[M][T] Haunted Mansion 3 - Page 10

Calix

3379 Posts

September 11 2016 20:38 GMT

#1604

Grack, do you have any reasoning on how HF being a retard with TT is something he would only do as mafia?

Because you say "his case is shit and he's pushing it way too hard" but when you get to the point where you say why it comes from scum!HF, you only use meta references which are terrible.

Do you have any reasoning for why it can't be town!HF tunneling?

Also I laugh at the line "TUMBLEWOOD IS THE ONLY PERSON BEING REASONABLE" in literally any context this game.

I appreciate you listing all of TW's terrible scum-reads though.

Calix

3379 Posts

September 11 2016 20:43 GMT

#1613

On September 12 2016 05:41 NeverUnlucky wrote:

Show nested quote +

Welcome back.

I'm back to scum-reading you.

Yeah, saying TW is reasonable is like saying Mother Teresa was a child molester.

Cool story.

Pretty sure Grack was taking the piss out of you with regards to pronouns, rofl.

Calix

3379 Posts

September 11 2016 20:51 GMT

#1622

On September 12 2016 05:47 Grackaroni wrote:

Show nested quote +

No those are my reasons I can't explain them any better than I have. I fully believe that HF was trying to make TT seem scummier than he was.

I don't even think it would have been a bad lynch if HF had just made a light push, asked some questions and then we end up shennanying on him at the end of the day. Which is what he was doing with Lunatic in the last game that he brought up to try to refute my argument.

Just wondering because when you were making other cases for why someone was town/ scum earlier on, the reasoning felt stronger than it did here and when I read your meta analysis in this case, I didn't get the same feeling.

The premise of "scum!HF was trying to paint TT as scummy" is not bad (as in, it is possible and makes sense if you read HF as mafia) but I'm not finding the evidence for this idea compelling enough to believe it is the case atm.

Calix

3379 Posts

September 11 2016 20:52 GMT

#1623

lol NU, you want to lynch me on my birthday? I see how it is.

Calix

3379 Posts

September 20 2016 21:09 GMT

#3026

I really liked the dead player mechanics. Games are always a lot more fun when you have someone to discuss it with

You can thank Skynx for the medic save, by the way.

Calix

3379 Posts

September 21 2016 07:10 GMT

#3060

On September 21 2016 07:56 Holyflare wrote:
My lynch was still objectively terrible and you should all feel bad.

Also I've read all the QTs now. Calix you played very well, probably got a bit too taken up with arguing with your town reads that were critical of you but I can't blame you because I do the exact same thing.

NU you played well, were a good voice of reason at most times but probably need to cut back on the scum slips and wifom.

Uh other people you need to stop signing up to games if you're willing to put 0 effort in. There was no real analysis of any post after day 2 save from me??? You all afkd and came back to do random shit tone reads and afk again. If you're not willing to commit to a full game then join obs qt because you sure did play like one.

But despite crappy afk you somehow managed to look towny day 1 to 2 so not too bad after all.

Yeah, my default reaction to being scum-read is to OMGUS...because obviously I am so townie that anyone scum-reading me must be doing it to discredit me or something. It's a bad habit of mine.

I think my TPR play was pretty crappy, actually. I wasn't around for most of Day 2/ Night 2 and I wouldn't have had a clue who the mafia would attack and I spent two days voting for Damdred. Although I think picking you on Night 2 was a good choice since you were the most proactive player.

I read the scum QT, not entirely sure why I was killed unless it was a standard "kill the towniest players" NK. (which would make sense)

Calix

3379 Posts

September 21 2016 07:13 GMT

#3061

I'm still not 100% accustomed to the site meta. I'm not much of a bussing person myself - it's not a standard site play from where I am from although distancing is very common - and the tendency to suddenly switch wagons at EOD is curious.

Prev 1 8 9 10 All

Please or register to reply.

[M][T] Haunted Mansion 3 - Page 10

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming