Newbie Student Mafia XXII - Page 4

On August 08 2016 00:36 Lunaticman wrote:


Hahahaha, That is one loooong cup.

On August 08 2016 17:55 beentheredonethat wrote:
J Roc

His day 1 posting pattern is really weird. Lot's of fluff ("I am blue"), early, unreasoned vote on Stutters ("Happy Birthday")...



But he drops that style at the point where silentwarrior comes up with his Kelsier read.

I think anyone would agree with Silentwarrior there but what I find highly interesting is that J Roc completely disagrees with what Silent said about Kelsier. Why? I think silent's point there are really good. The thing is however that kelsier flipped town so there's no way that his is mafia soft defending an inactive teammate. But what I can see there is that J Roc is defending a vote on RB. RB would've been an easy mislynch for scum had he continued his spam.

Next thing that is weird is the vote on scott:


He says that RB's actions were null. He points out my post about RB, scumreading me for that post. Scott does the same, which implies that scott agrees with Roc at this point. But he completely disregards that. Instead he votes scott (who still has a weak position at this point because he comes off of the RB replacement and IMHO could've been an easy mislynch if mafia dared to push him) because he thinks that an observation from OUTSIDE THE GAME is alignment indicative? That does not make any sense to me, at all, and feels like scum seemingly having found a pain point that can be pushed. I am absolutely not liking that post.
Talking about a scott mislynch, it looks like that's how J Roc perceived it indeed:

I completely disagree with the scum read of Scott. Completely. The reasoning behind this read is simply bad and highly constructed. Yet he still stresses it, without any follow up, without bringing scott back to the thread's attention.

Instead, mderg defense:

At this point, many people want to lynch mderg. This can easily be scum, trying to gain town cred for voting outside the wagon.

"Look, I knew it."

His following reads during the night phase say Rels and Scott are scum, while he does not react to Moosy although being explicitely asked about Moosy - by Moosy. Also he engages in discussion with Moosy and starts agreeing on Moosy's vote analysis bullshit. While they had opposite opinions before, J Roc abandons his scott push at this point and follows Moosy. Why? But yeah, after that short excursion he goes back to scott.

Then he leaves completely:

That never happened.

Given that J Roc went for scott since D1 and never really stopped, I think he's pushing an agenda. It actually makes sense, scum needed only one more mislynch to win before moosy was modkilled. And pushing a player with two pages of filter that is being scumread already by others (-> Celestial, who has a high level of town cred) feels like the easy thing to do. In D1, it's safe to vote outside the town wagon. D2, the push can be kept up, and once D3 has started, things look good: thread put me under suspicion (first potential mislynch), and if that fails, there's always scott (second potential mislynch). We're lucky that Moosy was modkilled tbh.

I think J Roc is scum and we should vote him. If J Roc flips town which I find highly unlikely, I'd go for Scott. Or at least that's what I would do now. We're in a very good situation but we really need to carefully look into what we do next.

On August 08 2016 17:56 Skynx wrote:
Other voters have to explain themselves. Mafia didn't even bus lol this is such a wtf game. Silent and celest earned eternal towncred. I'm not scum.
Btdt needs a bit of a re-read but he's putting effort right now.
Comes down to Onegu vs Scott. Onegu has been tunneling Scott since min1 so I doubt he's the last one here.
Scott should be the vote for now. Time to re-read if he's town which would be unfortunate.

On August 10 2016 02:48 silentwarrior wrote:
But I am quite puzzled by last nights kill. There was a decent chance that skynx would be lynched, and there are a lot better options for night kill. I see 3 reasons for killing skyns.
1. The most obvious town players had townread the mafia
2. Skynx had scumread mafia and he wanted rid of him
3. He was trying to cast shade on the ones that skynx had scumread.

I don't think 2 is likely, it would be too suspicous tbh.
Can say as of right now, I consider only btdt as the only town apart from me. Rest I am unsure about.

On August 10 2016 04:04 silentwarrior wrote:


People do check dead peoples reads, that even happened in this game.

1 would matter a lot. For example I am seen as pretty town since, but can easily be wrong about the last mafia which is why I wasn't killed last night. I might have townread last mafia, in which case me living helps him more than dying.

You just used wifom about nk against scott, but say it dosen't matter? All I was trying to do by that post was show that nk could be done for multiple reasons. It was posted in response to you saying nk is a point against scott, which I think it's not.

On August 10 2016 05:56 Onegu wrote:



If you are town why dont you put the work in and help us figure out who is scum instead of asking these pointless questions.

On August 10 2016 06:07 scott31337 wrote:
I want a serious answer you and Celestial won't try to squirm out of after I'm dead. (You will, but I want it on paper)

Now i know you're Onegu I'm even more confident it's one of you two. Don't do jack all game until the fun occurs.

I can't outspam Celestial so why even try?

On August 10 2016 06:18 beentheredonethat wrote:
Im im the hospital. Daughter had accident. I concede the game im last scum.