Team Melee Mini Mafia VI: Newbies and Vets - Page 89

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

March 04 2016 13:30 GMT

#1761

He was wrong about Kush, I'm not disputing that. I'm not even saying that the things he said make kush mafia. If you read that page I told you to go read, you see that I even say as much TO sandroba AT THE TIME. My point is that SANDROBA as a player BELIEVES what he's saying. He physically CANNOT believe what he's saying if he's mafia man, it's impossible because he would KNOW Kush is town. Could it be fake enthusiasm and skillful post-play to make it seem like he genuinely is reading kush's filter and trying to convince me of something that he's noticed? Sure I guess, but that's simply not the vibe I got from it and I'm particularly qualified to comment on it because I was personally there active at the time. It was genuine, I could feel the lightbulbs going off.

So no, not "fuck me". You can disbelieve if you want, and I obviously can't make you make the right call. But I can implore you, and I can plead with you, and I can vote for the mafia. That's all I can do in the end.

But don't just AFK, we were given the game when Damdred modkilled himself and Kush fucked us out of it when he modkilled himself. WE GOTTA TAKE THE POWA BACK!

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

March 04 2016 13:31 GMT

#1762

Felkyr

United States135 Posts

March 04 2016 16:45 GMT

#1763

Based on the fact that we can still suspect Sandroba despite effort in the game AND busing Dam/TheCow, I realized that it is totally not correct to give FF and Sent a free pass. Although they had some interactions with Dam/TheCow that would be pretty hard busing if they're both scum, besides that they have done basically nothing this game. Their filter definitely looks worse. The reasons why they are scum from D1 are still all valid, and after EOD day one, they have both gone back to doing nothing. I feel like they are riding out the ML and using other people's defense (like Shape) to quietly avoid coming into the spotlights again.

As pointed out by TT:

On March 03 2016 13:36 Tictock wrote:

Show nested quote +

You could be right actually, UN is just sitting on the sidelines. Clearly reading the game yet not really doing anything.

On the other hand he just pointed me in the direction of an amazing song list.

It's anyone's guess.

This is important. Sent is very well aware of everything that is happening, but is currently not contributing at all. Contrariwise, both Qob and Tumble have made dumb-tells regarding the Damdred/TT claiming situation (which I agree could be fake):

+ Show Spoiler +

On March 04 2016 12:36 Koshi wrote:

Show nested quote +

What about this dumbtell?

On March 03 2016 23:13 qob wrote:

Show nested quote +

i dont know what JK means, nor do i know what okekkkkkkkk means.

Point being, Sent is here but hasn't done anything, like most of the game. Interestingly, he didn't believe TT's claim at first, and tried to propose that Damdred was a green who fakeclaimed:

On March 03 2016 10:55 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

Show nested quote +

If TT is right then the fakeclaim is a green.

On March 03 2016 11:52 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

Show nested quote +

Still have no idea if it's TT or Damdy tbh.

His second to last post is from more than 24h ago:

On March 03 2016 13:39 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
Until then, gonna read some filters and go find a scum.

His last post:

On March 03 2016 13:46 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
I agree with the paranoia. I don't think it's scum play. It actually reminds me a lot of yamato's town play.

So Sent doesn't think Sandroba is scum. Sent, who do you think is scum?

FF, on the other hand, also while doing not much, has very opportunistically jumped on the Sandroba wagon. His reason? Qob's filter is toxic. While I have typed the same thing in Koshi and my QT, I think this was a bit too easy.

On March 04 2016 11:25 Fecalfeast wrote:
So why doesn't everyone put which team they think is the most likely to be mafia in the thread?

Team Innocent - qob is acting like a standoffish prick this game, has been 'tunneled' if you can call it a tunnel on my team for bad reasons. He was called out for scumreading a joke post and vehemently denied that he had done such a thing rather than admit that he misunderstood the post, or simply hadn't read the list of teams. I think qob has shown that his main focus is not to find scum but to cause a disturbance in thread whenever he can.

Wow, qob, if your tactic was to make people irritated just by reading your filter it worked on me

My point: if we can suspect Sandroba despite his Dam/TheCow pushing, then we can definitely suspect FF/Sent. And they don't look good.

##unvote
##vote Team Anal Prolapse

qob

84 Posts

March 04 2016 16:47 GMT

#1764

On March 04 2016 21:42 Koshi wrote:
Can you give me a real reason why sandroba is town VE? There are a couple good reasons why he is mafia in the thread.

That Kush read kinda felt like it was something sandroba had in his backpocket. It was too certain and too big to be real. But then again, I might be tunneled.

You are voting pure by PoE? Because there are a ton of reasons why fefe/sent are town.

im not one to really defend others, but since sandroba is my partner, I told him i thought kush was town before he gave a read. He was susp of them before but i believe i calmed their suspicions.

qob

84 Posts

March 04 2016 16:48 GMT

#1765

If Anal Prolapse is town im gonna kick myself for not trusting my gut.

but lets not be hasty here, im waiting for sandroba rn.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

March 04 2016 18:06 GMT

#1766

I've actually talked to FF in the QT but I'm starting to have second thoughts about sandroba.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 04 2016 19:21 GMT

#1767

Really what it comes down to is everytime I read a post by VE I think he sounds townie. Him defending me here does not mean he is auto town, because he knows I would know it's him if he said he thought I was mafia. But what it comes down to is the way he is arguing all game feels really townie and I think I'll have to go with my gut.
The logic says FF/Sent are unlikely mafia, but their behavior does not. FF only ever posts anything when his ass is on the line. He just went and agreed with some case on my team, saying that qob is rash thus mafia, without even comenting on me who has been posting non stop this game and should have made my alignment very clear. Now that he sees the tides are turning Sent just pops in saying they are willing to reconsider and probably vote for VE. I don't get the same townie tone I get form VE at all when I read FF's posts.
Considering you guys think it's possible somehow for me to have bussed damdred in the way it happened day 1, it should be even easier for mafia to do what Damdred and FF/Sent did to each other. I've commented on how fake sounding and shallow were the explanations they gave for voting each other and that's likely mafia's ultimate sin: when they bus they are a bit afraid of exposing their partner true colors for everyone to read.
I'll go with my gut on this one and change my vote to team anal.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 04 2016 19:26 GMT

#1768

More importantly I would rather lose to a VE that made me feel he is townie all game, than to an FF that I felt was scummy all game, never put any time into it, and I let slide for BS explanations.

Felkyr

United States135 Posts

March 04 2016 19:28 GMT

#1769

Nice summary/rephrasing of my post. =D

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 04 2016 19:30 GMT

#1770

On March 05 2016 04:28 Felkyr wrote:
Nice summary/rephrasing of my post. =D

Dunno if you will believe me, but I didn't even read your post.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

March 04 2016 19:38 GMT

#1771

I see no way Felkoshi are scum. Felkyr, being a new player, is not going to have such strong reads unless they're real; if this is the product of koshi coaching, he wouldn't be teaching felkyr how to make these reads but how to pretend to be town. For me, it's between sand/qob and fefe/sent. I want to see some more development before I make a decision, but I'm very confident it's between those two teams.

Tumblewood

United States3709 Posts

March 04 2016 19:42 GMT

#1772

On March 05 2016 04:26 sandroba wrote:
More importantly I would rather lose to a VE that made me feel he is townie all game, than to an FF that I felt was scummy all game, never put any time into it, and I let slide for BS explanations.

This is not a justification. The important thing is not 'what will make you feel better if you're wrong' but 'which one is right'. And if VE has felt townie all game and fefe scummy, why are you even considering voting VE?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 04 2016 19:46 GMT

#1773

I believe I explained that already Tumble. And I'm voting on the one I think is right and on the one who will make me feel better if I'm wrong. And to me it is a good justification when you aren't 100% sure.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 04 2016 19:48 GMT

#1774

It would be like EXTREMELLY annoying to let town self implode and give the game away in a silver platter to team cownadow + team anal prolapse, who have both done nothing at all this game to earn it.

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

March 04 2016 20:06 GMT

#1775

Oh god damn it i have to do shit again?

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

March 04 2016 20:10 GMT

#1776

I already lied to my buddy about putting time in once i guess today is as good a day as any. Deadline isn't today is it?

Hapahauli

United States9305 Posts

March 04 2016 21:26 GMT

#1777

Day Three Vote Count

Team Anal Prolapse (3): Team Official Mafia Gauntlet for Underachieving Scum, Team Koshi, Team Innocent
Team Innocent (1): Team Anal Prolapse, ~~Team Koshi~~
Team Official Mafia Gauntlet for Underachieving Scum (0): ~~Team Innocent~~
Team Koshi (0): ~~Team Innocent~~

Currently Team Anal Prolapse is slated to be lynched.

The cycle ends on Sunday, Mar 06 1:00am GMT (GMT+00:00) in . Voting is mandatory.