EPTNew Smurf Mini Mafia - Page 20
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Wartrukk
152 Posts
| ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
| ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
On February 13 2016 09:07 Iwasrobik wrote: Either call me scum or don't. If you do, explain why I posted these as scum. This kind of attacks don't help solve the game. I won't call you anything until you've finished reading the thread and doing what you are going to do As for the specific comment, it makes it seem like you know more than you should. At least considering this is your first "real" entrance into the game, so things being "obvious" and "I would have raged if X had died" feel totally out of place. | ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
On February 13 2016 09:06 Wartrukk wrote: So on first read I hate gargamel and want him to be died. He quite obviously cares less about this game than I do and that's just fucked I had a townread on him for some reason reading the thread. Let's see why. On February 10 2016 12:26 GargamelxD wrote: cant really take any posts seriously so far, no analysis possible becouse it still seems like standard banter I first had a scumread for this post. On February 11 2016 15:57 GargamelxD wrote: he could be SL maybe, either that or ls either way i think goldrom is VA and i want to kill him with fire ##Vote 77Goldrom Oh yeah, he was one of the first to take a firm stance for the lynch. Town points. On February 11 2016 21:45 GargamelxD wrote: i dont see any issues with unholy as he just postponed his actual play which i also did, and his entrance wasnt as awkward as roms. he actually took interest into what was happening and gave a bit of his opinion on smurf hunting. in rom you have a guy who apologizes for being late, claims his role, asks about the latest news and in the next post acts like he doesnt care. Not scumreading me when I was an easy ML. + Having strong opinions in his few posts. Not confirmed town but likely IMO. | ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
On February 13 2016 09:12 keanuisgod wrote: I won't call you anything until you've finished reading the thread and doing what you are going to do As for the specific comment, it makes it seem like you know more than you should. At least considering this is your first "real" entrance into the game, so things being "obvious" and "I would have raged if X had died" feel totally out of place. Finished reading the game a while ago, when I made my list. Now I'm on a comp though. | ||
|
Wartrukk
152 Posts
| ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
| ||
|
Wartrukk
152 Posts
On February 13 2016 09:20 keanuisgod wrote: Well, he hasn't put his vote on Valdi after straight up calling him scum so I think we know where this is going Yeah but I want more stuff to read now | ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
On February 13 2016 09:18 Wartrukk wrote: I'll buy that. Valdiano kinda won me over when he was posting because it was content for me to read. robik do you think valdiano is the most likely scum now or is your top scummer still keanu? Need to read keanu's filter before deciding this. | ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
Well, you can still answer my question about Bhaal from the previous night. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt for the whole "acting like you don't give a shit" thing from late-D1 for now, at least until D2 consolidates with Gargal/robik/Valdi showing up (I'm very interested to see what happens with these 3 this day) | ||
|
Wartrukk
152 Posts
On February 12 2016 10:03 keanuisgod wrote: It's really nice to come back to activity 1-2 hours before the lynch and shout how the "wagon looks like trash" isn't it? It's also really nice to vote right at the last moment to someone who is OBVIOUSLY not getting lynched and making no effort to try to get him lynched It also isn't suspicious at all to vote someone completely unrelated to the lynch and wait until the last second (when you KNOW your vote doesn't count and thus you can't be held accountable for anything) by just saying "I have real reasons but am still busy" Anyways, we know Bhaal is town now, so please explain your read on him. These are your only posts about him Why exactly was he in your "leanscum" pile? What does the "lying LS" thing have to do with anything? Did you even pay attention to my case on him and the later change of heart of many people in the thread about him? leanscum for roleplaying and parroting what wa already said in the earlygame. lying LS means I was so sure it was LS and that he was lying which is, IMO pretty scummy. I did not pay attention to any of those things at that time. | ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
| ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
On February 13 2016 09:33 nnn_thekushmountains wrote: robik why is keanu scum? I didn't notice anything scummy about him. I LOST MY POST EXPLAINING WHY AND I FUCKING HAVE TO RETYPE IT AND I HAVE TO GO SOON | ||
|
nnn_thekushmountains
1501 Posts
On February 13 2016 09:49 Iwasrobik wrote: I LOST MY POST EXPLAINING WHY AND I FUCKING HAVE TO RETYPE IT AND I HAVE TO GO SOON i dont need a wot | ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
His early game. Almost only jokes, which is only a smaaaaall scum indicator. Scum indicator nonetheless 'cause stuff was happening, namely kush publicly saying he was smurfhunting (small town indicator for driving discussion + being in the spotlight) and wartruk attacking him for that (good town indicator for attacking the loudest guy in the thread). Even if you disagree with my conclusions, the info was there to make serious posts. But kaenu made jokes AND these two posts: On February 10 2016 10:57 keanuisgod wrote: Okay, the bubblegum is gone (srs), so let's get to it!  I can see trying to out smurfs as a "Palmar-like" plan. After all, meta analysis is a (useful) tool town uses pretty often, and to do that you need to know who you are talking to. For example, if you can figure out an inactive lurker is actually a vet, you'd likely change your stance on him, comparing to you not knowing who he is. These kind of plans aren't usually "scummy" nor "townie" (though there are some exceptions); they just are, specially in games with special characteristics that allow these kind of plans to emerge (like themed games) Though I guess it kind of fights against the fun of this kind of game (i.e nobody knowing each other at all throughout all game, allowing shenanigans to happen). Anyways, this seems like usual D1 shitfest OMGUSing, which is pretty neutral shit (i.e not scummy nor townie). Nothing was said in this post. It's only fluff that appears townie, at a time when kaenu probably felt the need to post something serious but didn't want to take position. On February 10 2016 12:01 keanuisgod wrote: Considering NNN's recent attempts at smurf-hunting it does seem like it won't produce many useful results, thus allowing scum to smurfhunt on their own in their QT, but confusing the heck out of town (and most likely NNN if he acts on said "smurf reads") And this post, which call kush scum without calling him scum for an extremely bad reason. Joking around when he could have try to solve the game + even his serious posts are non-commital => scum indicator. His case on LS + Show Spoiler + On February 11 2016 09:32 keanuisgod wrote: I'm not sure if posts like this show a poor lost townie out of his depth, or scum faking being "innocent and naive" to forgo posting actual content. I'll just be straight with my suspicions here: Bhaal came to the thread roleplaying in a fun and seemingly confident manner, but as soon as he stopped roleplaying he turned into a mess: This post is ripe with excuses ("I sometimes can't read into properly when I'm tired") and all the smileys lke ">.<" and ">.>" which serve little purpose other than appear like an innocent playful townie. It also shows an unnatural fear to respond a normal question saita asked him (like saita asked everybody). The reaction is odd and scummy The response he gave saita about why he pressured me doesn't seem to make much sense with what he actually posted. When I noticed his question, I got the feeling he wanted me to post some content and reads. His response seemed to confirm this, with the "Fair enough Mortal" (making it seem he was satisfied with my response). But later in his response to saita he says he only asked my for my reads so he could piggybank them since he "can't read properly when he's tired"? But what about "being the analytical God when it comes to find scum"? Was that a lie that only existed in "role-playing-mode"? I said previously this scumread was flimsy BECAUSE of the roleplay. Maybe, for some reason, town Bhaal got all confident and funny and stuff and acted like that, but when he stopped roleplaying the situation overwhelmed him or something and this is how he normally plays. But it still feels weird. He keeps apologizing (here) and just throwing casual "cheery" posts. Yet he has actually to post any actual content at all, even when asked by many people. Might as well start somewhere, fuck it #Vote: Bhaal LoM P.S: I'm not really confident in this read, mainly because I have a gut feeling in my stomach that Bhaal is just clueless town and this is all a misunderstanding, and also I'm a little pussy and I don't want to commit to a 100% scum read this early into the day. But whatever, we have to start somewhere and this is the best lead I've got, after the 3 inactive dudes Two things. First, this read is plagued with maybes and doubtfulness. Kaenu absolutely doesn't believe in his case, but voted anyway because "fuck it". Second, the reasonning as to why LS could be scum COULD BE APPLIED TO KAENU HIMSELF. When he said LS kept throwing "cheery" posts, KAENU KEPT THROWING JOKING POST. This is the worst: This post is ripe with excuses ("I sometimes can't read into properly when I'm tired") and all the smileys lke ">.<" and ">.>" which serve little purpose other than appear like an innocent playful townie. It also shows an unnatural fear to respond a normal question saita asked him (like saita asked everybody). The reaction is odd and scummy Read the above carefully and compare with this kaenu post: On February 10 2016 11:46 keanuisgod wrote: I ... I just wanted to contribute to the current thread situation, posting what I believed made the most sense ;_; ![[image loading]](http://vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/smurfsfanon/images/7/7d/Weepy_Fanfiction.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/250?cb=20120103110642) But srs, dunno, do whatever you want. I believe the juicy D1 will start after this "fight" is settled and the other 5-6 people chime in, there's no hurry. Yep. Kaenu did exactly what he scumread LS for doing. To resume, kaenu doesn't believe in his case and his reasons for scumreading LS are non-believable => scum indicator. | ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
But you got it bro. I'm pretty sure these two are scum, 'cause there are scummy + the other players are townie. + this post: On February 11 2016 08:06 keanuisgod wrote: Ok, I'm home now. Don't really have much to add, but while we're waiting for some people to respond and start posting content might as well add comments about some people: Initially I was somewhat torn over Valdi's initial posts, in the sense that he may have tried to put a "wall of soft reads" and then leave making it seem like he's contributing, but on second read his 1st post seems quite strong, so I'm leaning slightly town on him based on feels (though I really want to keep him as null in case my first hunch was right). Is partner indicative of the two. | ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
kush is town 'cause he is the the main force behind discussion in this game, and scum has an hard time doing that; and kush is a pretty lazy scum. Wartruk is (probably) town 'cause of his attack on kush very early, when kush is the main force behind discussion blablabla, and thus a pretty bad target to attack for scum. And his posts EOD1 are way too obviously bad for scums to make I think, I'm wary of that one but that's what I think. I think I have everyone ? The two scums, I explained why gargamed was maybe town above. Pretty sure kaenu and Valdia are the 2 scums. | ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
| ||
|
Iwasrobik
190 Posts
| ||
|
keanuisgod
271 Posts
On February 13 2016 10:15 Iwasrobik wrote: Kaenu is scum because: His early game. Almost only jokes, which is only a smaaaaall scum indicator. Scum indicator nonetheless 'cause stuff was happening, namely kush publicly saying he was smurfhunting (small town indicator for driving discussion + being in the spotlight) and wartruk attacking him for that (good town indicator for attacking the loudest guy in the thread). Even if you disagree with my conclusions, the info was there to make serious posts. But kaenu made jokes AND these two posts: Nothing was said in this post. It's only fluff that appears townie, at a time when kaenu probably felt the need to post something serious but didn't want to take position. You are right, it was fluff. So? And this post, which call kush scum without calling him scum for an extremely bad reason. What makes you believe I implied kush was scum? I implied kush's smurfhunting abilities were bad Might as well come forth with that, in the sense that I don't want NNN to believe I'm 100% someone and then make decisions off me based on that when it (may) not be true at all. Hope hosts don't smite me  (perhaps)Two things. First, this read is plagued with maybes and doubtfulness. Kaenu absolutely doesn't believe in his case, but voted anyway because "fuck it". You got that right Second, the reasonning as to why LS could be scum COULD BE APPLIED TO KAENU HIMSELF. When he said LS kept throwing "cheery" posts, KAENU KEPT THROWING JOKING POST. This is the worst: Read the above carefully and compare with this kaenu post: Yep. Kaenu did exactly what he scumread LS for doing. I'll let you reread those posts and see if you notice the difference yourself Here, I'll even show both posts so you can spot the difference more easily: On February 10 2016 23:17 Bhaal LoM wrote: Okay enough roleplaying for me it time to be a little bit more serious(If you don't know my name is from you prob never played Baldur's Gate or Baldur's Gate 2). To answer your question nnn: I was wanting to see if kean can read more into stuff than I could because I sometimes can't read into properly exp when I am tired >.< Also I wanted to see his thoughts at the time given the low activity of the thread >.> On February 10 2016 11:46 keanuisgod wrote: I ... I just wanted to contribute to the current thread situation, posting what I believed made the most sense ;_; But srs, dunno, do whatever you want. I believe the juicy D1 will start after this "fight" is settled and the other 5-6 people chime in, there's no hurry. Read the above carefully | ||
| ||
![[image loading]](https://nerdinthecity.files.wordpress.com/2013/07/wpid-screenshot_2013-07-17-04-16-26-1.png)
