Also going 1-1 makes sense if scum wanted to draw out the jk to not risk us gaining a ML with a save. This probably implies that 1 or both of the remaining scum are not under suspicion right now.

Damdred

15669 Posts

January 10 2016 22:36 GMT

#4862

But I rot is doing a 1 v 1 why not let exo be lynched if he's town 3x lylo without a clear lynch next day is worse for town than maybe getting another lynch when,scum still has a rb to block oo from getting a save

Damdred

15669 Posts

January 10 2016 22:42 GMT

#4863

Like the only way this is possible,is if exo is the rb and scum doesn't want a potential save tonight.

But would be giving up a lot

The Shining

United States2406 Posts

January 10 2016 22:43 GMT

#4864

No no I meant going 1-1 as OO claiming trying to draw out the jk claim

The Shining

United States2406 Posts

January 10 2016 22:45 GMT

#4865

Even though it still irks me that ritoky would rather soft push me instead of OO who should've been claimed scum in his eyes but I guess we'll see post flip

Damdred

15669 Posts

January 10 2016 22:45 GMT

#4866

Oh well yeah it makes sense as oo being scum less so as rit as scum.

Rut wasn't a clear lynch tommorow, or today for that matter. No information from nk vs information tonight.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 10 2016 22:46 GMT

#4867

Jesus, I guess we're not lynching exo today.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 10 2016 22:47 GMT

#4868

I haven't read anything, but I guess the gist of it is that ritoky actually counterclaimed?

ritoky, you talked about shining being mafia 100% but to you OO should be confirmed mafia, why not just immediately cc?

The Shining

United States2406 Posts

January 10 2016 22:51 GMT

#4869

Damdred, right.

Palmar, yes. Both claimed to jail Damdred n2 after his fake claim but ritoky said it was aggressive, whereas OO said he was just protecting a town read.

And thanks for parroting my last post -.-

The Shining

United States2406 Posts

January 10 2016 22:52 GMT

#4870

If you didn't read anything, how'd you put all that together, though? QT sparknotes? :o

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 10 2016 22:53 GMT

#4871

I'm working through the scenarios and why they would happen in my head right now.

We have the following options:

OO is mafia, rit is JK, exo is getting lynched. In that case ritoky has no idea if the exo lynch is correct, but he probably doesn't believe it (I don't have time to check what he actually thought), seeing as I remember him calling shining scum and to him OO must be mafia too. Unless he thinks exo is the third mafia.

Also OO could be town, exo is getting lynched and ritoky as mafia ccs. this is potentially a play, but almost only if exo is mafia. It makes no sense to save a townie (exo) which rit would know if he's mafia to create a 1v1 with an already claimed jailer.

But the thing is Exo is actually super likely to be mafia, still if exo is mafia (ie: I'm right on exo) why would ritoky who I've been sort of suspicious of but not been outright calling mafia, attempt to save him with a pretty hail mary play.

Like if we turn around and lynch ritoky here and he flips mafia, wouldn't we simply immediately lynch Exo tomorrow?

I guess based on that it's more likely OO is mafia

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 10 2016 22:54 GMT

#4872

On January 11 2016 07:52 The Shining wrote:
If you didn't read anything, how'd you put all that together, though? QT sparknotes? :o

anything being not a literal statement. (more like, I quickly went through the voting thread and skimmed the thread)

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 10 2016 22:54 GMT

#4873

On January 11 2016 07:51 The Shining wrote:
Damdred, right.

Palmar, yes. Both claimed to jail Damdred n2 after his fake claim but ritoky said it was aggressive, whereas OO said he was just protecting a town read.

And thanks for parroting my last post -.-

right this I did not know.

Do we have their full claim history somewhere?

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 10 2016 22:56 GMT

#4874

I know OO's

Tbh it's better for me if OO is the JK because he jailed me at some point. clearly town

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 10 2016 22:56 GMT

#4875

ok found rit's, basically he's been jailing damdred for 3 nights.

ExO_

United States2316 Posts

January 10 2016 22:56 GMT

#4876

On January 11 2016 07:53 Palmar wrote:
I'm working through the scenarios and why they would happen in my head right now.

We have the following options:

OO is mafia, rit is JK, exo is getting lynched. In that case ritoky has no idea if the exo lynch is correct, but he probably doesn't believe it (I don't have time to check what he actually thought), seeing as I remember him calling shining scum and to him OO must be mafia too. Unless he thinks exo is the third mafia.

Also OO could be town, exo is getting lynched and ritoky as mafia ccs. this is potentially a play, but almost only if exo is mafia. It makes no sense to save a townie (exo) which rit would know if he's mafia to create a 1v1 with an already claimed jailer.

But the thing is Exo is actually super likely to be mafia, still if exo is mafia (ie: I'm right on exo) why would ritoky who I've been sort of suspicious of but not been outright calling mafia, attempt to save him with a pretty hail mary play.

Like if we turn around and lynch ritoky here and he flips mafia, wouldn't we simply immediately lynch Exo tomorrow?

I guess based on that it's more likely OO is mafia

"extremely likely I'm mafia" yeah why is that exactly? I'd like to know. I want to hear how you as a scum are going to call me mafia, or you as a VT are misreading me as mafia

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

January 10 2016 22:57 GMT

#4877

ritoky tomorrow
probably lynch exo in two days
after that it should be obvious

remember to check and recheck all your assumptions and re-do all your reads, last chance to not fuck this up 100%

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 10 2016 22:57 GMT

#4878

On January 11 2016 07:56 ExO_ wrote:

Show nested quote +

"extremely likely I'm mafia" yeah why is that exactly? I'd like to know. I want to hear how you as a scum are going to call me mafia, or you as a VT are misreading me as mafia

Do you just not pay attention?