Newbie Student Mafia XIV: Firefly - Page 97

Breshke

Australia3749 Posts

September 10 2015 12:37 GMT

#1921

Fidel mooses explanation makes no sense at all.

He doesn't believe rayn is doctor so trying to wifom the kill from not being directed at rayn makes no sense

MoosyDoosy

United States4519 Posts

September 10 2015 12:43 GMT

#1922

On September 10 2015 21:37 Breshke wrote:
Fidel mooses explanation makes no sense at all.

He doesn't believe rayn is doctor so trying to wifom the kill from not being directed at rayn makes no sense

it does make sense. i'm basically saying what i believe in while preparing for the off chance that i am wrong.

NocturneMage

United Kingdom1965 Posts

September 10 2015 16:02 GMT

#1923

I work overnight tonight so going to try and get a few things done before I take off.

On September 07 2015 11:48 Breshke wrote:
RB's aren't notified though so how do you tell the difference between if he was actually roleblocked as town doctor or if he pretend to be role blocked as mafia?

I also don't really understand why you want to rely on having one of our blue roles claim when I have shown that GB lied and for now reason other than to justify his claim.

On September 07 2015 11:49 Breshke wrote:
Do you disagree that GB lied there? If you can explain it from a town perspective im willing to listen. I'm not 100 percent GB is mafia but i feel it is very likely and i feel like we don't need a blue role to claim.

more filter diving - think Breshke is town for these posts and the concepts around them, among other things.

granted his activity is low from judging from the database, he doesn't seem to be overly pushy or elaborate in his reads, compared to what I remember of newbie 13, he was a bit more elaborate in 13, but he's justified it with being busy at uni. so I'll consider activity alone not alignment indicative.

he also rescinded a town read on GB early on without trying to give too much information away so I think Breshke is probably town (and not bussing under the guise of TMI). if someone wants to make an argument otherwise, fine and dandy, but that's what my main takeaway was.

NocturneMage

United Kingdom1965 Posts

September 10 2015 16:15 GMT

#1924

boxerfred did have some good posts early on but his activity has fallen off.

understandable that scum have a harder time fabricating things into late game, but he also claimed he had no time to play the game. considering he's gotten lynched early on in some of the games he's played due to real life I'm going to say he's town. Gut read.

only outstanding issue with him now is the lack of followup (despite subsequent posts) on contentious MD, who I have issues now for reasons I'll put in another post. but think if he could weigh in on that (he's done so for fidei, so fair play) it would go a long way. he scumread him earlier, scum lean/okay with lynch in 1580, and in 1744, he said he was sure he was scum but he wanted to look again.

what is your thought process there from what you felt in 1580 to 1744. that doesn't look clear.
what is your (final) conclusion?

would not blame a cop for checking him though if he felt it.

NocturneMage

United Kingdom1965 Posts

September 10 2015 16:55 GMT

#1925

bah I lost my post on superbia :/

anyhow

couple of issues I'll try and sum up

1 from long list post he made (post ) no follow up on scott for the clip on copcake
2 relatively noncommittal reads/stances on gb (posts 1128, 1142, 1146) granted he didn't hide it but then you get to his list post and then you see this

"That being said, after GB's weird posts (drunk/food poison stuff) at EoN I kind of expect GB to be mafia."

I mean that's something I could see people make as either alignment. I don't know how that is exclusively mafia. why wasn't he mafia for some of the other stuff he did earlier. it just reads weird to me.

I think it was fidei who wanted to eval superbia's stance on gb, looks like he didn't have one though he asked others loads of questions on him, I don't know if he wanted to avoid deliberately taking a stance or if he was confused as all hell on gb.

what does work in superbia's favour though is the mafia read on md and his followup on md. it makes sense from a town perspective. additionally his post-lynch push on fidei going off the main wagons ALSO makes sense and is logical at the time he said it.

so superbia sits null. he's also worth a cop check.

CopCake

4378 Posts

September 10 2015 16:58 GMT

#1926

Idk what the fuck rayn posted but I am laughing so hard.

NocturneMage

United Kingdom1965 Posts

September 10 2015 17:04 GMT

#1927

bah I have work 1830 until 0330. end of night is 2330, I should have a break - but I cannot promise - to look on md again before end of night

but moosy doosy

I don't understand why he found it weird I was re-evaluating copcake on the town cred/unlikeliness of hard bussing a partner d1, particularly making a call at eod. I even said the town cred wasn't absolute and I wasn't even making an absolute read on her. nothing like it. didn't like that response at all. and then going from that to me having a good point on copcake when he was screaming about the case.

unless I'm missing something. I think fidei, you said it was possible scum can bus like that but how likely? those are two different questions to me.

offhand skimming the cop/copcake thing was weird, dumb town or scum, I don't know.

also what is dumbtelling? don't think I heard that term before in newbie 13.

I didn't have the time to fully review md's latest exchanges since I have to go, but I'll see if I can extract anything from it if/when I get a break at work. for now, I'm out.

NocturneMage

United Kingdom1965 Posts

September 10 2015 17:05 GMT

#1928

On September 11 2015 01:58 CopCake wrote:
Idk what the fuck rayn posted but I am laughing so hard.

you have anything new to add?

particularly on breshke since you mentioned him. or md. both posted.

(just saying. assuming you're town, the more input, the better)

now I'm out.

Alakaslam

United States17336 Posts

September 10 2015 17:30 GMT

#1929

On September 11 2015 01:58 CopCake wrote:
Idk what the fuck rayn posted but I am laughing so hard.

He posted a memorial to TLMafiaTrolling's past antics

scott31337

United States2979 Posts

September 10 2015 17:54 GMT

#1930

My thoughts for now -

Superbia-my #1 Scum right now - very little followup - not voting the right wagons - first vote for n00bking - beyond any magic blue work - want to lynch tomorrow
MoosyDoosy - His Night 2 is espically weird - he thinks rayn's claim is fake - gets called out for bluehunting (which I sure thought he was doing as well) and then backpedals quite hard on it. My gut calls him #2 right now.
boxerfred-quiet and in the stands - although has some good posts and points - just above null.
Breshke-I've like his play n2 with moosy - trying to prod and get answers out of him - bad voting d1. He'd be above boxer.
CopCake - I just want this guy to do some more as town if he is - what are your thoughts on everybody? slight townlean, please help

Fidei86 - Helped get GB lynched, but just has been a little off - maybe he's overworked like he said in a few messages? townlean
Alakaslam - did the super phat bus on GB (voted first on him day 1, never left until he claimed, was suspicious of him all game) or he's town - not lynching anytime soon.
raynpelikoneet-Da man - I will keep the town in line and accomplish victory for us in your name!

Oh and IRL excuse - I'll be traveling out of town tomorrow/Friday and then a pool party afterwards - so expect very little posting.