|
I dont have a ton of time tonight so I'll be doing more fleshed out dives of the people from my list.
From a casual glance through filters I'm feeling like BM and HtS are pretty clearly town. There are some differences in their play from what I've seen of them as town in the past, but nothing that jumps out to me as scummy.
For HtS it's tonal, shes not as vocal or as thorough as I've seen her before as town. I like most of her points though, I'm just getting some funny feels from her.
BM is totally different this game than I've seen him before. He's super active and engaged compared to what I've seen before from him as town. I'm definitely going to need to reread his filter in detail because of this, but almost everything I recall reading from him has felt very towny to me. Shift in meta vs towny behavior, I'd lean on the behavior everytime.
So from my list before I'd initially put Fidei and FF as my top scumspects.
FF looks a little worse to me, but I've found myself agreeing with some of his posts (like the one I commented on ~hr ago). Posts like these jump out at me though.
On September 18 2015 01:57 Fecalfeast wrote:Show nested quote +On September 17 2015 22:00 Tictock wrote:On September 17 2015 09:41 Damdred wrote:
I'm going to vote ff for grail at this point. He's pretty obvious town, rels is pretty obvious town.
I'm sorta short I'll be more active tommorow just doing a major party for work. This post makes me question giving FF the grail a bit. I'm thinking FF is town, but the way Damdred lists FF and Rels together as two obvious town is strange to me. I see a few posts in FF's filter that look pretty towny but I wouldn't group him with obviously town Rels. Plus ofc I'm scum reading Damdred so... @FF you are scumreading Damdred for similar reasons to me I think. How does him wanting to give you the grail affect your read on him? it does not lynchables: damdred LS BM Dandel fuck em all
On September 22 2015 06:14 Fecalfeast wrote:
I am going to work I will be back in 15 or fewer minutes. I am down for killing damdy/TT/fidei or even LS fuck it kill em all
He was also very late to join the lynch on damdred. I'd need to check in more detail but this seemed odd given how he pretty much stated he was just sheeping rayn. So doesn't care who we lynch but is last to vote for Damdred (who I'm fairly convinced was scum).
For Fidei my main issue was his WoT opening. He started with a somewhat flippant townread on LS (basically said this is how LS plays everygame, what he's used to seeing) then concludes that there is scum pushing LS. There is also a later post where he says he" found LS's defense super unconvincing" which looks a little odd given his early townread, but given the large amount of time in between posts it's hard to tell what Fidei is thinking.
So FF and Fidei would be my current bet for the last 2 scum.
I'll do some more proper rereading tomorrow when I have time and flesh this all out.
|
And don't forget those cases on me.
I wanna see em
|
Geez, GG guys.
WTF was that lynch on BM guys?
Rayn you especially... I'm shocked you jumped to that conclusion that he was Cop or Mafia and pushed an insta-lynch with a laundry list of roles for mafia to fill in >.<
GG Rels. I felt like you were going for the pocket on D1, I kept it in mind but you played really well when others didn't. Your push onto Dandel probably should have been more of a flag, but you did a good job on that case. Overall just well played.
Fidei, way to be carried. Lol.
Sorry I called you mafia FF, but I was pretty sure there was one mafia between you and Fidei. Ironically that last DayPhase was starting me on thinking one of Rels or Rayn had to be mafia as well.
Rough setup. Soon as I saw the lynch go down putting us 6/2 with 3 claims out there I knew we were eating soup. GJ of figuring out the setup. Knew there was a reason I was hoping to roll scum >.<
|
On September 25 2015 07:20 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am curious had you guys 100% won if BM hadn't been a retard?
Dude... you need to learn how to play nicer with others. Calling everyone bad and shitting on anything you don't like makes this game not fun.
You get good reads sometimes sure, but gotta cool them jets sometimes.
|
On September 25 2015 07:26 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On September 25 2015 07:22 Tictock wrote:On September 25 2015 07:20 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am curious had you guys 100% won if BM hadn't been a retard? Dude... you need to learn how to play nicer with others. Calling everyone bad and shitting on anything you don't like makes this game not fun. You get good reads sometimes sure, but gotta cool them jets sometimes. It's impossible to explain anything for people who don't even bother to read and understand the setup so...
I agree this setup is rather... advanced, and is probably best played with people who are more familiar with the setup and stuff.
Problem is this game clearly had a bunch of people in it who were unfamiliar with the mechanics. This is going to have to impact how you deal with your fellow town.
Town made bad plays all over the place this game, and Rels carried the mafia team pretty hard. Pretty much comes down to that in the end I guess.
|
On September 25 2015 07:30 LightningStrike wrote:Honestly I just got home and man that hammer on BM was super bad idk what the fuck were you guys thinking of lynching him...... Also I figured Damdred was scum and was right on him since Day 1 
Yep gj on your one read! Lol
Why on why did you claim as Pope LS? Lol
Guess I shoulda trusted more in HtS's meta.
|
Oh I should say, I know I didn't play terribly well this game so apologies for that. I didn't have as much time or focus as I woulda liked.
Mosta of the things you guys scum read me for were funny though. Like mentioning that Vivax had been afk for a long time ^.^
|
On September 25 2015 07:37 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On September 25 2015 07:36 Tictock wrote:On September 25 2015 07:30 LightningStrike wrote:Honestly I just got home and man that hammer on BM was super bad idk what the fuck were you guys thinking of lynching him...... Also I figured Damdred was scum and was right on him since Day 1 Yep gj on your one read! Lol Why on why did you claim as Pope LS? Lol Guess I shoulda trusted more in HtS's meta. I thought I would of gotten lynch honestly so that why I claimed. If it wasn't for the claim we wouldn't of lynched Damdred honestly.
Fair enough, you might be right. Though I think I was sorta townreading you before that claim. The claim threw me, mostly kus it was weird that geript visited you N1 after scum reading you but also kus the wording on that role isn't super clear.
@ Geript
Actually why did you visit him after scum reading him pretty hard? Some kinda percentage play?
|
Oh also, Dam you rayn for pointing out that Dandel was Crusader not Grandeir!!!
Like that bit of WIFOM on the soup coulda been great for us. I was sorta planning to claim crusader and bait out a fail soup.
*Noticed Rels was thinking Crusader was still alive as D3 started in their QT
|
On September 25 2015 07:51 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On September 25 2015 07:50 Tictock wrote:
Oh also, Dam you rayn for pointing out that Dandel was Crusader not Grandeir!!!
Like that bit of WIFOM on the soup coulda been great for us. I was sorta planning to claim crusader and bait out a fail soup. c'mon do you think Rels does not read the roles? ffs....
Uhh this was before you knew Rels was mafia...
Besides...
FIDEI
THERE IS THE CHANCE I AM KILLED BY BM BEING GRANDIER OR CRUSADER
IF THAT HAPPENS, FOLLOW RAYN'S PLAN AND COUNTERCLAIM TT IF HE IS NOT THE CRUSADER
He clearly thought that...
And yea Rels, after Rayn claimed and Town insta lynched BM for reasons the game was yours regardless of that. But if it had been you trying to soup LS Vivax and me, then town mighta had a shot.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
