IMO it was weaker because of it. I already mentioned how Valdi "not scumhunting" wasn't that much of an indicator when few people were actually scumhunting at that point

keanuisgod

271 Posts

February 15 2016 04:12 GMT

#584

On February 15 2016 08:38 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:

Show nested quote +

He was active and not scumhunting, which makes him scummier than people who were inactive and not scumhunting.

Perhaps, but not enough for me to be sure he was scum.

On February 15 2016 08:40 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
Last game, shapelog, aka keanu, IMO played one of the best scumgames I've ever seen. Keep that in mind.

I don't think it's fair for you to base your possible scumread on me on this kind of meta and smurfhunting.

keanuisgod

271 Posts

February 15 2016 04:16 GMT

#585

Anyways, right now I think Warty is the remaining scum. I don't really buy the "In the first 12 hours I was really into the game having fun, but then I suddenly got work and decided to actively post that I'm not reading filters nor the thread and don't give a shit" excuse.
Like, being heavily active on (early) D1 but declining activity and "care" for the game as it goes on is something I've only seen scum do, and "ragequitting" townies do. Warty definitely doesn't fall in the 2nd category.
If we also go by the "being active and not scumhunting" metric, he's #1 in that aspect

Garga's attitude on D2 felt townie, specially his gradual increase in suspicion on me (I understand the "chainsaw defense" thing and waffle on Warty and how that could have been seen by a town Gargy, specially if Warty is scum).

robik is townier I guess because Warty is more likely scum, because this would be one hell of a bus if not, because he seemed to make sense after getting off my back, and he shows he cares about the game (the most out of the people in question above at least).
His suspicion on me I think makes sense if he wasn't part of the thread and didn't have any back-and-forth with me. Some of my posts, standing alone without any context may scream "lol scum", but if you are in the thread interacting with me I think I can prove my towniness enough. After interacting with me robik changed his mind ala saitama, so that makes me feel better about him.

NNN is the "default townie" so far and leading force against Valdi since N1, so yeah no suspicions there.

keanuisgod

271 Posts

February 15 2016 04:23 GMT

#587

On February 15 2016 13:20 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:

Show nested quote +

OK, you weren't sure he was scum. You were more sure of Warty being scum?

At the point where I nearly panicked near the deadline yes. Up until like 1h before deadline I wasn't sure anybody was scum yet (couldn't finish rereading the thread either)

And why isn't it fair? It's not fair for you as scum you mean?

It's not fair as town for you to read me as scum based on smurfhunting and meta in the way you posted. I thought you took the previous hint I mentioned to robik at some point

keanuisgod

271 Posts

February 15 2016 04:24 GMT

#588

EBWOP: It's not fair (for me as town) for you to read me as scum based on smurfhunting and meta in the way you posted

keanuisgod

271 Posts

February 15 2016 04:33 GMT

#590

On February 13 2016 10:30 keanuisgod wrote:

Show nested quote +

What makes you believe I implied kush was scum? I implied kush's smurfhunting abilities were bad
Might as well come forth with that, in the sense that I don't want NNN to believe I'm 100% someone and then make decisions off me based on that when it (may) not be true at all.
Hope hosts don't smite me