not a fan of your list, but i also don't think you're mafia. kels has a thing that fucks with his vote as well and you think he is lynchable? i think all 3 of us are town and geript is town since he was supposedly double green checked and had kp blocked on him.

town:
ritoky
geript
fecalfeast
kelsier
LT - assuming some type of vigi for now, come back to it later

3p:
damdred

potential mafia:
fidei - fucked off real hard after defending himself. 0 investment this phase. makes case on HTS town, HTS proceeds to die. still think d1 case is fine and he has done very little to try and find scum or change my opinion.

rayn - subs in and does balls. not town rayn, maybe cuz sub and not initially in the game but he is giving 0 shits so pressure him until he does or lynch him.

rels - i coached him as town, he is clearly trying to impersonate someone but no idea who it is. he is playing vastly different than he did when i coached him. his reads are static, they lack depth, they are mainstream, and he has done 0 vote analysis.

breshke - ain't done shit, fidei town read him for some utter bullshit so mafia by association.

Everyone else I don't even have a strong inclination either way on.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

August 23 2015 04:09 GMT

#1586

I guess judge might also be town cuz she has had some of the same thoughts as me throughout the game but the constant images make me think his role might be ritoky and that role i would imagine is mafia aligned. so paranoia mostly keeping her out of town circle.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

August 23 2015 04:13 GMT

#1587

Both of you (OWS and ff) listed BM but not rayn in your would lynch area, why?

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

August 23 2015 04:16 GMT

#1588

On August 23 2015 13:13 ritoky wrote:
Both of you (OWS and ff) listed BM but not rayn in your would lynch area, why?

Rayn is in my "maybe" lynch pile. I made a one-off post explaining why.
/shrug

I guess I'm kind of biased because I like rayn and I don't like lynching him but I digress.

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

August 23 2015 04:17 GMT

#1589

Why do some of our only active players have roles that prohibit them from doing useful things with their votes?
So dumb.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

August 23 2015 04:18 GMT

#1590

ows what do you think of the other 3 ppl i listed then?

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

August 23 2015 04:20 GMT

#1591

and the raisins (reasons)

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

August 23 2015 04:24 GMT

#1592

I haven't really researched fidei so much so I'm whatever on him atm.
The whole "connection" between Breshke and fidei seems tenuous at best, though I do agree that Breshke is being useless and scummy.

Otherwise I think I commented on everyone else at one point or another.

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 23 2015 04:24 GMT

#1593

I honestly 100% forgot rayn was in this game, could lynch.

If fidei spewed breshke town that would imply breshke is town if fidei is mafia, no?

could lynch rels but I don't havve a very strong opinion myself on him.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

August 23 2015 04:27 GMT

#1594

On August 23 2015 13:24 Fecalfeast wrote:
I honestly 100% forgot rayn was in this game, could lynch.

If fidei spewed breshke town that would imply breshke is town if fidei is mafia, no?

could lynch rels but I don't havve a very strong opinion myself on him.

why do you think kels and i aren't town even though our roles seem to be similar to yours?

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 23 2015 04:38 GMT

#1595

over saturation of the same role archetype, I imagine one of you two is scum

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 23 2015 04:38 GMT

#1596

err not archetype, condition? idk

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

August 23 2015 04:39 GMT

#1597

I don't want to believe that ritoky is mafia.
It'll make this game infinitely more annoying than it already is.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

August 23 2015 05:14 GMT

#1598

On August 23 2015 13:38 Fecalfeast wrote:
over saturation of the same role archetype, I imagine one of you two is scum

eh maybe i am being naive and 1 of you 2 is mafia

as for the breshke spewed town thing, i don't know about that. the whole making an excuse to town read him and then scum reading you who did the same thing just read as someone town reading a partner for a cheap reason. can't really explain it much better than i have previously, that's just the feels i get.

ritoky

United States6851 Posts

August 23 2015 05:15 GMT

#1599

i mean it is day 2 and over half the game seems content or afk....we are in some shit here boyz....

Lord Tolkien

United States12084 Posts

August 23 2015 06:08 GMT

#1600

zzzzz

well, unless someone gives me a green check on afksocks, or someone turns up a red check on The Shining, I'm not saving him. I don't necessarily think the N1 deaths implicate him because they were the most vocal and active town anyways besides geript,

Additionally: a nuke is fired in thread and is resolved at the end of a cycle (day or night), but it can be shot down by an anti-nuke if its launched before the silent period (apparently that is a thing). I got a clarification on that last part, zzzzz..

Person who really really needs to be checked is rayn. FFS, people, just because you guys think his role is marv doesn't mean he'll roll town. Ive been saying this consistently. It's in the same level as "oh hey ritoky rolled BH there's an 80% chance that role is scum" shit that geript was putting out D1, and i feel really good about ritoky despite lolrngvotes.

my town circle consists of
OWS
ritoky
geript
myself
PROBABLY shining (since i doubt scum would be so brazen with a nuke; if tubes is scum then 100% confirmed)

"lol"
everyone else

beneather tier
yamato77
rayn

probably 3p, tbh
Damdred