I really don't like that reasoning. Why should we stick to the 2 lynches that have been slowly going all day that have gotten next to no reactions?

I feel like i have pretty good reasons for why GB is mafia here.

Check out my big case.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 20:58 GMT

#1213

On November 30 2015 05:52 Koshi wrote:
Yeah that case you made on GB has a lot of narrative in it. Doesn't make him mafia for being of opinion that sl is mafia for jumping on the ff thing... Then it makes him more mafia if he pulls that through to you and calls you mafia as well?

It's being consistent.

Him jumping around isn't general mafia either. Mafia has way more issues being a chicken without head all the time.

For one, he's hardly been jumping around on his reads at all, besides one or two exceptions.

Second, he has hardly given any reasons for why he's changed his reads in the last day.

Like the fact that he only ever talks about my activity, but never the content I'm putting out past that one post he went off on D1. That's not a read, and activity is never a good way to make a read on people. You gotta compare activity with content.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:07 GMT

#1223

On November 30 2015 06:01 Koshi wrote:

Show nested quote +

No. It is an ok first read. But nothing in it says:
GB did this because he is mafia, if he was town he would do Y.

It's more of a story of what GB did, and then find it odd to understand, then conclude it should be mafia GB.

The not understanding was not seeing how it made sense from town!GB.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:08 GMT

#1225

On November 30 2015 06:04 Koshi wrote:
Yeah... If OO and snow are not mafia last lynches will be scott, bf and Onegu.

TT, GB, SL, fefe are getting unlynchable at this point.

Yea I have really bad issues with this thinking.

You've got to at least consider the possibility of Scum being active, and town getting shit on with so many non-contributors.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:10 GMT

#1229

I'll tell you right now that if I was scum, I'd be just as active and doing as much work as I have been this game.

So yea, I think it's a very real possibility.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:11 GMT

#1232

On November 30 2015 06:10 GlowingBear wrote:

Show nested quote +

Again, summarise your reasons to why am I Mafia and tell us who are my partners if I am

I'm not trying to build a scumteam here, and I've made plenty of posts explaining why I think you are scum.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:19 GMT

#1237

On November 30 2015 06:14 Koshi wrote:
It's a good question.

Give us a scumteam TT.

4 names. most likely mafia

Without more info my reads are basically still the same as this post.

On November 28 2015 21:14 Tictock wrote:
Here is where I am at with this game atm, (things may change as I do filter dives and reread stuff today) listing strongest town to strongest scum

Town:
sicklucker
Koshi
ANickelDrink

Nullish:
ObviousOne
Chromatically + Show Spoiler +

Need to do a proper read on this guy

Onegu
boxerfred
scott31337

Scum:
GlowingBear + Show Spoiler +

Technically more of a scum lean, but strong enough to warrent being down here. Mostly due to his read progression not making much sense, I'll do a post dedicated to looking at GB later.

Sn0_Man

To do List for today:
- Filter dive and get a better read going on Chrom (His EoD felt pretty good to me, which is why he's moved up somewhat in my list from D1)
- Case on Sn0
- Try and put aside my OMGUS on GB and wade through his filter

And with the numerous inactive people and hardly any reads or info from the rest of you all I'm just about over this game.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:24 GMT

#1243

Throwing my vote back onto Sn0.

Guess we'll see how this goes, but my gut feeling is that town is pretty fucked this game.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:26 GMT

#1247

Well Koshi I though Shenanigans would be appropriate for how dead the day has been, but you all have undefined hard townreads on GB

or like SL just feel like even if he's mafia he's not the lynch here

this just feels like D1 all over again to me

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:28 GMT

#1249

On November 30 2015 06:26 Koshi wrote:
Like how can your gut think we are fucked if we are voting away your biggest scumread (par gb)

My gut can think whatever the hell it wants, my head gets to decide if I'm going to listen to it or not.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:29 GMT

#1251

On November 30 2015 06:27 ANickelDrink wrote:

Show nested quote +

who are you talking about?

Pretty sure he's referring to Sn0, but I'm not sure where this part came from.

If you don't have time to play the game and you don't wish to vote on people

Unless I missed or am forgetting about a post Sn0 made.

Tictock

United States6051 Posts

November 29 2015 21:34 GMT

#1253

On November 30 2015 06:31 Koshi wrote:

Show nested quote +

Both snow and OO need to go asap. This day has been pretty ok. Just sad 2 people are not playing at all and 2 are doing nothing townie in the few posts they made.

If we (aka town) lose this game because of that I am fine with it. If GB/Chrom/TT are mafia for instance, I am really fine with a loss.

The fact that you seem fine to just lynch through lurkers or inactive people and don't care if that looses town the game is going to make me really rethink my read on you after this lynch.

Plus I've never understood why you were so adamant that Vivax was town last EoD at first and then jumped on the lynch anyway.