EPTIn any sense you still can't read me Sl and no idea why not (this case just me not posting much to go on).
[M][N] Onegu is the Best Host Mafia Part 2 - Page 12
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
In any sense you still can't read me Sl and no idea why not (this case just me not posting much to go on). | ||
|
disformation
Germany8352 Posts
On August 08 2016 03:26 nnn_thekushmountains wrote: <a href="/forum/viewpost.php?post_id=25925102" class="submessage" title="August 07 2016 14:17 EDT"><span class="post_date">1 minute ago</span> <span class="post_time"><!--post time needed here--></span></a> So our number is 17. Our order is this. 60/ 13 = 4 r 8. 0-3 = Shapelog. 4-7 = Stutters 8-11 = Tumblewood 12-15 = kush 16-19 = DISINFORMATION Sorry bro. ##VOTE DISINFORMATION ![[image loading]](https://i.imgflip.com/dnzt9.jpg) RNGesus giveth and he taketh away. On August 08 2016 05:20 Damdred wrote: I honestly kind of felt like i would love this game with the player list but i'm kind of depressed every time i enter into it, which is kinda meh hf won't even talk to me so far :'(. In any sense you still can't read me Sl and no idea why not (this case just me not posting much to go on). Isn't sad Damdred town Damdred, according to Art's flowchart? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
But on a serious note i kind of want to go back on my grac townread somewhat, he is kind of missing the punch that I saw in some of his town games and kind of just along for the ride. Not sure if its a scum read yet but not comfortable town reading him at this point. Also the strange fight with kush just idk strange. GB I like the thought process I see, but idk can't really tell, i sort of want to go town but want to see more opinons. At least I still have my tumble townread, an dno wi want to townread vivax. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
disformation
Germany8352 Posts
In the same vein: @ tumble: can you try another approach of explaining why you don't like HF's scum read on Luna? Cause I am not really seeing it. Going to look at Lunas town game. After that prolly going to look into kush and grack. | ||
|
disformation
Germany8352 Posts
| ||
|
Vivax
22424 Posts
On August 08 2016 00:36 Lunaticman wrote: Meh I think we should just keep lynching someone who always rolls mafia. Anyone got a good idea? That's not different from random lynching. On August 08 2016 02:00 nnn_thekushmountains wrote: @damdred about rng lynches. it's done for the lols not for the wins. Kind of sad that you actually felt the need to point out that rng lynches are suboptimal. @hf nice catch on that lunaticman post. When I read it, I kinda thought he always opens like that half roleplaying like? Still I agree with you that the post is suspect. @onegu the filters link to liquiddota... FIX IT... I laughed. I don't want to RNG lynch, I just believe treating anything said about it as alignment indicative is pointless, so it's not really desiderable to talk about it. It never ends up being random anyway. | ||
|
mderg
Germany1740 Posts
On August 08 2016 04:53 sicklucker wrote: if an rng day 1 lynch is sub optimal its not by much. acualy statistically its just as good as a day one lynch. the only thing that sucks about it is you have less to go on in day 2. I really hope nobody was being serious about an rng lynch. rng lynching is always bad even if it statistically has about the same chance of lynching scum. Don't really like damdred getting so serious about this topic. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9857 Posts
On August 08 2016 04:46 Vivax wrote: Did a quick ctrl-f of my name, no results so far. Is the theory that only scum would try to deflect attention to me being afk for 1 half of D1 a shit theory or a good theory? With the caveat that they'd have to be under pressure to do so, so is it safe to assume no scum so far was under pressure? Or only scum that doesn't know my meta? I like the way you think. Still shit theory because the game is like 4 pages long. It's pretty weak to try to direct the lynch on to somebody not posting when everyone else is equally guilty of that. | ||
|
disformation
Germany8352 Posts
On August 08 2016 05:34 disformation wrote: What do you think of HF's points on Luna? The points HF makes are decent and Luna's filter is meh. In the same vein: @ tumble: can you try another approach of explaining why you don't like HF's scum read on Luna? Cause I am not really seeing it. Going to look at Lunas town game. After that prolly going to look into kush and grack. To clarify the question @ tumble: you are basically telling HF to read between the lines. Can you spell out for what you are seeing there, I am bad at reading between lines. Otherwise I did a short look at Lunas town filter from 72h and it is somewhat offtopi,c but reads and feels more carefree than what he has done this game so far. So tonally there is a difference to this game imo. | ||
|
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On August 08 2016 05:34 disformation wrote: What do you think of HF's points on Luna? The points HF makes are decent and Luna's filter is meh. In the same vein: @ tumble: can you try another approach of explaining why you don't like HF's scum read on Luna? Cause I am not really seeing it. Going to look at Lunas town game. After that prolly going to look into kush and grack. HF didn't critically evaluate it, in the sense that he saw something and plugged it into a mental checklist of things scum do without thinking, "huh, maybe he's town and just acting weird" as if he's never played with scrub town before. just very much 'see the forest for the trees' | ||
|
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On August 08 2016 05:42 Grackaroni wrote: I like the way you think. Still shit theory because the game is like 4 pages long. It's pretty weak to try to direct the lynch on to somebody not posting when everyone else is equally guilty of that. guys we found the mafia | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9857 Posts
On August 08 2016 04:53 sicklucker wrote: if an rng day 1 lynch is sub optimal its not by much. acualy statistically its just as good as a day one lynch. the only thing that sucks about it is you have less to go on in day 2. ^ with the exception that I think you get plenty of information either way. you're never going to get an RNG wagon without detractors. | ||
|
disformation
Germany8352 Posts
On August 08 2016 05:43 Tumblewood wrote: HF didn't critically evaluate it, in the sense that he saw something and plugged it into a mental checklist of things scum do without thinking, "huh, maybe he's town and just acting weird" as if he's never played with scrub town before. just very much 'see the forest for the trees' Ah. So you are basically saying "this post post isn't great, but could very well be a newish town player post" whereas you think HF is going "not a very good post, 100% scum". Dunno I like luna's filter from 72h more. *scratches head* | ||
|
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
a) likes the way vivax thinks (lmao) b) echoing vivax but as if he's having a conversation with him and pointing to the rest of the thread and saying, "I know, right?" like, town tends to talk one-on-one with people only when they're arguing and it's unnatural to make that post. | ||
|
mderg
Germany1740 Posts
Explain pls. I don't see it at the moment. | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9857 Posts
| ||
|
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On August 08 2016 05:46 disformation wrote: Ah. So you are basically saying "this post post isn't great, but could very well be a newish town player post" whereas you think HF is going "not a very good post, 100% scum". Dunno I like luna's filter from 72h more. *scratches head* that's because the 72h filter was more than one post | ||
|
Grackaroni
United States9857 Posts
On August 08 2016 05:43 Tumblewood wrote: HF didn't critically evaluate it, in the sense that he saw something and plugged it into a mental checklist of things scum do without thinking, "huh, maybe he's town and just acting weird" as if he's never played with scrub town before. just very much 'see the forest for the trees' If HF sees something on a mental checklist of things scum do then of course he should push it. Why do you think he shouldn't? There's nothing redeeming in Lunatic's filter yet. | ||
|
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On August 08 2016 05:47 Grackaroni wrote: Ok so everybody seems to think that Kush is town and I am scum. 为什么? yeah basically can someone not wearing red-tinted glasses evaluate this reaction? I want to call it weird but I feel biased. | ||
| ||
