Newbie Student Mafia XXV - Page 10

On January 11 2017 10:35 Kmatt wrote:


Considering that he got replaced, I think it was just being super AFK. Granted Mafia can afford to sit back but I doubt that all three members have been silent.

On January 11 2017 10:49 Damdred wrote:
Yeah DF reaction to the lynch and his going about the lynch doesn't feel exactly right so far to me.

Me being off the lynch is interesting though. Need to look at votes, but the throw awayb is interesting there.

On January 11 2017 10:57 Damdred wrote:


If me is scum which is possible I don't think he's scum with sw necessarily.

It's possible, it's a distancing tactic but I don't think a newb would do it here.

No then again hunting just based on teams won't win is the game here as a don't have that info so is weigh both separately atm which I will do shortly.

On January 12 2017 02:10 Damdred wrote:
I saw someone mention silver earlier as scum (I think) Why exactly? I read his filter and theres some really good things in their that I coudl see coming from town more than scum.

Reactions to whats going on in the thread
Reads accurate to what hes been talking about
Actual progression on the reads, good pressure to his scum reads

I really liked his filter honestly. Definatly going in the town pile today. I kind of want to put onegu in that pile as well

On January 12 2017 02:33 Damdred wrote:


Whops well she ^_-

what do you think of silver?

On January 12 2017 09:04 ika42 wrote:
im gonna find the scum team post silver preposed cus im 100% banking on that now

On January 11 2017 10:08 SilverWolf77 wrote:
What do people say to Calix, darthfoley, Onegu scumteam?

On January 12 2017 09:06 Damdred wrote:


If you mean this. I am not sure tbh, why leave the vig alive in what is 100% mylo at this point?

On January 12 2017 09:07 Calix wrote:


This is a good point.

On January 12 2017 09:15 Damdred wrote:


What about why Vivax was killed then? You have him coming around on darth, he thinks onegu is town and he wasn't really scum reading Calix I believe at that point?

Right now gut feels like silver was killed cause he was the most town read person atm in the game.

On January 12 2017 09:21 Damdred wrote:
By oh its auto you mean onegu saying that right?

On January 12 2017 09:29 darthfoley wrote:


I think it's more likely that SW was killed because literally 0 people scum read her and she was active

On January 12 2017 09:26 Damdred wrote:


Would you really want to risk the game killing onegu today and him being town? Like I understand frustration with someone not really playing that much. But i'm not sure if him not necessarily playing in this situation is super indicative.

On January 12 2017 09:45 darthfoley wrote:
wait Vivax never reads Onegu as scum. He town leans him

On January 12 2017 09:52 Calix wrote:


Like it is possible that ika is scum given that he's just limped into the thread with shitty NKA and no backing but SW dying is definitely not a reason that factors into that.

On January 12 2017 10:01 Calix wrote:


Don't worry, I don't care to.

Your post is WIFOM since it basically says "I wouldn't have done XYZ as scum" which cannot be proven one way or the other.

Kindly weigh in on the rest of the discussion if you don't mind.

On January 12 2017 10:03 Calix wrote:


The levels of logical fallacy in this post are extremely high. My previous post stands and I'm not getting dragged into a discussion about NKA with a player who has yet to talk about anything substantial today.

On January 12 2017 10:09 Calix wrote:


Your blind copying of a single "hey guys do you think DF/ Calix/ Onegu are the scum team?" post which she never elaborated on has also been noted, my dude.

There is no way for you to know why she posted that from the thread. There is no reasoning to "sheep"

Explain please.