|
On May 08 2016 04:23 RiceyKins wrote:
Palmar seems to buddy up to people strangely based on what stage the game is in. He did it to Etellex as everybody was still kind of thinking about him as a primary lynch after D1, he's gone after killing without saying much more than he sounds hostile but also admits he hasn't read the thread then says Sandroba needs to be lynched for doing the exact same thing he's been doing.
It's also somewhat semantics but he says he THINKS marv is town which we all know is almost guaranteed at this point. I have no issues saying Marv is town at this point. scum worries about wording to not let slip that they have information we don't. Even after the fact it could be that he's still in that mindset and wont commit to knowing marv is town. Unless for some reason the vet decided not to claim and is letting Marv organize a lynch but I find that highly unlikely. You've called him confirmed town yourself but Palmar chooses to keep him at the same level as you JAT, he thinks you're both town.
also in the same post he says Sandroba would be the best lynch, votes for killing, and then says he has no information and has no opinion on me, sandroba(?), and Slam. Which again is odd. No opinion on somebody you strongly want to lynch.
There's other small stuff as well but yeah
That's all fine and dandy but nothing in this post answers my question.
|
there's nothing about Etellex that would convince me that somebody else is or isn't scum while based on what I just said alone I'd feel better about my read on you because he puts you with Marv.
|
On May 08 2016 04:35 RiceyKins wrote:
there's nothing about Etellex that would convince me that somebody else is or isn't scum while based on what I just said alone I'd feel better about my read on you because he puts you with Marv.
Why? And what is your read on me in the first place?
|
United States4714 Posts
I dont mind lynching sandroba. Someone can tell me if I am wrong but from my memory sand was always way more hardcore as town and didnt really like being mafia. I mean replacing in doing nothing then making the excuse that he forgot he was in the game feels like such bs. Who replaces and forgets in the span of less than a day.
Palmar if the correct lynch is sandroba why are you voting killing?
|
null, slightly townish and what do you mean why? I just told you.
|
And I am back,
Give me a min.
|
On May 08 2016 04:23 RiceyKins wrote:
Palmar seems to buddy up to people strangely based on what stage the game is in. He did it to Etellex as everybody was still kind of thinking about him as a primary lynch after D1, he's gone after killing without saying much more than he sounds hostile but also admits he hasn't read the thread then says Sandroba needs to be lynched for doing the exact same thing he's been doing.
It's also somewhat semantics but he says he THINKS marv is town which we all know is almost guaranteed at this point. I have no issues saying Marv is town at this point. scum worries about wording to not let slip that they have information we don't. Even after the fact it could be that he's still in that mindset and wont commit to knowing marv is town. Unless for some reason the vet decided not to claim and is letting Marv organize a lynch but I find that highly unlikely. You've called him confirmed town yourself but Palmar chooses to keep him at the same level as you JAT, he thinks you're both town.
also in the same post he says Sandroba would be the best lynch, votes for killing, and then says he has no information and has no opinion on me, sandroba(?), and Slam. Which again is odd. No opinion on somebody you strongly want to lynch.
There's other small stuff as well but yeah
I'm a straight shooter, I tell it like it is.
this guy might be mafia because the bolded is basically bullshit. Of course I have basically no opinion on DrP/Sand, they haven't posted at all.
On the other hand, the very fact that they haven't posted at all makes them the correct lynch. Not necessarily the lynch most likely to flip mafia, but it is the correct play in this situation.
|
On May 08 2016 04:40 RiceyKins wrote:
null, slightly townish and what do you mean why? I just told you.
Why does Palmars read on me influence yours? Do you think he wouldn't townread a fellow scummer like that or what?
|
On May 08 2016 04:40 Mig wrote:
I dont mind lynching sandroba. Someone can tell me if I am wrong but from my memory sand was always way more hardcore as town and didnt really like being mafia. I mean replacing in doing nothing then making the excuse that he forgot he was in the game feels like such bs. Who replaces and forgets in the span of less than a day.
Palmar if the correct lynch is sandroba why are you voting killing?
sandroba is technically the correct play.
I'm voting killing because I want to kill him.
|
On May 08 2016 04:40 Mig wrote:
I dont mind lynching sandroba. Someone can tell me if I am wrong but from my memory sand was always way more hardcore as town and didnt really like being mafia. I mean replacing in doing nothing then making the excuse that he forgot he was in the game feels like such bs. Who replaces and forgets in the span of less than a day.
Palmar if the correct lynch is sandroba why are you voting killing?
You are not wrong.
|
On May 08 2016 04:44 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On May 08 2016 04:40 RiceyKins wrote:
null, slightly townish and what do you mean why? I just told you. Why does Palmars read on me influence yours? Do you think he wouldn't townread a fellow scummer like that or what?
I'd say it's less likely when he's being careful not to give away that he knows Marv's.
|
also marv it's 100% on you if we lose this game. If I get lynched you need to have a scum team of 3 ready by the end of the night to make up for your bads.
|
United States4714 Posts
JAT thoughts on sandrova vs palmar for the lynch?
|
I have a question.
On May 08 2016 02:06 sandroba wrote:
Unfortunatelly won't be able to catch up today so I'll leave my vote on marv's wagon. I did a quick scam on palmar's filter and see no reason not to lynch him, so there is that aswell. Hope you guys get it right.
##vote Palmar
Sands vote right? Reasoning bold and +
On May 07 2016 05:58 sandroba wrote:
Hmm Mig raises a good point about JAT/ricey and JAT in general, but appears instead goes after tube. I see that he is the one who started the whole tube ordeal, and although in hindsight it's easy to disagree with it I don't think he is mafia the way he went about it. He seemed to be one of the few really trying to find a lynch late into day 1, while most others seemed like they didn't care. JAT and Palmar I see both gave excuses as to not being a presence in the thread, but it wouldn't suprise me if at least one of them was mafia. I would honestly clump marv together here but luckly the vet event saved me the trouble of having to think about it.
My town so far mig kush marv killing. I'm kinda starting to come around on ricey. He does sound a bit townie in some of his posts.
His read on me.
On May 07 2016 06:03 sandroba wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2016 05:53 Shapelog wrote:On May 07 2016 05:45 sandroba wrote:
So far on page 24 people I like as town are Killing and kush for sure. I kinda cheated ytd and read pages around ~38 too and I know marv claimed vet and there is no real reason I see to doubt it so there are these 3. People I particulartly don't like so far are shape, fazer and ricey. Mostly null on everyone else so far. ![[image loading]](http://27.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m00ubh4ngS1qjd1y3o3_500.gif) Can't wait for those juicy reasoning! What tipped me off was your entrance post. The other game I mostly ignored your posting because you were doing lenghy posts with a lot of fluf, but this game I'm reading them more carefully. So far you have a ton of useless posts with jokes, lists, useless commentary which I find quite similar to the game we played together wich you were scum. I'm gonna look into you town meta next to see what it looks like before I give my final veredict.
Does anyone else feel weird about this? Somethings feels off to me in this, yet I cannot firmly say what it is.
It is like he has a stronger read on me than palmar. It could just be him voting for realistic wagon, and like he says later:
On May 08 2016 02:08 sandroba wrote:
Also it looks like people that I am suspicious of are voting on the counter wagon so my vote feels even better.
@killing I think you are town and you should prob move your vote. Etellex dude looks like lynch bait.
BUt then, if you look back at the reasoning (the big quoted post) He was comeing about on Ricey, still sus. on fazer, and Town on Killing. Interpet what you want on Rice, but he makes it sound that he finds townie things in his latest posts.
So, wouldn't that mean only 1 person he is sus. of is voting the counter wagon as well?
|
On May 08 2016 04:52 Mig wrote:
JAT thoughts on sandrova vs palmar for the lynch?
They are both good lynches. Confirmed marv who has the best read on Palmar on this site is leading a lynch on Palmar. Reason enough to sheep.
Sandro is also really scummy though. Excuses and lurking is his mafia meta.
|
On May 08 2016 04:40 Mig wrote:
I dont mind lynching sandroba. Someone can tell me if I am wrong but from my memory sand was always way more hardcore as town and didnt really like being mafia. I mean replacing in doing nothing then making the excuse that he forgot he was in the game feels like such bs. Who replaces and forgets in the span of less than a day.
Palmar if the correct lynch is sandroba why are you voting killing?
good point
From my own mafia life w/ him (2 games)
As Vt, he made big posts and etc.
As blue (and coming back into the thread after not being there for about half the phase (storm)) when catching up, he made bigger posts then he is now and IIRC he was pressed for time (don't quote me on it tho)
No clue as mafia.
|
Stay the course. Too often when I feel this way I am right.
You fools remind me why I troll.
##Vote: Etellex
|
What's funny is a lot of people seem to agree with me but now they are sheeping the bandwagon on a strong player they don't recognize as having "done anything" when he actually has.
"What has he done slam?"
Oh STFU and get out. If I told you you would say that it didn't answer your question.
|
On May 08 2016 05:00 Alakaslam wrote:
Stay the course. Too often when I feel this way I am right.
You fools remind me why I troll.
##Vote: Etellex
Is the fact that I forgot you where even in the game, a troll play.
I think i might pay your filter a visit before I start on Etellex's. Lets see if you are just trying to get townread for not doing anything, which is the scum game you told me you were working/wanted towards when you coached me.
|
On May 08 2016 05:03 Shapelog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 08 2016 05:00 Alakaslam wrote:
Stay the course. Too often when I feel this way I am right.
You fools remind me why I troll.
##Vote: Etellex Is the fact that I forgot you where even in the game, a troll play. I think i might pay your filter a visit before I start on Etellex's. Lets see if you are just trying to get townread for not doing anything, which is the scum game you told me you were working/wanted towards when you coached me.
Legit, go ahead and check it out.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
