|
Yeah thanks Slam you did answer my question in the other posts.
I'm not sure about a Tube lynch. I see what you're saying but I'm not convinced that just because he's quick to label his town reads he's definitely scum. His reason for voting isn't too great and looking at the last thing he wrote, I have to head out for like 30~ minutes but did Marv ever actually say he thought I was town? I'm skimming but I don't see it.
On May 04 2016 22:04 Tubesock wrote:Show nested quote +On May 04 2016 21:55 marvellosity wrote:On May 04 2016 21:53 Killing wrote:
Marv, hope on the "isn't really great logical sense" train with me. We're gonna have a wild ride i might rather kill tubesock though but i don't know yet Go ahead. You've wasted how many pages talking about this thing that you already said you're not gunning for Ricey. You have not scum hunted at all. The one thing you did was ask about a question mark. Even that you said you thought he was town before and after.
talking about the bolded
|
On May 05 2016 00:52 Tubesock wrote:Show nested quote +On May 04 2016 20:40 marvellosity wrote:On May 04 2016 09:20 Tubesock wrote:On May 04 2016 03:39 marvellosity wrote:On May 04 2016 02:12 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:On May 04 2016 00:55 marvellosity wrote:On May 04 2016 00:53 RiceyKins wrote:
the way he said it made me think it was specific to Palmar. my mistake then Marv. so why did you use a question mark when you were talking about what shape said had you genuinely forgot who it was in the 50 posts the game has? could you not have checked if you weren't sure? etc<script id="gpt-impl-0.7793814496370671" src="http://partner.googleadservices.com/gpt/pubads_impl_85.js"></script> At first I was like damn marv's being perceptive. And then I was like ... really though? I would speak about what Shape said about Palmar with the same vagueness and uncertainty. Shape alluded to his last game with Palmar but included none of the specifics, as far as I remember. So I'm kinda sus of you for making such a big deal about it. no harm in seeing how it went, is there? Did it go anywhere? Did your opinion of Killing change at all after his response? i thought he was town before and i still do
ah ok I can't tell if you meant to say me but said Killing instead there but fair enough.
Kush if we're going to policy lynch I'd rather it be Dr.P I'll copy JAT a bit here is there any reason to lynch Palmar over DrP or any of the others who haven't given us a reason for their absence?
|
Kush what's difference with somebody getting replaced in D2 and Palmar becoming active N1/D2 considering you think he's telling the truth. Wouldn't it be better to keep Palmar?
I mean I see your point, maybe Palmar never becomes active, so we've lynched Dr.P and that's basically russian roulette given how many people haven't said anything and then we still have to deal with an inactive Palmar.
I guess it's just a difference in opinions I'd rather keep the guy who gave a reason for being away vs the one that hasn't.
|
##Vote: DrParnassus
Between DrP and Palmar I'd rather see what Palmar says when he's able to play vs the uncertainty of DrP showing up.
who knows maybe he'll come back if he's about to get lynched and we'll hear from him.
|
I'm catching up on the last 2~ pages I'd be ok with Fazer or Etellex as well. Etellex has had a long time to come up with something but seems afraid to post anything substantial and Fazer's posts on Killing and then his vote on Mig followed by
On May 04 2016 23:13 Fazers wrote:I want to lynch him possibly. Why do you guys assume I want to get this man killed?  Just doing what I can to contribute lol, now I look like a fool.
gives me mixed signals for what he's trying to accomplish.
|
I'd be happy with just knowing what you think about more people Etellex  In your opinion but I guess we wont get that today =/
|
I'm hesitating to vote on Etellex just because it seems like he isn't taking the time to write everything he's thinking =/ I feel like I'm missing large chunks of his reasoning and only seeing the end result of him not mentioning Kush at all and voting for Tube. bleh
|
##Unvote
##Vote: Etellex
oh well, here's hoping he is scum and didn't just fail to provide an explanation behind his actions because he wasn't comfortable doing so.
|
|
|
hmm well Etellex I'd really like to hear your reasoning between backing off Kush and voting for Tube. Especially just jumping on Mig's case without much/any reasoning from yourself. Basically just connect the dots between saying Kush was your top scum read and then saying you have no relevant information to post and voting Tubesock.
|
I want to know how he worked through his decisions. So far we have no idea what he thinks about anything. Not even why he actually voted for Tube. He hadn't said a word about Tube all game or anybody really under the guise of having nothing to add to the conversation which is BS. I want to know why he didn't try to push you.
|
does Marv normally contribute so little as town?
|
cause I'm having a hard time seeing what the rest of you are when you call him town.
On May 04 2016 00:55 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On May 04 2016 00:53 RiceyKins wrote:
the way he said it made me think it was specific to Palmar. my mistake then Marv. so why did you use a question mark when you were talking about what shape said had you genuinely forgot who it was in the 50 posts the game has? could you not have checked if you weren't sure? etc
not really alignment indicative but it was pretty bad. For somebody who talked about reading comprehension he didn't look back at something that was only 1 page back? Alright.
Distracts both Kush and Tube with something trivial and continues to not actually contribute by arguing with them for a bit. I dunno then calls me out on being mafia before voting for Tube because Tube calls him out (for a second time) for doing nothing before proceeding to go afk after placing his vote on Tube and doesn't come back till the lynch is over.
like... what?
|
haha well you're right there I suppose Kush.
|
well this is nice to come back to. I guess I was mostly wrong about you Marv my bad. 
|
On May 06 2016 21:15 Killing wrote:
I still have mostly the same reads. It's unfortunate that marv is BP because he was already obvious town. I think our lynches should be Ricey and Ettelex.
There's no way I can't think Ricey is mafia. I personally thought most of his d1 was garbage and I was the only vote on him. I'm not down with the re-reading thing but I remember a few towns saying that he was indeed scummy. I mean I have to think that if he was actually town than some mafia would just BW behind me to get him lynched as I kinda wanted to kill him before you guys just went ham on tubesock for no reason. Point being is that I don't understand why nobody kinda agreed with me and tried to kill ricey when a few people thought he was scummy. Especially considering i'm a new player, I think it'd be super easy to just jump on board on me considering some may think I have no idea what i'm doing although for the most part that's true.
Etellex's giant wall this day felt exactly like a post I wrote in my first scum game. It was like excuse, sorry, weak content. He's prob mafia too.
Dunno who the last one is.
Towns are:
Marv
Kush
Shape
Mig
Fuck that guy:
Palmar
So you think I'm mafia, but tried to get Etellex lynched and by virtue also tried to keep Tubesock alive and briefly mentioned I wasn't sure about lynching him because I didn't have a good read on Tube (thought he was ok but people were making good points about him)
On May 05 2016 00:40 RiceyKins wrote:Yeah thanks Slam you did answer my question in the other posts. I'm not sure about a Tube lynch. I see what you're saying but I'm not convinced that just because he's quick to label his town reads he's definitely scum. His reason for voting isn't too great and looking at the last thing he wrote, I have to head out for like 30~ minutes but did Marv ever actually say he thought I was town? I'm skimming but I don't see it. Show nested quote +On May 04 2016 22:04 Tubesock wrote:On May 04 2016 21:55 marvellosity wrote:On May 04 2016 21:53 Killing wrote:
Marv, hope on the "isn't really great logical sense" train with me. We're gonna have a wild ride i might rather kill tubesock though but i don't know yet Go ahead. You've wasted how many pages talking about this thing that you already said you're not gunning for Ricey. You have not scum hunted at all. The one thing you did was ask about a question mark. Even that you said you thought he was town before and after. talking about the bolded
and you're saying I'm a scum team with Etellex? I think you might be right that Etellex is scum but if you think I'm with him you're not looking at things properly. I could have stayed on Dr.P and have no reason to attempt to bus Etellex as supposed mafia.
Why would I try to save somebody who is now confirmed town but up for lynch D1 and nearly break the balance (if Slams vote counted Etellex would have been lynched, or if Tube voted to save himself). Logically it makes no sense.
|
I know you can infer both of us are scummy but you also have to realize it's absolutely ridiculous to assume we both are mafia given what I just said.
However you didn't just call both of us scummy. You called us both Mafia. Meaning you're convinced both of us are in fact mafia and not just town playing scummy / poorly.
|
I'm not sure really JAT, It's possible the mafia just weren't there and we lynched a fellow VT on our own. Till Marv claimed I had actually read back on it and thought he was mafia but that's pretty impossible now. I need to take another look at Slam, I felt ok-ish with him during the first 48~ hours but I'm honestly not sure what to think of him right now and need to go back and make sure. Etellex though I believe is very scummy, probably mafia.so out of the people on Tube I think you're right, it's either 1 or none imo. Though I'm leaning way more towards the 1
|
if Marv is right and Palmar is mafia, and if I'm right and Etellex is, and the last one is between Killing / Fazers and Sandro then they really were just not there and didn't really have a hand in it. Aside from Etellex anyway.
|
and admittedly I'm probably biased on Killing cause he's tunneled me for like 2 days and when I know I'm not mafia it makes me think he's done nothing at all. lol so it might just be Fazers / Sandro.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
