Newbie Student Mafia XIX - Page 3

Post a Reply

Prev 1 2 3 4 Next All

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 09:42 GMT

#734

Got to get to work, this game is rather addicting.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 10:00 GMT

#739

On January 28 2016 18:45 Trfel wrote:

Show nested quote +

Date change..... like 13 hours in between the first two posts.

Anyway, I could be wrong about Tumblewood too, but right now I don't see it. I'd also like to bring up that he read my case on him, but didn't respond, and then voted on the leading wagon while yet again matching his reads with the thread sentiment. I really wish that he would interact with me more so that I could either confirm my read or realize that I'm wrong.

But I'm not really thinking that I'm wrong right now.

Sorry my mistake with the time, I thought it was 12 hour clock not 24.

It seems that in the third post you quoted, the additional points that Tumblewood brought up occured before he made the 2nd post and were available to reference then so that could be odd. He may have just gone back over Shapelog's filter and found more things he didn't like. Fairly interesting

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 10:04 GMT

#741

On January 28 2016 19:00 PepperMintTea wrote:

Show nested quote +

On January 28 2016 18:45 Trfel wrote:

On January 28 2016 18:40 PepperMintTea wrote:

On January 28 2016 18:34 Trfel wrote:

On January 28 2016 18:27 PepperMintTea wrote:

On January 28 2016 18:22 Trfel wrote:
Can someone tell me what is wrong with my post here? Is it that the statements themselves are wrong, or that it isn't alignment indicative?

Evidently, everyone feels that something is wrong with it, or they would be lynching Tumblewood?

And again, if someone wouldn't mind saying why they think Alur is town, that would be nice.

If you look at the post by Tumblewood he says firstly I was scumreading him for X initial reasons. I think those fit in the timeline.

He prefaces the second set of quotes by saying "more recently" which is fine so there is no timeline mix up.

Hm, I don't really get what you're trying to say here. If I may?

If it were just Tumblewood's first and third post that I quoted, it would be fine. However, in the second post, he says that Shapelog is scum because his early posts were just that bad. He doesn't seem to consider the more recent posts as important at all, which is very contrary to his perspective in the third post. This makes me feel that he's more interested in telling people what they want to hear than what he actually thinks. Do you mind explaining where you disagree one more time?

I feel the timestamps are important in your quoted posts.

He makes a read on shapelog based on initial posts, the follow up is about 2 hours later , makes sense that he still has the same posts in his mind and responds the same way.

Then it's about 8 hours until the next time he answers, he bring up the original points and then adds in the newer posts than reinforces the read.

I can follow that train of thought.

I'm going to read over tumble more carefully at lunch because I think I might be wrong.

Edit - but then again probably not interesting as the second post you quoted, he is respond directly about the townreads being given to shapelog, rather than his posts.

and when he quotes shapelog in the third post, those quotes all took place after his first scum read of shapelog, so no I don't see anything there.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 14:20 GMT

#758

having lunch, be here for an hour

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 14:31 GMT

#760

Decided I don't want to lynch ikodomari or trefl

Leaves me

Onegu, Tumblewood, JesusIncarnate or Kuragari

Onegu has really done nothing since Eden made his case, just confirmed what he was talking about with Shapelog and then replied weakly to my question. I'm not sure I could gather the votes to get this through

JesusIncarnate and Kuragari just haven't engaged the game at all.

Tumblewood has engaged a little bit but I he has questions outstanding he needs to answer

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 14:34 GMT

#761

you know i'm going to go with this for now and see what happens

## Vote Kuragari42

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 14:36 GMT

#762

actually this is more interesting

## Unvote

## Vote Onegu

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 15:22 GMT

#773

On January 29 2016 00:16 Ikidomari wrote:
Hey guys, there's obviously a lot of heat on me right now, and I'm going to be around for about an hour or so before bed, if you'd like to ask me any questions feel free, if you want my thoughts on something let me know.
The next time I'll be active is my lunch break tomorrow (probably about 13-14 hours from the time of this post), and then after that will be when I get home from work (18-20 hours from this post).

I'll be as transparent as possible in my answers.

On January 29 2016 00:18 Tumblewood wrote:
Just woke up... I have about ten minutes, maybe twenty to answer questions

The best thing the two of you can do is convince us you are town rather than just sitting there waiting to answer questions.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 18:11 GMT

#868

##Unvote

## Vote Kuragari42

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 18:56 GMT

#883

Kura, Jesus or Tumblewood, happy with any of those

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 19:04 GMT

#888

On January 29 2016 03:59 Alur wrote:
While I read up on the Tumblewood case.

Why wouldn't you be happy with Ikidomari?

I'm trying to consolidate and I think the other targets are better

With Ikidomari i'm still unsure but he says it's his first game and from his posts it seems to me like a new guy who knows he has messed up but wants to put his own ideas out there.
Plus he hasn't really had a chance to play so I want to see what he comes up with later on.

I think that the cases on the other 3 are stronger and we shouldn't be spread over 4 people.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 28 2016 19:06 GMT

#892

Kura or tumblewood, decided not to lynch Jesus

let's get it down to two.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 29 2016 08:59 GMT

#1106

I don't have anything to say until day starts so just going to read and then get to work.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 30 2016 11:04 GMT

#1350

##Vote JesusIncarnate

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 30 2016 17:49 GMT

#1366

On January 31 2016 02:48 Shapelog wrote:

Show nested quote +

Would you rather me pressure her instead? Like she has also said that she post/do shit today at EOD to get out of talking about why she voted Kura. And now the first thing she does is vote the person with 2 votes on them.

I am not going to wait for someone to post at this point.

you seem a little upset so i'm going to post in a little bit once you have finished having a tantrum.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 30 2016 19:59 GMT

#1377

Jesus is confirmed mafia based on his filter at this point.

Don't have anything else to discuss.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 30 2016 22:44 GMT

#1412

On January 31 2016 07:13 Trfel wrote:
PepperMintTea, I'm having trouble figuring out this game and would really like some help with solving the game. You seem to be a lot more certain than I am.

PepperMintTea, can you please explain how you approached the Day 1 lynch, and why you are so certain of JesusIncarnate being mafia?

I have to go back in my memory a little bit but from what I recall.

I had 4 people I was considering for a lynch, then after a sleep and another read through I added Kuragari , his filter was pretty bad.
I think his terrible push on darth and then nothing else made him scummy to me.
So I thought he was likely mafia and voted him.

I decided that voting for the scummy guy that everyone thought was scummy was pretty boring so I switched to Onegu who I thought was scummy. Then it turned out he was at hospital so switched back to Kura.

Iko I explained why I didn't want to to lynch and Tumblewood was still scummy but I thought Kura was more scummy.

The reason I didn't vote for jesus was because I thought he was going to turn out to be a role or at least that is how I read his blatant lack of investment. iko didn't post but when he finally started playing it was apologetic.
Jesus by contrast was arrogant and he read like a role that didn't want to get townread to hard. I felt that if he was pushed then he would claim a role and I didn't want to get involved in that.

Now we are well into day 2, Jesus did not post his promised information and hasn't actually contributed anything at all. The roles have been claimed and therefore Jesus has no excuse for his play other than being mafia.

I can work out the other mafia the next day but for now Jesus is the lynch and other suggestions are ridiculous.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 30 2016 22:50 GMT

#1415

On January 31 2016 07:49 Trfel wrote:
I guess that makes sense. Thank you for answering my question.

What if JesusIncarnate has a real life excuse to not play? That he can't post about because of said real life circumstances? Why isn't this a possible explanation?

it is possible but he's probably mafia.

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 31 2016 18:36 GMT

#1501

##Unvote

He's getting modkilled so not much point

i'm between iki and tumble

PepperMintTea

187 Posts

January 31 2016 18:40 GMT

#1504

iki's filter looks worse and he hasn't repaid the pass he was given D1.

## Vote Ikidomari

I've had an insanely busy weekend and haven't been involved in this day phase at all.

Prev 1 2 3 4 Next All

Please or register to reply.

Newbie Student Mafia XIX - Page 3

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming