|
On January 20 2016 11:36 kitaman27 wrote:Right now the only people that I'd say warrant assigned picks are Vivax, AlotSomuch and mayyybe The Shining. Vivax seems mafia because he shows up with this post to complain about the number claiming, but doesn't suggest a better strategy or show interest in planning things out. Show nested quote +On January 20 2016 00:55 Vivax wrote:
Pretty much sums up why this shitty number claiming strat won't do jack. AlotSomuch had a really weak intro post. Something about trying to take notes, but not having any reads. Then the way he mentions VA's supsicions of him seem....awkward? Seems fine with being assigned too. The Shining also a mafia lean for similar reasons to Alot. A few posts on numbers and then accepting a role assignment with little sign of interest of abusing the setup or anything. Gambler, Doctor, and kitaman27 would probably be my three preferences for the assigned roles. Mostly beneficial for town and not a ton of use for mafia. Another thing with the kita role is that if one of the doctor trio slips through, we could use it to make sure all three are in the game and then use a wall of protects/watchers/trackers to make sure they are able to pull of their checks.
This is a terrible post because the three names he mentions are basically drawn out of a fucking hat. There's a ton of people I have no faith Kita has strong opinions on simply because they haven't been around.
|
Can you explain your Keir and Kita suspicions?
|
On January 20 2016 16:23 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On January 20 2016 16:14 Keirathi wrote:On January 20 2016 16:13 geript wrote:
Either way. CPR doc must claim it ahead of time. That's a role town must know where it is. Ya, I have school from 12 until deadline tomorrow, so if I'm going to take CPR I'll definitely say it in thread before i leave for school. Ok well booh but whatever. Who do you want to lynch.
If I had to pick a lynch right this second?
Someone out of Damdred (for reasons I said), maybe Onegu (I think town Onegu would have probably tried to contest me for 1,1. It's weird that he didn't), maybe Cephiro pending reading some of his other games, maybe Cake for the random reads that felt kinda forced.
Then there's the whole host of people who haven't said anything like Vivax, GB, Alot, VA.
But there's still 60+ hours left. There's plenty of time to think about ti more and see what they have to say.
|
I also suspect you more now.
That might mean I need to sleep because I'm calling everyone mafia.
There's something about Keir that I just absolutely hate. Maybe we get him to pick moriarty, that'd be fine with me I think as it's somewhat useless as mafia.
|
After all this arguments about CPR doc I think we make superbia pick it. No one is throwing any shade on him being a townread. I think of all the people that aren't me I trust him most and he has pick #2.
|
So keirathi has no excuse to take it if we let the next person grab it anyway.
|
On January 20 2016 16:57 Palmar wrote:
There's something about Keir that I just absolutely hate.
Ouch, man. Hate is a strong word 
On January 20 2016 16:57 Palmar wrote:
After all this arguments about CPR doc I think we make superbia pick it. No one is throwing any shade on him being a townread. I think of all the people that aren't me I trust him most and he has pick #2.
I could probably get behind this, though. I definitely trust him more than you and geript.
Anyways like I said, I'll say for sure what I'm doing before I go to school tomorrow. Will give 6+ hours for people to change their roles if needed.
|
On January 20 2016 10:10 Palmar wrote:
Before I go to sleep, this is the outline of a plan that I'm slowly formulating, it's not very well thought through yet, mostly because I don't really know most of the roles, but here goes:
1. Keirathi - Trust level quite low: Force to pick gambler or dreamflower
2. Superbia - Trust level high. Should probably pick Link
3. ObiWanShinobi - Trust level moderate. I'd be okay with any investigative role here
4. Rels - Trust level moderate, investigative or KP role is good
5. Palmar - Trust level highest. I'll either pick CPR doc or arrow
6. geript - Trust level fairly high. I want him on an investigative role I think
7. Breshke - Trust level quite low. Force to pick protective
8. Koshi - Crazy, can't deal with him probably
9. Cephiro - Scum. Force into a completely neutered scumrole pls (like pure investigative or df/gambler)
10. kitaman27 - Trust level low to moderate. Good for a protective role
11. Vivax - Scum (force to pick dreamflower or gambler?)
12. Tictock - idk
13. disformation - low trust
14. Fecalfeast - low trust
15. Damdred - moderate trust, but not too much.
16. AlotSomuch - low trust
17. VayneAuthority - low trust
18. The Shining - low trust
19. Onegu - dumbass, can't deal with him
20. Sicklucker - Trust level high. either use him as a check, or get him kita, or get him a good role by forcing it to drop
21. Copcake - Whatever, preferably we try to force her into a role
22. GlowingBear - Whatever, preferably we try to force him into a role
the bunch of people with low trust in the bottom half on the list should probably try to grab PROTECTIVE or INVESTIGATIVE roles.
I will revise my list of people I trust later on in the game, but I will not accept any excuse for people picking KP roles unless they're on my trusted list. Current people I'd trust with KP are:
Superbia
Me
geript
sicklucker
I need 2-3 more names on this list.
How to get onto the list? there's two options
1. Post well and play well so I townread you.
2. Someone else (a third party) makes a good argument for you being town.
If anyone has a problem with anyone on my trust list, then let me know.
There is probably way more town at the bottom. Dnu why Vivax is scum. Maybe he is though.
|
On January 20 2016 11:11 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On January 20 2016 09:52 Cephiro wrote:On January 20 2016 09:45 sicklucker wrote:
why did koshi and ceperio overlap? im amusing you did it to block koshi? thats the only logical explanation Pretty much. I figured since I'm aiming for a partially random role it's fairly likely I'll get it anyway, and I remembered just a bit before deadline that I might as well knock someone down a bit while still keeping myself at a fairly high pick. Just checked a few filters I hadn't been too fond of hastily and decided to bump him a bit. Intentionally took 3,2 instead of 3,1 so he'd get the pick before me in case people were gonna make a fuss about it. I mean more than one third of the game is mafia, so I figured it's not too unlikely I'll hit one even if I haven't been paying the most attention to the thread so far. I'm really sceptical about the overall thread presence and people trying to lead, and until someone shows extremely surefire signs of being the clearest of clear town, I'm not very eager to co-operate. Not really keen on giving scum any control over my actions, in the worst case. This is very much how I've been looking at this game tbh. Especially agree with the bolded. I estimate myself becoming cooperative and invested post D1-2. Take that as you will.
Nobody cares if the mafia teams are fighting for thread control. Let them.
Also, Palmar can lead this thread even if he is hitler.
Also, I showed I was pretty likely town and this Cephiro dude bumped me down. He wrote 5000 words on how he bumped me down but hasn't yet given 1 concrete reason why I would be mafia. While there are been given 2-3 reasons why I am town in the thread.
Cephiro might be super mega trash at reading me, or reading townies in general because I played pretty town early on purpose. I can do so much worse than this lol, but I knew it had no purpose this game. To see somebody scumread me when I play like this is a joke. And does he really scumread me?
In his entire wall of text he is more like "dnu bout koshi guis, just bumping him down because"
Also number 3 is a good pick for mafia because it is pretty high up there, and picking 3,2 just to gain some "goodwill" is just fucking hilarious because his entire point was "I don't trust Koshi enough so therefore I picked 3, but I trust him enough to let him go before me"
lol
doesn't make sense.
Anyway, cephiro also might be town when he is an hypocrite fuck who lies against himself and the thread about why he actually picked 3. But in that case I want to lynch him out of spite.
I go for 80% scum and 20% town. But 100% my favorite lynch till end of days.
It is "only" 80% because I don't really understand the mafia motive yet. Probably it really is because a lot of mafia after number 3 were sitting solo on their number so Cephiro took me down to bump his friends up, while being pretty much on top himself because 3 was going to be the first double number.
Ezlynch Cephiro.
|
I also want to point out to the friends of Cephiro that I have no interest in hunting them down. I do not hold them responsible for the action of their slightly retarded friend.
No revenge kill pls. Or pre-emptive kill.
|
Also people who think Palmar is mafia and should be lynched/shot are retarded and don't understand this game. We can talk about this when 15ish people have died. Somewhere D3.
|
On January 20 2016 14:53 geript wrote:
I'll be honest. I'm going to pick CPR doc. I'm town and each of my last games (and analysis) I've pretty much targeted only scum. Plus, it's a roll where I can kill scum because I'm pretty shitty at making cases and convincing people.
Palmer, I'm 99% sure you're wrong about Keir.
Also I don't like disinfo. IDK why, but when I was reading while driving back from work (before my phone battery stopped that) I saw a post of his that I didn't like. But I'm not 100% b/c I think there was a game where I had the same feeling for what I think are similar reasons and he was town.
Just don't yell who you will target then, just proof you are town to the town. Mafia has medic or can even mindgame and target them with their own kp or other mafia team kp or town kp or ....
cpr doc is a bit unreliable this game. but it is a cool role.
|
Yo, it's my first day back at work so I have 1000 things to do. Won't have time to play before tonight.
I skimmed through the thread, I'm OK taking a prot role if people don't want me to have KP. So I'll claim:
I'll take Malcolm Reynolds
If someone already took him, quote the post and I'll change. Otherwise, kindly shut the fuck up
|
I saw SL accusing copcake and GB taking his number; it's like 99% likely they didn't chose a number and were sent directly to the bottom
|
On January 20 2016 13:14 Keirathi wrote:
sicklucker are you sure you sent in to both hosts that you were picking 12?
Becuase if you assume that your pick is still 6,1, then the draft order makes sense.
fuck i only sent to hts. I DID TYPE ONE OUT TO GREYMIST THO. I dont know what happened to it I must not have clicked send GG
dumb system is dumb
|
AT LEAST IM CONFIRMED TOWN GUYS. IM SURE SUPER AND THE USUAL WILL AY I WOULD PULL THIS OFF AS MAFIA THO. becasue im sl right? I FAKE DUMBTELL ALL THE TIME AS MAFIA
I did this rant last game as town too I dont fucking do it
|
yo SL, around to talk about stuff ? I've got a few ideas I wanna discuss with people
|
|
|
Good timing it's my lunch break p: I have 2 hours of free time. Gonna grab a sandwich and read carefully what I missed since last night.
Writing something before leaving I want people's opinion on.
|
2 hour lunch break? seems legit I used to get 30 minutes
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
