[M][N] Onegu is the Best Host Mafia Part 2 - Page 10

On August 14 2016 08:03 Holyflare wrote:
Conspiracy theory, disformation and lunatic are mafoa and he's hard bussing him with things that don't make any sense in the slightest.

On August 15 2016 08:31 Half the Sky wrote:


I really do not think you are giving them enough credit. Things they did right:

(1) Shapelog's blue snipe on Tumblewood was beautiful, Tumble was NKed solely because he was blue. He had a blue meta read on him. Couldn't determine investigation or protective but he knew he was blue.

(2) disformation broke meta by upping the activity massively. Maybe you never played with him but as mafia, he lurks hard and really falls off. He also poked holes in town's cases and put himself out there at greater risk to draw attention.

(3) Shapelog mixed his "quality" posts with just enough spam that enough people didn't want to read his posts or at least not critically. I was thinking enough people would catch on to him but this was not the case.

(4) Presence matters. Scum had ~50% of the total posts in this forum. They were able to influence the thread or dispel suspicions and even better disassociate from each other. (scum qt reference: shapelog was looking to divide the town days 2 and 3 to distance himself from the other two.)

No doubt town had their share of muckups but that blue snipe night one made a difference.

On August 15 2016 08:38 Grackaroni wrote:
(3) Shapelog mixed his "quality" posts with just enough spam that enough people didn't want to read his posts or at least not critically. I was thinking enough people would catch on to him but this was not the case.

Is this not standard Shapelog though? I didn't look at any games so I don't know.