[M][N] H O L Y F * * * E mafia!! - Page 8

On May 28 2016 03:34 Tumblewood wrote:

Is this a joke

On May 28 2016 05:08 Tumblewood wrote:

I come and go as I please thank you very much
And no. That is definitely townie, but also his early early game interaction with HF is for sure not SvS. Also his content (like his dumb push on Palmar) is bad but in a scrub-town sort of way.

On May 28 2016 08:46 Damdred wrote:
Slow day so far nit nuch in the way if marv sadly meh.

On May 28 2016 13:09 Damdred wrote:
Probably scum I suppose alignment I addictive most of the time

On May 28 2016 17:30 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
If I'm wrong maybe ritoky slot would be my next guess.

On May 28 2016 18:43 sicklucker wrote:
hum i dont want to lynch marv acually. but he deserves it

On May 28 2016 18:47 sicklucker wrote:
also koshi looked like a pr. I was very worried I might have made him slip day 1 somewhere I forget. I kind of thought he was a powerrole personnaly and I probably would have nked him if I was mafia

+ Show Spoiler +

On May 28 2016 18:23 Palmar wrote:
that was a long ass post saying nothing but:

On May 28 2016 18:20 Palmar wrote:
right. If it wasn't obvious I wasn't really serious about killing marv because of the night kill.

However, his response to it has been uncharacteristic. I honestly have no idea what that means. I could see a world where marv is frustrated by being put under pressure for no good reason at all and just goes fuck it. However it would be a complete first for him that I remember as town.

I don't even know if I can draw the line from "uncharacteristic -> scum". But given how he has responded today, which was mostly very hostile, I also can't make the opposite conclusion.

Like if we assume marv is just normal marv, he must be mafia here, because he would never be this hostile, unproductive as town. I am of course speculating here, but my experience leads me to believe he would have ridiculed or ignored me and spent his time doing at least something useful, however little time that is.

In conclusion, I'm debating myself whether I should stay on lynching marv. I have absolutely 0 faith in the argument I voted him for earlier in the day (the NK one). It feels like a dick move to lynch him like this, because I mostly baited him into becoming mad. On the other hand, if I lose to a marv that doesn't play like a town marv I would be pretty furious at myself. Also, I genuinely believe what I said on day 1 about marv being tired of his meta, so technically maybe it's ok to lynch him as town this one time to open up his doors for being less productive than what we're used to.

I _think_ it's mechanically the right play to kill marv today. He hasn't given us any information and mostly just built a fort from where he calls people bad. No matter how you look at it, marv doesn't sound like town marv. But the problem is I'm not entirely sure he sounds like scum marv either.

In other news, Rels sheeping my fake and bad reasoning in the way he did looks really bad.