Battle of the Drams Mafia - Page 7

On September 30 2015 20:04 rsoultin wrote:


yes, i reevaluated cause other players i thought looked scummy or could be scum were looking more townie to me -shrugs- it happens

On September 30 2015 20:07 rsoultin wrote:


mostly just his reaction to the votes seemed pretty townie because of anger to me...i also liked some of his other stray comments later, but i don't think he actually did anything to progress the thread on further reflection

plus the whole the vote stays unless you say something that only town rsoul could say just is really ridiculous for a push on anyone

On September 30 2015 20:25 rsoultin wrote:
truffle's weirdness with his pushes on me were clarified as our joke, which i thought they might be, plus he's putting in the effort again so i felt good about him

On September 29 2015 09:39 Trfel wrote:
OH YEAH that was my argument!

Thank you for reminding me!

Never mind, it's still somewhat valid.

On September 29 2015 09:44 Trfel wrote:
Basically, GlowingBear made this one post purely to generate discussion. His other posts before this post that you made were serious posts.

The post you quoted, the "I'm town" post, does nothing to promote discussion at all. My opening posts also didn't end up creating any discussion.

Basically, your post claims that my opening posts actually had a purpose and created discussion, and GlowingBear was actually succeeding at making provocative posts. Both claims I disagree with.

Hm, but now that I think about it I don't think that this is a good argument

Wow, I'm really bad at this.

On September 30 2015 20:42 rsoultin wrote:


they're clearly not lol and he admitted to as much? what's your point?

On September 30 2015 20:38 rsoultin wrote:
also i think we have scum in rels tbh, based on people's reactions to marv's "case" that wasn't a case and rels' push on truffle all game lol

On September 30 2015 20:45 rsoultin wrote:


when he said i was still mafia and left was a joke, and when he started pushing on me was a joke, so the problem with the progression of his scumread on me is not a problem because only the parts you quoted were serious

On September 30 2015 20:48 rsoultin wrote:


marv's case is demonstrably false by my role pm lol

moreover i've explained it more than adequately from a townie mindset. address what in my explanation doesn't make sense

explain how trfel's read progression on me is weird given the knowledge that only the posts you quoted were serious from him

and i expect mafia to capitalize on what is most likely a town marv pushing on a town rsoul; we're kind of the defalut nks along with rayn in this game xP it's obvious that mislynching any of us would be fucking brilliant for scum

On September 30 2015 20:51 rsoultin wrote:


he already explained that my later posts made it seem like i was going a different direction?

better question is why you're pushing this "truffle's read progression on rsoul" thing so hard, from the very beginning of the game, yet the moment marv comes out with a case on me, you sheep it

do you really think we could be scum together?

you clearly are much more adamant about this point from early game on truffle that you've been harping on and filling most of your filter with than anything anyone has said about me. there's a truffle wagon and yet you're voting me lol

this does not compute

i think you're scum for it

^ note to all townies if marv's fit gets me lynched...rels is probably scum here for this...dropping the push on truffle to come after me when, rationally, i should be town in his eyes

On September 30 2015 20:53 rsoultin wrote:


yup this is your true scum lol he's making things up now

it's perfectly reasonable to reevaluate based on the game state. there is nothing unreasonable about it

the better question is what do i gain from flipping my read on marv at that point?

On September 30 2015 20:55 rsoultin wrote:


mafia lol explain how it's more scum indicative in your eyes

i'm on the edge of my seat

On September 30 2015 19:08 Rels wrote:
mm that rsoultin stuff is damning
going to finish catching up then will fact check your posts
if she really turned around her read on you based on nothing, she's probably mafia running out of targets to scumread

On September 30 2015 19:54 Rels wrote:

OK I fact checked that and it's true. Marv didn't post anything between rsoultin's townread of him and the "marv didn't push anything worth Damdy" post. Later she lists marv as one of the three lynch candidates from her POV.
That doesn't make sense. rsoultin voted marv at the beginning of the game to pressure him. Then when marv did stuff, she put it in the "strong townread" category, before putting him in the "I would lynch him" category 1h30 later when marv DID NOT POST A THING BETWEEN.

On September 30 2015 21:00 rsoultin wrote:


this was rels' reason for voting me

he's clearly stuck on truffle's read progression of me

until you explain why reevaluating the game and thinking that i gave marv's fit following being voted for the first time too much credit is unbelievable, you are scum in my eyes

you have a reason to scumread truffle that you've been pushing all game, where we can't be scum together, but you drop it in an instant for this

why would i do this as scum, is the better question?

no one is asking that question

regardless, he drops the read he has been TUNNELING ALL GAME which is one of the reasons i was suspicious of him in the first place, cause it's based solely on early game and has allowed him to barely comment on the rest, but i thought he could be tunneled, to vote off a player who under any normal circumstances cannot possibly be scum with truffle, the player he's been tunneling

this is mafia taking advantage and not believing in what he's been harping on from the beginning

On September 30 2015 21:06 MoosyDoosy wrote:

wow, this kind of hurts, especially because I have a feeling in the following posts I'm going to read, you're going to try to lynch me again off of the reasoning that "Moosy can't be this dumb". after I flip town you're going to send me another bm PM saying I played terribly lol. but if this is what's going to run this course then I'm fine with it.

On September 30 2015 21:09 rsoultin wrote:
oh you half did; i just missed it

what is unbelievable about reevaluating reads?

what makes this more likely to come from scum rsoul than town rsoul?

On September 30 2015 21:15 rsoultin wrote:


no i scumread him for his overall play

you should ask before you make assertions like this

i townread him because he reacted in a way that i considered to be townie to the pressure, but then continued to do very little to progress the thread, so i then reconsidered that maybe that reaction wasn't worth the hard townread

it's very simple and has already been explained

what doesn't make sense here?

On September 30 2015 21:26 rsoultin wrote:
to be more clear cause i fail at that a lot

mav continued to do very little

AFTER THE POINT WHERE I FIRST TOWNREAD HIM AND UNVOTED HIM (not when the hosts noticed but when i actually unvoted him many hours earlier) FOR HIS REACTION TO THE PRESSURE

^^

and i'm pretty sure i said something to this effect when i first started talking about marv as scum again, cause i know i was thinking it

On September 30 2015 21:33 rsoultin wrote:


no i don't actually mean after the sexy marv post

On September 30 2015 21:33 rsoultin wrote:
okay, rels, reads and reasons

your ls read has been static, that i remember distinctly

so has your truffle read

what was good about scott's list post?

who else do you think is scum and why?

townreads?

i want it all...i'd rather push scum as a counterwagon so if you're town, help me out here

On September 30 2015 21:36 rsoultin wrote:


this was where i townread him for his reaction, early yesterday morning over 24 hours ago, and when i actually unvoted

the sexy post was like 6-8 hours after that between classes cause i liked his vote on moosy and i thought rayn's bitching over semantics was just as asinine as marv's post suggested