Newbie Student Mafia XX - Page 4

Kuragari42

United States346 Posts

April 14 2016 07:12 GMT

#1062

On April 14 2016 16:06 Kuragari42 wrote:

Yeah, Gosse pointed it out right at flip. And that's the point.

Scum (art): 5 votes
Town (Goss): me, art

Race didn't vote.

If me and race were both town then the 2 scum on art could have switched and mislynched. Race wasn't there so he screwed his team over.

Knew that wasn't right. Shaperape back at it again.

Kuragari42

United States346 Posts

April 14 2016 19:49 GMT

#1070

On April 14 2016 20:40 Race Bannon wrote:
I'm here. . We need to lynch Kura.
Goss checked the right people, crumbed inconspicuously, played accordingly so that was exemplary cop play; voting in favor of art regardless was a calculated move, probably instructed by art himself: it's now him vs me and he just needs 1 person to believe he's a dumbass newbtown trying to geronimo Goss' lynch through by himself like a boss, which his excuse of both cases had seemed scummy would indicate.

Look at my past games. You will see that I am indeed "dumbass newbtown" and that I also "geronimo" lynches (my off wagon votes on who I believed to be scum in Cell is a good example).

Kuragari42

United States346 Posts

April 14 2016 20:04 GMT

#1071

On April 15 2016 00:27 Tumblewood wrote:
Why would Goss's case seem scummy, Kura?
If you're still here

The timing of the crumbs. I don't understand why someone would wait so long to do it. And his whole "why would I CC if I was mafia".

Those coupled with his lacking reading comprehension, his scum case on RB, and his short filter (lots of 1 liners/questions). I was forced to skim art's bc it was longer and I ran out of time.

Kuragari42

United States346 Posts

April 15 2016 21:35 GMT

#1091

On April 16 2016 06:19 DoYouHas wrote:

Show nested quote +

Hard to get motivated to post when the reasoning for Kura is so straightforward and if we get it wrong the game is over. I'm completely with you on upping the activity level post lynch though. That is, unless you have some stuff to talk about while we wait.

How is the reasoning for voting me straightforward? All I've seen for arguments for voting me:

1.) "RB can't be scum with Artanis because art scum pushed him so hard from the beginning."

2.) "Kura voted town Goss despite art's bad claim."

and

3.) Inactivity.

The first point is bad because despite art scum reading him most of the game he never actually tried to get race lynched. He always brought up someone else before a race lynch ie "Let's lynch GB and RB. GB first then RB." (paraphrasing obv). There was never any actual danger of RB being lynched as far as I can tell.

The second point.. yes, art's claim was bad but I was stressed out due to my lack of time and the fact that I had to choose between 2 of my scum reads. If I had an extra hour or so I'd probably voted differently but idk.

The third point is NAI especially considering Spika's flip.

I AM NOT SCUM.

Kuragari42

United States346 Posts

April 15 2016 21:44 GMT

#1093

I've said from the beginning that I thought RB was town so having to look for scummy shit in his filter was difficult but here it goes..

1.) He understands why Art is mafia but avoids holding himself to the lynch and instead wants GB and Art to "duke it out some more". (Post #608)

2.) He town reads Art for "Too scum to be scum" and forms his scum team around pretty weak reasons. (Post #778)

3.) He has voted off-wagon twice and held his vote on the most important lynch. In race's own words, "a calculated move" to avoid being tied to a mislynch. Idk why he decided to abandon his team on day 3. My guess is he thought the art wagon would steamroll on without any countervotes.

Kuragari42

United States346 Posts

April 15 2016 21:47 GMT

#1094

On April 16 2016 06:42 DoYouHas wrote:
But he didn't drop RB at all after GB died. He was still as aggressive in trying to get RB lynched once GB was out of the way. He got lynched as the result of a redcheck. He couldn't have planned for that.

He could have realized he was redchecked/(that Gosse was making a decent case against him) and thought it would look good for race if he continued to push him.

And was race actually in any danger of being lynched? I never saw that as being the case.

Kuragari42

United States346 Posts

April 15 2016 22:10 GMT

#1096

C'mon guys, look at the votes! There has been extremely little argument against my lynch! The reasons for voting me are NAI or PoE because there is no consideration that Art would "bus" his teammate. Artanis is a veteran (and from what I've heard, skilled) player. I'd think that he would know how to throw suspicion off of his scum buddy.