On February 07 2016 05:25 Shapelog wrote:
I do not like the fact that there is not any complaining of the lynch. Does this not concern anyone else.

What do you mean

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 06 2016 20:39 GMT

#2282

On February 07 2016 05:34 Shapelog wrote:

Show nested quote +

Like if scum is getting lynched i feel they would be screaming out right now.

Screaming out how? Like why?

Also, what do you think prompted nooniansoong's filter explosion?

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 06 2016 20:53 GMT

#2286

That could be true Shapelog..... Now that I think of it it is kind of weird

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 06 2016 20:54 GMT

#2287

But it might just be that PMT is scum and doesn't think she is threatened tonight

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 06 2016 21:00 GMT

#2291

Fudge

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 06 2016 21:02 GMT

#2293

Fudge fudge fudge this is my fault Darn it sorry guys. I didn't have enough motivation to evaluate any suspicions other than nooniansoong. I really thought we had scum there.

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 06 2016 21:08 GMT

#2295

Trfel I think you need to list all your reads before day 5, because for reasoning I'll explain later, I think you will die tonight.

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 06 2016 21:12 GMT

#2297

Hey guys (not a serious post)
I just thought the most amazing plot twist of all would be if Shapelog is mafia. Think about it. He has been hiding in plain sight the entire time. That would be amazingness

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 07 2016 20:41 GMT

#2310

I think it's interesting that PMT voted 10 times in 4 days.

Day 1:
+ Show Spoiler +

Votes Kuragari42
Votes Onegu
Votes Kuragari42

Result: Kuragari42 lynch

Day 2:
+ Show Spoiler +

Votes JesusIncarnate
Votes Ikidomari (note: PMT was the last one aboard the Ikiwagon)

Result: Ikidomari lynch

Day 3:
+ Show Spoiler +

Votes scott13733
Votes Tumblewood (last person aboard Tumblewagon)
Votes scott13733
Votes Tumblewood (last person aboard, again)

Result: Tumblewood lynch

Day 4:
+ Show Spoiler +

Votes nooniansoong

Result: nooniansoong lynch

In the cases of Kuragari42, JesusIncarnate, scott13733, and nooniansoong, PMT was always one of the first three voters. This makes it seen like she was semi-confident in these scumreads. And all of them are confirmed town.

In the cases of Ikidomari and Tumblewood, PMT always made the last vote. This makes it look like she was not so sure about the scumread, but joined in (she already knew they were scum) to claim some responsibility for scumlynch.

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 07 2016 20:48 GMT

#2311

I know my votes have been not so good lately, and I know this doesn't really mean anything, but it makes me feel nice that my first two votes were scum. it feels kinda cool.

Ikidomari then Tumblewood, Day 1.

I didn't realize that until I was looking through the votes.

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 07 2016 20:59 GMT

#2313

Let's see who died

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 07 2016 21:01 GMT

#2315

Figures. Well, let's see what PMT has to say for herself.

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 08 2016 04:20 GMT

#2318

Hey scott31337,
I see what you mean about having a few more days (24hr days) to figure it out, but if PMT doesn't say anything useful during these last hours then it will just be wasted time.

Or do you want more time to filter dive and read the thread?

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 08 2016 04:49 GMT

#2319

From my PoV, players most town to least town:

scott31337
Shapelog
PepperMintTea

(If I were doing this without the knowledge of my role, I would put _MexicanAlien in between PMT and Shape.)

scott31337
He claimed Veteran. No counterclaim.

Shapelog
I find it hard to believe the immense volume of SPAM and utter nonsense coming from Mafia. It is just too illogical. I do not think a noob mafia could pull off that kind of insane stunt. Even coaching (sorry LoneMeow) could not get him this far.

_MexicanAlien
I honestly think I do seem the least town out of Shape and scott, and this is actually one of my personal reasons I believe PMT has to be scum. If I (knowing my own role) am the second-scummiest player, then the scummiest player has to be the Mafia.

PepperMintTea
She seemed helpful D1, have good analysis, but then Day2/Day3 she just lost all interest in making any sort of game progress, just came in regularly and said she was busy/only going to be there for a few minutes. She does not seem to care whether or not we lynch scum, just that we lynch. Also, had been ignoring the thread for the past few days (24hr days). She may have a good reason though. I'll be waiting for it.

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 08 2016 19:42 GMT

#2325

Shapelog,I just want to say for all I think bad about you, is really hard not to just laugh at your posts (in a good, funny way). Thanks for being so non-boring man. Sorry for any angst coming your way from me.

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 08 2016 19:48 GMT

#2328

Also, in response to your " Game Face" post above, I think you are really doing great with your reads, some of it is a bit.... Uhhhh you know it doesn't seem convincing, but most of it is spot on with how it feels. I agree with you and I really am wondering....

Where in the World is PepperMintTea?(aka Carmen San Diego)

Ah, the old days of geography.

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 08 2016 19:50 GMT

#2329

On February 09 2016 04:45 nooniansoong wrote:
:popcorn:

:fail:

::fail::

_MexicanAlien

South Africa193 Posts

February 08 2016 19:59 GMT

#2333

I want to vote for PepperMintTea, but I think Hillary Clinton is a better option until PMT gives us her keynote speech on all those hard-hitting issues like abortion and Mafia tactics.