I don't think he did. I think that was honest because it seemed to be in his post. He posted this as he changed:
"Now I'm lynched unless someone else votes marv, but them's the breaks."

It was deliberate.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 00:43 GMT

#1121

Actually skimming Stoicism's post I could MAYBE warm up to a shennanie onto him. Its arguably even worse than marv's. What's holding me back is that he's (seemingly) completely new which makes it a little harder to damn him for not getting stuck in as much.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 00:49 GMT

#1139

On October 13 2015 09:45 sicklucker wrote:

Show nested quote +

I AGREE WITH YOU MARV IS SUPER SCUMMY.

but if hes town he will be nked like 90% of the time. We want to keep him around at least 1 day. Like its math and very good for town in mana reasons. if hes mafia it will be aparently obvious as time passes and we will still lynch him.

Stocism posted 6 paragraphs we will probably never get a great read on him and this is a plus on deciding who we lynch day 1.

We really need your vote to move this

Fine. I don't think I'm going to persuade anyone to get on marv now anyway and I don't like the OO train much.

But if marv doesn't get killed N1 and he doesn't seriously turn it up on D2 then I'm parking my vote there and never moving it until he dies.

##Unvote: marvellosity
##Vote: Stoicism_

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 00:53 GMT

#1148

In fact unless marv plays godly N1 I think I'll be literally parking my vote there as soon as I can after the D2 votes open.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 00:58 GMT

#1155

With the votes spread like that then if Stoicism isn't scum then I can see one mafia on his train and the other two elsewhere to be honest. Quite possibly people who aren't here.

I'm not sure how helpful the VCA is going to turn out to be though if that turns out to be the case.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:01 GMT

#1159

Oh BOOM.

Gj sicklucker. I nearly didn't change there. X-D

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:01 GMT

#1160

Shame about Gumdrop though.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:02 GMT

#1164

On October 13 2015 10:02 sicklucker wrote:

Show nested quote +

na its not that bad it might even be pro town

I meant its more a shame that he stopped playing again. X-D

Guy seems to sign up and then just...vanish.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:04 GMT

#1168

Anyway I give it like a 50-50 chance that there's a mafia on Stoicism. It seems a fairly easy bus to make, even as a shenanie because he's just not been around forever. And I can imagine at least one mafia trying to be around for EoD.

But I'm pretty certain at least one mafia is off that train and has their vote elsewhere.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:07 GMT

#1170

Brb, getting a brandy.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:07 GMT

#1171

On October 13 2015 10:06 MoosyDoosy wrote:
So we definitely have a cop and we may or may not have a Doc/Veteran. I'd prefer if people didn't advise blues to do stuff. Although the roleblocker is now gone, a Mafia might be trying to influence the blues and I want to avoid that as much as possible.

???

Why definitely have a cop? Vig shoots EoN, right?

TMI?!?

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:22 GMT

#1194

On October 13 2015 10:10 sicklucker wrote:

Show nested quote +

Vote logic says me you and shining are almost always town here. Since I had you both as obv towns (which is why I asked for your votes) im happy to go with this for the rest of the game. After that it gets a little hazzy.

ObviousOne was open to this switch hes definitely less likely to be mafia but not impossible.

Moosy is porbably town for not voting stoic who was about to flip no matter where he voted. If he knows his partners about to flip he would vote him so hes really closed to lock town too but not comlpletely.

That leaves 2 mafia in

) Onegu (
4) Eversince (filter)
6) Vivax (filter)
7) KelsierSC (filter)
9) Fecalfeast (filter)
10) marvellosity (filter)

Im most suspicious of kscs vote. Also the way ksc/vivax have acted against each other I think 1 is always mafia while the other is town.

My position is that you're about 99% town after the shenanies there tbh. There's a couple of quite devious reasons I can think of why that 1% chance of still scum is still there which I'd rather not go into because it'll give mafia ideas for confusing the thread. But in any case its incredibly unlikely you're scum in my eyes. I'm happy putting you down as town.

I'm not entirely as convinced about Shining, OO or Moosy. I guess its possible one of them bussed but it seems unlikely. There were other trains going strong they could have pushed so I'd lean town on all three right now; though I'll still be reviewing filters over D2.

My next scum nomination would have to go to marv. Until something dramatically changes he's basically my top D2 lynch.

Your thoughts on KSC/Vivax I could kinda get behind. But Vivax WAS calling for shenanies onto Stoic well in advance. So that's boosted him up quite a bit in my eyes. On the other hand I'm not really behind the idea of scum!KSC. So I really don't know there.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:24 GMT

#1197

On October 13 2015 10:16 sicklucker wrote:

Show nested quote +

IM SURE YOU WANTED TO LYNCH SHOICNIC VIVAX LOL

He really did:

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewpost.php?post_id=24963089

On October 13 2015 09:14 Vivax wrote:
We still can kill stoicism who is probably my fav lynch but I'll need 4 valiant people.

This really helps Vivax in my eyes.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 01:25 GMT

#1198

On October 13 2015 10:21 MoosyDoosy wrote:
sicklucker has to be town lol. I've never seen him this happy and excited before.

IKR

Its pretty funny. SL is usually really hard to read for me from what I've seen of his games. But if my 1% chance that he's still scum is true then he's playing this masterfully. Every one of his posts is just full of total joy. X-D

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

October 13 2015 12:00 GMT

#1219

On October 13 2015 12:55 sicklucker wrote:
This does not really have to be said but @celestial I would never ever bus a newbie in a newbie game unless they specifically asked me too

I was more thinking because he wasn't about at all for ages that's precisely what he might have done. "Something came up and I can't be about, can I get replaced? No? Just bus me."

Anyway that was kinda quick. GG. That brings me up to 3/3 wins, 3/3 survival which is nice.

Watch me get killed first and lose the next game I play. X-D

On the subject of a continuing game: I might have had a little bit of trouble coming around to a KSC lynch, but there's practically no way I was doing anything else D2 than demanding marv's head. Someone probably would have picked up on KSC at some point anyway and with so many people confirmed or almost confirmed the concede was probably the only realistic decision unless KSC wanted to make a long, drawn-out fight of it.

On October 13 2015 20:13 rsoultin wrote:

also no. i was not smurfing a girl roleplaying a cowgirl @.@

Come on, rsoultin. You know you want to.

In fairness people were guessing smurf BEFORE the cowgirl thing went all the way down the rabbit hole. X-D