TL Mafia LXXIV: Storm Mafia 3 - Page 13

On March 25 2016 06:35 Superbia wrote:
Tiiiiired.

Did not like slam's reaction. Felt like forced emotional tailored to withhold info (we still don't know that much about his role, though I believe he dropped the hint that he has multiple shots?). Was expecting more info. Also no idea why he's reacting that strongly if he's town.

JAT is.. okay? I feel conflicted. On the one hand I like his aggression and pro-activeness. On the other I don't really like the direction he's taking it in. I feel like this is more his town game than his mafia however (i.e. I think we approach the game differently as town). Kind of town-lean for now.

I feel like a lot (1-2) of people are taking my stance on Koshi as me reading him mafia. That is incorrect. I have a town lean on Koshi.

Also some other stuff but I forgot. Around to chill and talk for a bit when gf is not distracting me. Maybe will get some dive-energy later.

On March 29 2016 22:44 Shapelog wrote:

That could actually be the case tbh. Mainly just because the post itself seems super weird. I still find it weird though from a read progression point of view but maybe i am not taking into consideration of something like this.

Eh, i think i am just going to move on from it for now and read filters. Class is about to come up though so idk when i get to post anything about it.

On March 25 2016 08:05 Superbia wrote:
Yeah. Picture someone pretty damn tired sitting behind a computer going to sleep in the next x0 minutes. That's me. I really don't want to read through posts so I'm going to play from the top of my head (that's what I generally like to do either way).

Now let's revisit the gumshoe thing, all right? I had like this nice timeline but it's whatever.

Do you think there was scum pushing on gumshoe in hindsight? Before slam shot?

On March 25 2016 08:08 Superbia wrote:
All right, now that I have both your attention I want to continue the train of thought.

Everyone kind of agrees that gumshoe's post was somewhat scummy, and that it was an easy scum-push regardless of alignment. So I'm inclined to believe that -a- scum would pile on the push. Agreed?

On March 25 2016 08:31 Koshi wrote:

100% certain mafia.

On March 25 2016 08:31 Superbia wrote:


Naw. What about tumblewood or rso?

On March 29 2016 22:58 VayneAuthority wrote:
yes thats correct, its unlikely tumble is mafia aka why I look bad atm.

the most important question is JAT is bad this game or was he purposely misconstruing koshi's meta and other bad posts because mafia?

On March 25 2016 16:33 sandroba wrote:
Read up till gumshoe died so far. It looks like slam shot him adn koshi somehow arrives at the conclusion it was ritoky. Kinda weird from koshi, but it seems like an honest mistake, not a fake dumb tell. Ritoky btw looks like is very likely townie, not really because of his vt gambit (which could be done by mafia if they had the roles early), but because of how much he believes his plan was the shit. As town we tend to think our dumb plan is so great imo =P.
Weird that slam didn't make any coments after the shot if it was him (which I'm inclined to believe). If I had to decide right here I'd say slam is scum.

On March 25 2016 16:52 sandroba wrote:
I like rels, he looks a lot like last game where he was townie. I see the point on slam being town for revealing he was about to shoot and not trying to incriminate anyone. The weird think is that he said he was going to think about it and the shot went off and he apparently wasn't here anymore. Gotta wait till I read what slam has to say.
Also leaning town on kurumi a bit. Null on rso. I think rels has the wrong idea on ritoky and rso is spreading doubt a bit. Dunno. I find her hard to read.

On March 29 2016 23:01 Rels wrote:

Reading Koshi's filter before EOD2, do you think think JAT pushing him makes sense or not ?
JAT changed his mind after EOD2. Do you see a difference between Koshi's posting before EOD2 and after it ? Do you think JAT changing his mind is logical ?

On March 29 2016 23:07 Shapelog wrote:
>_<

On March 25 2016 19:32 sandroba wrote:
Besides that rsoul thing I find jat quite towny, he posted/questioned some of the things I was thinking. Shape, who I was unsure about in the beggining also seems quite towny. People I don't like as town so far:

rsoul - not much follow up or questioning in her posts, still hung up on this ritoky business and also calls shape scum. Her reasoning on ritoky was that it didn't seem genuine and it his plan would never achieve nothing. W/E townie do random things, mafia rarelly does so, and mafia never tries to uncover blues like that, it's retarded. Half the townies would probably not even recognize the vehicle and then mafia would have to shoot into a big pool of people either way. Not a mafia plan and the way he felt it was so great and defended his own plan kind of proud of himself means town. Also he posted more stuff which if you cared to read are pretty townie. Other person she says may be mafia is shapelog who is one of my strongest town reads atm. And she never talks about the whole Slam deal, she doesn't talk about it seems unfased by it and doesn't seem to care what slam's alignment is. She simply ignored the event and derived some koshi superficial read from it like it meant nothing. So rsoul being terribly wrong and ignoring stuff that points to town on people means she is probably mafia.

tumblewood - he seems disconnected from the game making superficial reads. Nothing screams scum in his posting besides maybe the certainty slam is town as I mentioned previously. Not really much to say about him besides nothing he has posted so far makes me feel he is town and some of it make me feel he might be mafia.

slam - I'm back and forth on this, but his reaction does seem exagerated and over the top and his lack of explanation is disturbing to say the least.



ls and vivax kind of dropped off my town circle for a bit since vivax had a nice burst then felt like he did enough and ls is being kind of useless lately. Not sure I can read him well, I had him as town earlier but now I'm unsure.

kurumi I think is probably town. Wouldn't lynch today anyway. VA OWS and Tube, besides not posting much don't jump me as scum. Stutters and TT pretty much gave up on reading, wouldn't be surprised if at least one of them is scum.

So my prefered lynch is rsoul, but I can see lynching slam if he stays bitchy and doesn't start to provide us with answers.

On March 25 2016 21:49 ObiWanShinobi wrote:


Just sandroba.
I've got a bunch of experience with sandroba and iirc he's completely useless as mafia - he posts very little and the posts he does make are easily recognized as illogical and bad. He is far and away stronger as town.

On March 25 2016 22:13 Superbia wrote:
I liked that tumble claimed scum right before the game began and then disappeared for 20 hours.

On March 29 2016 23:16 Vivax wrote:
nah man OWS is town and sandroba is probably mafia, easy as that.

Solution can easily be the nulls from VAs list with exception of LS.

On March 25 2016 23:05 rsoultin wrote:
quite frankly, y'all are wasting time even discussing me today ^^

and sand is probably town, which is good i suppose but also makes his read on me especially annoying given it consists of

- her scumread she should be reading town (i'm gonna laugh so hard at you scrubs when i'm dead and rit wins the game)
and
- she didn't react to slam (??? um, what?)

like i know you think i'm the scum god after carnival, sandy, but really? lol >< that's pretty pathetic

like, seriously, i really want to lynch scum!rit here or at the very least have someone actually discuss with me why i'm wrong (so i can show you the light >>)...also down for lynching tumble or shape...wouldn't protest slam

the reason i was asking him about his role is it seemed like he couldn't change his shot once submitted given his posting...and that seemed like a 3rd party type role to me rather than a town one cause what sort of bastard host locks in your shot on d1? i honestly don't think he's scum either, cause the enthusiasm resembled more his play in greymist's game lol >< which was what i was referring to in my first reads post

if he's 3rd party (which seems likely given this "i don't know") bit coupled with his other posts, he's not a bad lynch either

i'd prefer scum though

can we lynch rit now? :/

On March 25 2016 23:12 rsoultin wrote:
okay, so, legitimately, i am not getting lynched today unless this is the worst, most inactive town ever

not gonna happen

so every single one of you voting me i want a list of at least two other people you think are scum, and why you're reading ritoky/shape/tumble town (if you even are)

^^ at least do me the courtesy of acknowledging that i could be town here so that we actually have a chance in hell of nailing scum today

On March 25 2016 23:19 rsoultin wrote:


nope it didn't

shape's posting in general just rubs me the wrong way and of all the people reading me scum, his seemed the most contrived (and yes, i'm looking for scum on my wagon, cause duh ^^)

sandy i know is paranoid of me
i'm shit at reading va but i know he could think that as town so whatever
rit obv is going to vote me but this just makes him more scum tbh lol >< i'm pretty sure he's the one who said that my scumplay is characterized by being passive

i really can't recall who else was pushing this but you

which reminds me! what is this pressure bs anyway? like it's definitely not to get me posting, but it doesn't sound like you scumread me either @.@

On March 25 2016 23:32 Superbia wrote:


Something.

In fact, if you're town, from your standpoint something has already been accomplished by me. You're now reading one of the persons who joined the train on you as scum.

On March 29 2016 23:28 Shapelog wrote:

I think she is scum because of how day 1 she litterly just scum read everyone for little or no reasoning and when she did give reasoning it was a bit lackluster IMO. She also is trolling us IMO with her role at this point.



I guess i have to now wait till day time to see anything about a item too.

Idk maybe i am tunneled vision. But she really does seem scummy as hell to me.

On March 25 2016 23:34 rsoultin wrote:


-squints at-

like, real talk, boyo. i find you hard to read. you gonna help me out or just be snotty? i really resent this assertion people are making that i'm doing nothing; if i were doing nothing i sure as hell wouldn't be the leading wagon right now lol ><