On September 15 2016 06:41 Holyflare wrote:
wow you're so easily convinced by the guy that has no opinion on the mafia team that has two people left, why couldn't nu decide a kill?

in every single scumteam I have played on the most experienced player decides the kill. shape in xxi, ve in newbies and vets, me in presidential, rels in 72h. who is the player in this game who lets nu decide the kill? certainly not you or damdred or palmar, almost definitely not vivax or super or grack-- no way nu decides the kill. plus I have an opinion on the mafia team, don't like how you feel the need to bring me down just to make your point. it does not in any way invalidate grack agreeing with me because first of all I'm right.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 14 2016 22:08 GMT

#2417

either way NU has been obv town all game and you are both scrubs for not seeing it

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 14 2016 22:27 GMT

#2419

who was a good kill?

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 14 2016 22:28 GMT

#2420

tbh it goes grack > NU > skynx and everyone else could reasonably be lynched today, ignoring the idiocy about the nk

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 15 2016 01:06 GMT

#2455

meh as long as you don't touch NU or grack or me I don't have any strong opinions on the lynch today. not yet, at least. everyone is all muddled in my head and I need to sort them out.
super and fuba are people I still don't want to lynch very much although I will not defend them. vivax is iffy but if he continues to lurk I am totally on board. he has a hard time tryharding as scum for more than a day or two as I know it. actually I can make conditions like this for everyone and it will be cool and rad. I will do that soon™

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 15 2016 01:13 GMT

#2456

On September 15 2016 10:01 Grackaroni wrote:
lol nope I just had a total epiphany between the minute I posted that and right now. Holyflare killed Skynx because in his mind he's going to look strange in LYLO for not dying even though nobody else is thinking that.

It makes way more sense than that same reasoning being applied to Vivax because I don't think Vivax would ever think that.

yeah vivax has an obvious excuse for surviving to LyLo which is that no scumteam ever has been afraid of him

conditions for lynch:
- Hf if he pushes a mislynch today (leaving this open-ended in case it is not vivax)
- vivax if he does not put a decent amount of effort in. decent to be determined when I see it
- Damdred if I don't want to lynch anyone else. or if he lurks most of the day. god he is such a plan b I want to lynch him more just thinking this
- super if I happen to not like him for whatever reason. I do not have a reason to hate him yet besides the calix bullshit from n1
- fuba if he doesn't do anything meaningful today. I will be lenient to an extent
- Palmar if he continues to be a useless shit or if he continues to call me a useless shit
- grack or NU if they literally claim scum

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 15 2016 01:15 GMT

#2457

although it supports what I want to believe grack I think your reasoning is getting a little shaky. overall I do not like the amount of NK wifom going on in the thread because there are 50000000 possibilities for why the hell mafia would kill Skynx and 49999999 of them are wrong

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 15 2016 04:04 GMT

#2479

On September 15 2016 12:53 Grackaroni wrote:
Let me ask you this, do you have any reason not to kill Palmar right now?

oo I can answer this
the answer is no
even if Palmar is a good player he has been a do-nothing this game, which makes him somewhat likely scum. Damdred falls into the same category except people have been on his case for quite a while instead of for 7 minutes

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 15 2016 14:23 GMT

#2503

On September 15 2016 19:38 Palmar wrote:
like I understand I need to reevaluate some parts of my reads at some point (maybe tw is town? Maybe hf is mafia?) but I feel like after 1 bad lynch and 1 good lynch we're ahead anyway so I just want to kill the scummiest player in the thread.

ok so you want to kill the scummiest player in thread and that doesn't involve getting good reads? and we weren't already killing the scummiest player in thread?
this isn't overtly scum but either way it makes 0 sense

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 15 2016 15:40 GMT

#2524

On September 16 2016 00:36 Superbia wrote:

Show nested quote +

I don't really read your posts that much tbh. As such, you're kinda calling yourself shit or mafia.

not at all

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 15 2016 15:41 GMT

#2527

On September 16 2016 00:40 Tumblewood wrote:

Show nested quote +

not at all

what he is saying that you also say is not what makes you shit or mafia. it is the fact you are saying what he says + the other stuff

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

September 15 2016 15:54 GMT

#2533

I think voting vivax is the best decision for now (no plans for EoD yet) because if he's town he comes back with fire and if he's mafia he has a higher chance of giving up seeing the vote count. don't get your hopes up too much, though, hf