United States114 Posts
Agrees with me on Vivax defense of others he doesn't have a read on being scummy.I want to see if he does any of his own reasoning on any reads instead of sheeping me but the fact that he's reading the situation the same as me is a plus. It doesn't matter that we were wrong. It matters if he's thinking along the lines of a town thought process. Says he believes Onegu's VT claim and questions him on his scumreads of Vivax and B0ston. OK, this is him trying to figure out Onegu which is good. Doesn't like Grack not willing to explain his townread on Vivax. Also, doesn't like Grack trying to cause conflict and making the thread hard to read or get reads. Also, doesn't like that he won't explain his townread on Vivax. This is all reasoning I agree with but he said it before me so this isn't sheeping but coming up with his own reasoning. Good. I don't like his sheeping btdt's case on B0ston however. He take's his vote off of his main scumread Grack to sheep onto btdt onto B0ston who he had previously had no read on. I think btdt's flip will help with B0ston and Reps read. I don't see either one of them as scum with him. Also, don't like Reps saying if someone comes up with a good argument on Grack, he'll revote. Why wait for someone else to give you a reason to vote before doing so? Very wishy washy here. Doesn't like btdt's sudden switch to Vivax after casing B0ston-I agree with not liking this so this is good for Reps. Votes Grack after the claim, cc fiasco. So do a lot of people so meh. I do like his further elaboration of why he thought Vivax defense of others was scummy. It was well thought out and easy to understand. His further explanation of Grack, B0ston, etc was fine but a little too much on theory. Still, fine though. His suspicion on Onegu wasn't bad. It was his own original thinking and it made sense. He didn't like Onegu voting B0ston after B0ston voted him and his general lack of presence in the thread and commenting on irrelevant things. This isn't bad. Leans town on btdt for the roleblock claim but later agrees with my saying it still could be scum and votes btdt. Meh. Further explains his Onegu scumread which is o.k. So overall, probably town, does sheep a little bit but overall has a town thought process on reads and does come up with some stuff of his own too. I really needed to do this because Squishy was one I was having trouble figuring out. | ||
| ||
