I feel like you just made a wall of text on every player in the game for no real reason and the majority of your scum leans are simply the unproductive ones. It just seems so out of place. Why the need for the summary?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 29 2016 15:04 GMT

#534

Your opinion on me shouldn't be anything other than null btw. I haven't done much but you should certainly agree that your NU reads are wishy washy useless crap and it is excellent to be called out for that when you yourself didn't even "realise".

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 29 2016 15:24 GMT

#538

I don't play at work, you're lucky I'm even posting anything right now and even this is tough. My "only content" so far is great and was posted on the train. It's quite easy to see I have a thought process and am following it up whenever my scum read posts (you).

I simply don't have time to read anything other than the latest posts till I get home.

Basically, I think your stances are poor. They are based on meta and/or some form of insubstantial tidbit. "This guy feels different," "Koshi is town for this but here's something I need answers for even though you're not scummy looking at all".

Your mindset just doesn't align with how I'd be thinking if I was thinking what you're thinking. You're questioning your town reads and aren't really concerned about your scum reads. Your only questions are really to your highest town read and have done not much to get any more information from your scum leans.

You want content but you rehash the game in a giant wall and expect people to do something. You want activity, you make activity by asking questions and pushing things. Not by idly commenting in a summary.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 29 2016 15:51 GMT

#548

I find it hard to believe that the discrepancy I've outlined has gone over your head. Your retort of mockery just furthers my conviction.

If I have to enlighten the dim witted then I shall. The discrepancy is quite clearly that the only questions you ask are targeted at your town reads, who you should be the least wary of, and none to your scum reads, who should naturally be the inverse.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 29 2016 17:41 GMT

#584

I'm gonna throw out some big time knowledge here.

+ Show Spoiler +

Koshi might be mafia.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 29 2016 23:07 GMT

#693

On November 30 2016 06:53 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

This is such a bad post.
First, his read was "minor scumlean for that, but I hope he steps up".
Second, he obviously won't think his NU read is scummy if he's town SINCE HE S TOWN.
Third, you've played enough to know that it's normal to tend to scumread people that scumread you.

First point isn't even a point, I clearly said I should be null and not a scum lean.

Second point, I never said it was scummy in this post. Your reading comprehension led to that but what it is saying is that Margarine is calling me a scum lean for not pointing out anything despite pointing out things that Margarine thinks before he/she thinks them.

Third, irrelevant and does not apply in the context of getting someone to do something productive that breaks them out of their mould by antagonising them slightly.

Either way, don't expect much from me. Voting me isn't going to make me magically more productive.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 00:23 GMT

#709

I didn't check the votes. I caught up and posted on the only relevant thing in my eyes.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 00:35 GMT

#710

Anyway, still not capable of being productive in the slightest, sorry. Just really not feeling it.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 07:29 GMT

#759

You shouldn't lynch me.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 08:38 GMT

#765

I'll try to try :/

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 09:08 GMT

#769

I mean are there even any cases for Margaret to chime in on? I don't think there are at all.

Onegu has done nothing, already been commented on in his list post.

I've done a mediocre amount, nothing has changed.

He town read nu afaik?

List post excessive

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 09:15 GMT

#774

No koshi? He's kind of sidelined a bit imo.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 09:41 GMT

#782

It's not really odd. You didn't push me for pushing Margaret which I thought was very weird. You completely ditched your tt vote based on nothing when he plays the same way he's playing now (afk) as both alignments. You were posting about afking a lot and returning to not really post any follow up to anything. Like Margaret said, jabbing from the sidelines.

Vote on me is whatever but it's incongruous with what you've been saying about me, "there's a reason hf might be town but it's not the speed of votes," "hf's posts sheeping me were cool and showed confidence in a read," "Margaret fell down a bit, maybe hf was right," and then you followed rels for some bull shit reason of "i didn't like that post." which is bs because like margarine is saying above in his new list "hf pushed me for correct things" so you and rels, your reasons for disliking me based on one post is bull shit when the person AGREES with what I've been saying about them. You post si much about how i could be town but then I'm second and even first in your list of mafia. It's crap.

I don't hate your nu post now. But he did play this way as town in a recent game but that was d3 onwards so I'm hesitant to just follow it.

Sl not pushing me and instead sheeping me is fucking weird when I'm pushing a new player.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 09:46 GMT

#788

That's my point. Literally what my post says. You weren't in the thread. You just sat back for a while and did nothing after people town read you. That's when my koshi could be mafia post was posted.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 09:49 GMT

#791

Entrance good, tt case good, good list post, sheep koshi.

Koshi afk, koshi only joins thread to say one liners, koshi drop tt when tt posted tripe, koshi switches on me based on nothing, koshi one liners are "yes he needs to comment". Koshi bad,koshi looks like mafia koshi now.

Koshi nu case not bad. Koshi okish.

Explain to me the reason why you just said I could be town to ls. You're playing saying crap like "i don't need to explain myself," but then holding all these reasons back l

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 09:52 GMT

#795

On November 30 2016 17:29 Koshi wrote:

Show nested quote +

second person who says this but I am pretty sure it is only Rels and I who voted him. And I pasted my voted after Rels to just give the wagon some more prominence.

It's all good.

HF is maybe not mafia but it is not because the wagon formed on him too quickly. Please disregard that idea.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

November 30 2016 09:53 GMT

#797

On November 30 2016 18:50 mahrgell wrote:
Anyway, to get back on track, let me repeat my theoretical question:

If you have 2 players, both highly suspicious, but certainly not both can be scum at the same time. Lynch one or not? As I said, in IRL mafia with 3 scum alive, I wouldn't lynch either but wait and see. How about online with the more town favored numbers?

Who cares if a towny dies, you get a lot of information out of it. It's pretty irrelevant who dies day 1. Potentially even bad if mafia die imo. Makes the game complacent and stale.