No it's not, I'm not voting LS in a million years. There is no benefit if he is scum, besides my worthless TR and getting yelled at for TMI
[M][N] H O L Y F * * * E mafia!! - Page 2
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
No it's not, I'm not voting LS in a million years. There is no benefit if he is scum, besides my worthless TR and getting yelled at for TMI | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
Anyone that thinks that emotion was faked can shut up | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On May 25 2016 04:09 ritoky wrote: Rito Mafia Check of Tumblewood: (The forgotten file) There exists no town purpose to this post. If you're going to attempt to apply pressure on to inactive players, why refer to them anonymously rather than call them out directly? This does not apply the desired pressure and I find it to be a waste of space and an easy post to make to blanket seem like you're doing something. I sincerely doubt any inactive player felt any heat to post more because of what you said here. OK, ritbot, Your case on me is mostly logical and not scummy, except this. This isn't like, "something else I thought was scummy and forgot," this is not even that bad but you're putting it in an unnecessarily negative light. This isn't a critical evaluation of anything, this is "didn't apply pressure" restated 3 times and it doesn't even make me scum. I think you started with the conclusion and fit the reasoning to that. Actually you know what this whole case sucks. "Posted justification for afkness = scum", "stopped trying to gain insight from the first 8 hours of the game = scum", "said he cared about something = scum", + Show Spoiler + oh no I'm becoming the real hypocritoky | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
You go HF BTW Super LS Koshi are all a million percent town, but please LS you're never getting an answer from Palmar | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
| ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
| ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On May 25 2016 08:01 ritoky wrote: Rito Response Analysis of Tumblewood: 1) I think your response is telling of a salty mafia who got caught OMGUSing. You can see your progression throughout this post: "Your case on me is mostly logical and not scummy" -> "Let me try to argue this" -> "Man I can't argue this" -> "Call it all shit" -> "OMGUS vote". At no point here do you consider the possibility that Rito Bot is of the town alignment simply because the case called you mafia. You had a conclusion in mind when you wrote this post. 2) Your post lacks any direct response of specificity as to why I am wrong and why your mindset and play is necessarily town. I clearly stated why you are mafia and you made a blanket statement about it all being shit rather than actually comprehend and explain the reasons why I view you as mafia. If you would like them again it is as follows - Shows tremendous interest in early discussion surrounding HF/Koshi/LS/Damdred/Kush -> leaves the thread -> discussion continues surrounding the issues -> returns to the thread making no comments or conclusions -> clearly did not care about read, which is distinctly different from other reads and displays a level of inconsistency. - Mafia tend to overexplain away inactivity, you overexplained inactivity. - Your interactions with LS read as pocketing, his town read of you was not warranted and your response was unwarranted and false. LS could very easily have a mafia motivation there and the specific interaction almost guarantees that 1 of you is mafia. - Non-town mindset displayed by an over-the-top reaction to a post by Superbia that was mildly town at best. - Anonymously calling out players who lack activity rather than directly pressuring them is pointless except for the fact that it doesn't directly link you to players by having their names in your post. Feel free to argue against those, as I feel all of your current responses lack an understanding of the accusations or you are simply in fact mafia. 3) Your town reads are junk. They are entirely responses to players calling you town and display that you are not approaching the game with a critical eye, but simply making friends. Mafia make friends, town find mafia. 1) but I could argue it. look, it has an argument. 2) this is also false. I said it was scummy because you're seeing facts and twisting them to fit your claim. 2.1) I was a scrub and thought HF was serious for far too long, and "HF are you serious was half of the questions I asked. 2.2) this is borderline NAI 2.3) if LS is pocketing someone, it's someone with actual clout (aka not me) and vice-versa. plus he did the same in tortoise as town. 2.4) over the top reaction, apparently: "that was real emotion [getting town points] and if you disagree you're wrong" 2.5) there were so many AFKs that no one would feel pressure even with names. 3) seriously? only LS was because of a TR. Your points all suck. I don't believe that your read is the result of seeing all these things because half of them are false and the other half don't make me scum. | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On May 25 2016 20:01 Rels wrote: This is a bad read. Scum defends lynchbait townie all the time for exactly this reason. If he defends me he doesn't get other people's town points. Source: this game He also did it as town in Tortoise. | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
| ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
| ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
Given everyone else's apparent soulreads it seems I should reconsider my read on Superbia. I could buy that this is kinda like Storm where he had 20+ pages of nothing. 6/10 would sheep Also rit might be town. Confirmation bias is a real thing to consider. Also he's kind of breaking the bot persona which could show that he actually cares, and it's a fine thing to hide behind as scum. | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
| ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
Rit Marv Damdred Palmar HF Super Town circle LS Koshi Sleeping encouraged. For now ##unvote | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On May 26 2016 01:56 nnn_thekushmountains wrote: Tumble try to convince me about l s. I'm not very good at reading him. He has that "lynchbaits stick together" mentality which is a town thing for him. Also he got/is pretty worked up about Palmar not answering him, a town sort of tunnel. | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On May 26 2016 01:59 Holyflare wrote: So ritoky is looking townier, he's in your scum pool. Superbia looks more like mafia and I'm casing the mafia guy and I'm in your scum pool. And your town read contains the guy who has called out everyone's alignment with far too much certainty and his case is a wall of text saying palmar is afk? Alsoooo, what is this bs people are spouting about marv? Sure, his post looked genuine but then, again, why are you blatantly ignoring that he said nothing about his work until now and saying he's town, no way anyone says that da fuk. -Rit is looking better but still definitely a decent lynch. - I don't care if you might be right I don't TR people just because they're casing someone scummy - yeah and they're both town - Marv is in my scum pool though. | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
| ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
| ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
ritoky's post on Rels makes him kinda town actually | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
On May 26 2016 06:10 LightningStrike wrote: You seriously not considering the fact that HF if scum fucking abandoned his team making harder for them to win which is a very dumb thing to do? Or Possibly HF doing this in confidence he can survive and look town for this? | ||
Tumblewood
United States3709 Posts
| ||
| ||