Newbie Student Mafia XXII - Page 2

On August 02 2016 06:18 Stutters695 wrote:
Dear Grack/Silent: I'm not getting lynched, consider consolidating to someone who actually has a chance of getting lynched. Kthx

On August 02 2016 07:01 Grackaroni wrote:

I'm already voted for Mderg. Silent's post looks fine to me, what's your issue with it?

On August 02 2016 07:05 silentwarrior wrote:
Rels, what's your take on stutters and my case about him? I read yours on mderg and agree with most of what you wrote, but Stutter's is so blatantly mafia. Also, can others also comment on it?

On August 02 2016 07:45 -Celestial- wrote:



See above.

The votes went Scott on 3, then mderg hit 3, then you hit 3 when mderg switched and scott went to 2. Leaving mderg as the one as first in queue to be lynched. Now mderg is on 4.

That's the usual rule from when I used to play around here last year anyway.





Honestly I agree with you. Stutters' reasoning is highly questionable on that point.

I think silent is a better chance of hitting mafia though.

On August 02 2016 07:49 Stutters695 wrote:
Scum doesn't hammer themselves. Just saying.

On August 02 2016 09:50 -Celestial- wrote:


Hmm?

And where the hell have you been?

On August 02 2016 09:51 -Celestial- wrote:


Evidently, given the lack of voting. -_-

On August 02 2016 10:02 J Roc wrote:



Was a bad lynch, we should have lynched Scott.

On August 02 2016 10:03 -Celestial- wrote:



More or less his entire contribution to the game so far has been to focus mderg, a now flipped town, like a laser and get him lynched. So yes, I'd be an idiot not to be incredibly suspicious of him. Though how much of it is just because I'm still pissed off about the vote is questionable.

I'll have a better idea tomorrow. I'm going to re-read his filter then. If I was to take a more measured approach I might say that Rels' focus on mderg left him absolutely zero wriggle room when mderg flipped town. Which is an incredibly risky position to put yourself in as a mafia. Not to mention the thread didn't really need driving in that way if he was mafia because it was all still very up in the air. But then again he did leave himself a bit of an out when he said he might just be super tunneled.

On the balance of it he looks awful post-flip. But WIFOM strikes again.

I'm hoping to be able to put together a full post of my thoughts by tomorrow anyway. Honestly concerned I could well be dead by Day 2. And right now I've had a bit too much wine to be properly coherent for something like that.

On August 02 2016 10:12 J Roc wrote:



Wouldn't lynch you at this point. Why would I? Rels needs to be looked at much harder because I disagreed with him on mderg but Scott is scum.

On August 02 2016 10:17 J Roc wrote:



The fact that he just fucked off and let the train happen without doing anything else is really suspicious also.

On August 02 2016 05:26 Rels wrote:

This list that scott posted right as he replaced is exactly my list at this point
Welcome my town bro

On August 02 2016 10:23 -Celestial- wrote:


Er...I didn't change my vote.




Please don't do it like this. Come up with something better than a 'feeling' and explain how his actions were town.

Because this is almost literally what happened between a couple of people and prplhz in a previous game I played. In fact its weirding me out a bit where this is going right now. There was this big thing about how people were 'mind-melding' with him and heavily town reading him because of vague feelings; totally overlooking the fact that everything he had actually DONE amounted to jack all but being afk a bunch and then some harm to town. He turned out to be mafia.

On August 02 2016 10:32 J Roc wrote:



Like seriousness. Nothing race bannon did was alignment indicative, nothing. So you can't say he was low hanging fruit like he was confirmed town. He can play like that as either alignment.

On August 02 2016 10:36 -Celestial- wrote:



To be fair I don't think Moosy is necessarily implying Race was/scott is town. Race was low hanging fruit whichever alignment you were. If I was on his scum team and he was screwing about like that I'd be on that plynch train faster than you can say 'bus' because it was clear he wasn't going to be any help whichever alignment he was, and the free town points for a mafia kill would have been too much of a temptation to ignore.

On August 02 2016 10:38 J Roc wrote:



OK point taken. Still if I had to bet money I would bet on more scum on mderg than RB.

On August 02 2016 10:50 -Celestial- wrote:


I'm actually not too bothered about that specifically. My target was scummy enough to lynch but its not like I wasn't open to changing my mind, hell I explicitly asked for a convincing argument against mderg. My frustration mainly comes from that fact that as the deadline approached it became fairly blatant that there was no way mderg was going to flip mafia.

I mean, that accidental hammer on himself should have set EVERYONE'S alarm bells ringing.

Ultimately Rels came up with an argument that was okay at first glance but the more I looked at it and the more I looked at the way the thread was going as the deadline approached; something seemed off. And yet nobody else seemed to see it except Stutters.

For the record...I'll have to do a check on his filter but right now I'm feeling like I'm absolutely not interested in lynching Stutters D2 unless he suddenly goes horribly bad.





Unless I'm missing something then nobody? Final count was this:




I don't see any duplicates there. You going somewhere with this?