|
Reading more into this shining thingy, there's actually a part that bothers me quite a bit:
On September 16 2015 04:40 The Shining wrote:I'm here. Post will probably be sloppy because I'm writing as I'm catching up. Show nested quote +On September 15 2015 18:34 Rels wrote:
Going to grab some lunch so I'll be AFK until later. Here is my brain right now:
Town
rayn
Vivax
TT
Maybe town
Damdred
geript
Null
FF
HTS
fidei
BM
Maybe scum
Dandel Ion
Scum
The Shining
LS
See you all later (= This post is so easy to make. I said I don't get on much Monday/Tuesday and the game started slow while I was on, with almost no one posting. I'm almost always scummed D1 because I don't like to play it but w.e, I'm used to it. I started the holy grail convo because no one was talking about anything else and I figured the sooner we settle on it, the more info we'd get from people trying to push for it for strange reasons. Better to discuss it now than leave it until the last 12-24h of day phase.-snipped- Rayn town, Vivax un-CCd town, I don't agree with Rels read of me for obvious reasons but he looks pretty solid town. -snipped- .
Going from "this post is so easy to make" as if it's supposed to come from mafia to "he looks pretty solid town" doesn't seem very appropriate.
|
On September 18 2015 00:44 Dandel Ion wrote:
vivax of all people is the one getting close
oh boy this is gonna be a tough one
It would help if you weren't playing like a bastard host with the solution on his table.
|
Bleh thread, I'm keeping my vote where it is. cba cause I'm gonna die anyway.
|
Why is damdred so unmotivated to play the game? His back and forth on LS isn't that bad, but it kinda lacks novelty to me. Doesn't quite convince me to not vote for Dam.
I can be malleable for Dandel shenannies too at this point since he didn't really try to push more on TS, but overall I feel unsure about stuff.
Still would like a BM lynch much but nobody wants that (including mafia apparently).
|
I have a sudden urge to kill a geript
|
Partly cause he says Dandel doesn't care as mafia but when I read this something vs the mods thingy, he was mafia in there and seems more active than in this game.
|
Give me something sheepable cause else I only have faith into my own case on BM.
|
On September 18 2015 05:21 geript wrote:
Like I don't have really well thought out, thoroughly developed reads on people, but the thing is that there have been a few that really stuck out to me. Fido not posting much is a big warning light. I think I posted something about him yesterday too when I thought it was deadline.
The LS points are really, really good. I don't get why people aren't sheeping them.
What ls points
|
yeah give it to me, let's trash that thing. it's not like it necessarily means that the double vote is gonna hit a witch.
|
I'm about to take my leave as I don't have permanent internet access for still like 1-2 weeks.
Going to vote Damdred as I am still not impressed by his plaý and he seems to have the best chances of getting lynched among my suspects.
I really think BM is mafia but you aren't convinced. Well, enjoy having him around I say, whatever happens I'm going to die tonight.
Remember this: My death will be announced if I die by martyring. Not sure if the actual target will be revealed atm and dont wanna check. Anyway the point is that whoever was targeted can as well role claim since mafia will know his role even if I sacrifice myself for him.
|
We don't know what shining was, period.
For that matter we don't even know what Dandel was. Maybe he was grandier, maybe he was crusader, but maybe I'm overestimating his skill.
Anyway, that was a really odd night kill. Going to revisit geript and especially rayn.
|
Who cares about all this role shit just do some old school scum hunting, nobody should ever claim in this setup.
|
Why should we lynch LS, rayn?
|
Damdred still has to die. Shining was an okay target by Dandel, we might be at two witches left without knowing it.
I still don't know why geript died though.
|
The issue is that so far I've read LS correctly in every game I was town in and when I read his filter in this one it doesn't really stick out to me. Maybe he's gotten better but I certainly haven't gotten worse.
|
Okay need reads from LS ASAP cause he didn't seem to have anyone as scum when Dandel was getting lynched. Only some thoughts about filter diving tick tock but there's not really a conclusion and he answers a question from FF on who should get the grail.
So the worst thing I can find atm is his lack of scumreads.
|
you talk about a lot but only about damdred when you are asked? there doesnt seem to be much drive at all behind that scumread tbh.
|
ok so i just looked at damdreds filter in expectation that he actually started to care by now and its absolutely not the case. his activity was already abysmal on d1 and its worse now.
he should definitely be lynched before ls who is one of the most mislynched players on the forum atm.
more once i reach my pc
|
Saying "there's no claimed check so Damdred must be green" is dumb, Nobody has any idea if the inquisitor died among the three flipped dudes, nobody has any idea if he actually checked Damdred. Hell, he might even have checked LS.
Why would you lynch LS who has like 6 pages of filter over Damdred with shitty 2 pages just cause maybe the inquisitor checked him and is a guy who can never claim until he red checked two witches for the claim to be worth it.
|
Well fuck your logic if somebody plays like mafia he is mafia and Damdred sure as hell isn't playing like town.
Doesn't matter what you people talked about during D1. The inquisitor either
is dead
didn't listen to you
might even have red checked Damdred and doesn't claim cause claiming would be idiotic if he trades himself for one witch.
He needs at least two checks before claiming can have any value and even then it's situational. Cause mafia soups us both the night after.
You guys are so fucking hung up on roles this game, it's like Guardians of the galaxy where people fuck up by basing everything on the plays around roles. Fuck your roles, lynch people who play like mafia.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
