|
On March 01 2016 08:11 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On March 01 2016 08:06 TheCow wrote:
Team Anal Prolapse and Team Fairly Odd Couple are my current pool. I kinda get your read on FF's team, but what about Marv's team is making you think they are scum? Also what do you think about Sandroba's read on you? And what does it suggest about his alignment? First one is in regards to your opening post. Show nested quote +On March 01 2016 05:39 sandroba wrote:
His post sounds fake as shit. Says he can't understand the "philosophy" of the thread (w/e that means) and it's mostly filler discussion right when the game is starting to pick up, and his post itselft is filler with no reasoning for anything or any new ideas. The comentary on the meta ignores the fact we are questioning the player who made said meta and dismisses it for no reason. Pretty much as generic filler fake post as you can get. Doesn't sound like a townie interested in people's alignments at all. Show nested quote +On March 01 2016 06:13 sandroba wrote:
Quite an arduous job to read without the filter function, but from the town game I read from him his tone is more inquisitive / tentative / hedging his bets as opposed to more assertive in his mafia game.
I gather that Cow and qop played together a bit so Cow sheeping qop's sentinel read does not look as fake as I had thoght. Still, his overall tone looks more in line with his mafia game.
On March 01 2016 08:15 TheCow wrote:
sandroba did not understand the point of my post and voted for me. qob feels town to me, and because I know how to read him, I am reading the slot as town.
sandroba himself is scummy for reasons I implied earlier.
|
On March 02 2016 05:42 Damdred wrote:
I've been reading while I do my chores around the house rip married life.
A few more thoughts,
1) If kush is scum he has pocketed me so hard. I've developed the palmar syndrome I just can't help but ignore people who have started to town read me.
* While I think my initial thought was clearly towny, I am not sure it deserves such a staunch defense especially since I've been afk. Call it a hedge if you want but I do like kush.
2) Koshi and Marv are both town I think its pretty obvious the activity the bad manners. It makes the game slightly easier that I can trust Marv and koshi I believe.
3) Sandriba/qob are town. I think the pointed posts and sand actually playing make that easy.
4) My most controversial read is I think that ve has a very high chance of flipping town. This is a tonal read, how he approached the game even if he is wrong. I do like him for town.
Since I know I'm town
Leaves me with tt, rels and ff.
I think this is a good pie place to start with, honestly I think sent and ff should be the first lynch today. The activity and lack of anything I think shows to a scum mindset.
I think rels group is the second, rels scum reads don't make a lot of sense to an extent and he's not being the prescrbse that I think he would generally be.
Tt I likes several of his posts and his tone felt right to me early,
Now any questions?
Damdy I don't hate your reads. Can you be more specific as to why sent/FF should be the lynch? "The activity and lack of anything I think shows to a scum mindset." I don't think that shows a scum mindset in particular, that could be explained by many other factors.
|
|
|
Felkyr I feel better about cownado's lynch. If you don't hate that lynch I ask if you would be so kind to leave your vote there.
|
I went to the trouble to read sentinel's filter again and honestly there is nothing there that makes me think he is mafia and a few things that make me think he is town. Damdy's FF theory is all fine and dandy, but honestly it is just a theory that COULD explain FF's inactivity, not a reason to vote someone Sent's vote on him wasn't oportunistic at all, he was simply aplying the metrics damdy himself told us he used to find mafia. The few posts FF does have do not look like a mafia saving face.
Cow in the other hand the few posts he does have DO look like he is trying to save face. And damdy's posts do not convince me in the slightest he is town, on the contrary, it looks to me he is trying to say the things we want to hear (his thoughts on his reads are very superfical and his reasoning is very shallow) and go for the easy target FF.
I really think we are making a mistake if we let this one slide, I don't think we can expect day 1 to get better than this.
|
If you claim what blue you are and there are no CCs I'll happily lynch someone else instead, prefereably TT.
|
On March 02 2016 08:14 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
@sandroba what's your reasons for townreading sent?
Mostly tone and the absence of reasons for reading him mafia. Must say I'm not 100% confortable with FF's posts.
|
I would like to know your role. If I was mafia about to get lynched I would claim blue for sure.
If it is indeed the case you are blue I think is very likely TT is mafia. He was defending thecow with very shody reasoning, even though he just found out thecow answered a question he made him at the very beggining.
In TT's mind cow was townie even though he never answered something he directly asked him and TT never bothered to follow up on it. After I pointed out the answer, which in my mind points towards scum, TT's response is "wut LOL answer still townie.". Smells of TMI.
Not taking into account the wall of shit he posted earlier.
|
On March 02 2016 08:30 VisceraEyes wrote:
Where did TT defend Cowthing? Did that happen?
Basically filter him an you see he assumes cow is newbie townie in all of his posts.
|
Nevermind TT, I just reread his filter and I'm back to being unsure on him. His cow comments can be interpreted as him being on the fence, but having a town lean on damdy, so it could make sense.
Please explain to me the case on Rels.
|
Honestly rels' filter looks super townie. I'd rather lynch sent and FF than him.
|
On March 02 2016 08:57 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On March 02 2016 08:49 sandroba wrote:
Nevermind TT, I just reread his filter and I'm back to being unsure on him. His cow comments can be interpreted as him being on the fence, but having a town lean on damdy, so it could make sense.
Please explain to me the case on Rels. Basically it's OMGUS from me, he's accusing me of everything he's doing, only he's maliciously misrepresenting my actions in this game which is worse. He doesn't care about the lynch, he spent the entirety of today trying to get a lynch on me. I mean, obviously you don't know I'm town but I do. That he's wrong doesn't make him mafia. That he doesn't care if he's wrong or right is what I'm seeing, he's just pushing me to push me, and it doesn't matter what I say or do. But maybe it always feels that way to the guy getting pushed.
I don't think that is unreasonable of him. You and bum are not exactly shitting town rainbows. If it was between your team and his I would vote your team all day tbh.
|
On March 02 2016 09:00 marvellosity wrote:
This has all gone a bit wrong. Ff making me unsure if I was right not to vote him, but I can't really explain why. Otherwise um. Only got tt's weird sand read and I'm not sure that's enough
Yep got the same feeling about FF =/
|
Thinking about my convo with damdred in the very beginning it's kinda ironic it has come down to this.
|
qob I'm as clueless as the next guy, do w/e you please with our vote.
|
On March 02 2016 09:09 VisceraEyes wrote:Show nested quote +On March 02 2016 09:00 sandroba wrote:On March 02 2016 08:57 VisceraEyes wrote:On March 02 2016 08:49 sandroba wrote:
Nevermind TT, I just reread his filter and I'm back to being unsure on him. His cow comments can be interpreted as him being on the fence, but having a town lean on damdy, so it could make sense.
Please explain to me the case on Rels. Basically it's OMGUS from me, he's accusing me of everything he's doing, only he's maliciously misrepresenting my actions in this game which is worse. He doesn't care about the lynch, he spent the entirety of today trying to get a lynch on me. I mean, obviously you don't know I'm town but I do. That he's wrong doesn't make him mafia. That he doesn't care if he's wrong or right is what I'm seeing, he's just pushing me to push me, and it doesn't matter what I say or do. But maybe it always feels that way to the guy getting pushed. I don't think that is unreasonable of him. You and bum are not exactly shitting town rainbows. If it was between your team and his I would vote your team all day tbh. omg I missed this post. Between RELS team and mine? You'd lynch MY slot over RELS slot? Lord give me the strength....
I'll probably ask qob to do it for me. And I would look away.
|
If he thought damdred/cow would end up being lynched I think he would prefer his vote was in the opposite wagon. Anyway I'm not confident on him being mafia. I'm kinda clueless tbh, All I got is some town reads.
|
Like I could see a close vote between team blahvacado and team prolapse, but this jat wagon makes no sense to me at all. Rels filter looks solid and race's filter looks okay. So what if the dude is afk near the deadline. Many people were afk during other times, I don't think that's a good enough reason.
|
On March 02 2016 09:41 Fecalfeast wrote:
How about everyone who's here posts the reason they are voting for the team they are voting for so there is at least some info pre-flip.
Sentinel seemed more confident in rels' alignment than I was on top of the weird drunk post. From my persepctive of only having read the last 12 hours in 2 hours that team is the best shot.
I'm lynching you for lack of a better option, like not being sure on team blahvacado and because qob wants to know if he is the boss. Also I get a weird feeling in some of your posts like you are gloating or something, dunno, just feels a bit mafia-y. I admit it's kinda random.
|
On March 02 2016 09:50 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
marv that is a cowardly vote.
It's weird but he is possibly the only one voting scum today.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
