I also think Ikidomari's absence makes him more likely to be mafia. I remember my first game where I rolled scum, after dealing with tons of accusations and squirming out of them, I had no gas left in the tank when town came back to me.

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 19:23 GMT

#1519

True Kush. That's a fair point. Damn it, would be so much easier if he just got mod killed

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 19:40 GMT

#1527

Yea i'm not 100% sold on Shapelog town tbh

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 19:41 GMT

#1529

but i'm not voting on him today lol

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 21:46 GMT

#1559

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 21:49 GMT

#1560

Good. Ikidomari was normal mafia goon. Two to go! It's actually rather cute; Ikidomari played scum quite similarly to my first time scum play (though I will suggest I played slightly better).

I think we should think about JesusIncarnate lynch for a few reasons: getting replaced later in the game screws up all types of reads and shit like that. Maybe scott will provide something good, but he replaced a VT last game and did nothing to dissuade people's scum reads. He's in a very similar spot now. I also think we can gain some info from a Jesus lynch. Remember how his wagon fell apart and Trfel + Shapelog got onto the Kuragari wagon with little explanation? If Jesus flips mafia, I think the remaining mafia is either Trfel or Shapelog. It's a safe lynch at this point in the game, no?

Also, if we have a doc... please save me. I'm the only confirmed town we have and losing confirmed towns is never good. I wouldn't suggest doing a big WIFOM and not save me because you think mafia will medic dodge...

or maybe i'm WIFOM'ing

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 21:49 GMT

#1561

oops sorry for the double post

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 21:53 GMT

#1563

I also don't think that Trfel is confirmed town because of the Ikido vote/flip. It's smart mafia play. Pretty sure there's 1 mafia voting for Ikido there. Potentially getting him off the lynch block with no good reasons for a second time in 2 days wouldn't look particularly good.

PMT hasn't provided much but she's basically been all over Ikido iirc. Eden kind of explained why it makes him likely town already. I'm relatively confident they are town. Of course i'll look at some filters again, because I haven't been able to follow yesterday + today's dialogue focused enough for my liking

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 21:54 GMT

#1564

Trfel + Shapelog brag mafia team

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

January 31 2016 22:06 GMT

#1568

can someone do time stamps on who voted for Ikido and when?

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 00:12 GMT

#1596

On February 01 2016 08:38 Ikidomari wrote:
Aw fuck, I went out saturday night / sunday, wake up to be lynched

sorry for being such a shitty player / having little impact on the game.
If I play with TL again I'll properly research things and try to actually play well.

GL to my teammates.

No worries bud. I had a similar experience when I played scum my first game on TL. Hope you play more often! Town is so much easier, believe me.

gg

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 01:01 GMT

#1601

yea shapelog, i'm always around. Just refreshing the page every now and then

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 01:08 GMT

#1603

If he couldn't help his team during the game, he wanted to help them afterwards? Interesting. I'll take a look at his "reads" post

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 01:45 GMT

#1615

On February 01 2016 10:43 nooniansoong wrote:
@shape.
yup all his town reads are turning up to be town.
so all his scumreads are probably scum.

that includes you lol

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 03:17 GMT

#1629

Just want to summarize publicly Ikidomari's two read posts

First read post

Town:
darthfoley
Alur
PMT

Scum:
Onegu
JesusIncarnate
Trfel

Last read post

Town:
Alur
Kuragari (already dead)
Darthfoley
MexicanAlien
Eden
Tumblewood

Null/Doesn't give a read:
PMT
Shapelog (says he's town for now, look at him very closely)

Scum
Onegu
Trfel
Kush
JesusIncarnate

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 03:18 GMT

#1631

forgot to add:

Keep a close eye on (read post 1): Kuragari, Shapelog, Tumblewood

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 03:22 GMT

#1632

Doesn't it make sense that a newbie mafia member wouldn't know how to properly "read" their scum teammates, lending them more likely to be in the "keep a close eye on"/ null read category?

That would be Tumblewood, Shapelog, and PMT

Think we should also figure out who Ikidomari seemed allergic to in the thread. Who didn't he talk to directly, or talk much about indirectly? Which of his reads seem forced? I will look into this myself, but I want to see what others think.

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 03:51 GMT

#1651

i'm sure mafia doesn't mind this back and forth bickering

we're really getting closer to finding those other two mafia!

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 03:52 GMT

#1655

Eden, what do you think town's best course of action is over the next day or two?

Trfel, what do you think town's best course of action is over the next day or two?

MexicanAlien, what do you think town's best course of action is over the next day or two?

darthfoley

United States8003 Posts

February 01 2016 03:55 GMT

#1659

Fair enough, but at some point soon I would prefer if (at least temporarily) we could have a cease fire, and we could get back to scum hunting.

After all, we just lynched a fucking scumbag and there has been less useful discussion than when we lynched a townie and lost two others...