Tropical Storm Mini Mafia - Page 34

On August 13 2015 04:36 prplhz wrote:
isn't hopeless the guy who never does anything d1?

On August 13 2015 04:32 raynpelikoneet wrote:
then lynch hopeless.
why cant any of you read anything.
this game is so bad.

On August 13 2015 01:23 Vivax wrote:
Ruxxar why isn't Damdred among your scumreads?

On August 13 2015 04:39 raynpelikoneet wrote:
if ruxxar turns out to be mafia in this game i have a lot to talk about with certain ppl.
if ruxxar turns out to be town in this game i will just vig him whenever i have a chance because he is too bad.

On August 13 2015 04:37 rsoultin wrote:
except he's not making any reads at all...he usually at least does that ^^

On August 13 2015 02:11 Vivax wrote:


Let me sum up what you said so far across different posts:

Mafia has nothing to gain from defending you.

Mafia might try to pocket you with that.

You think it's subpar mafia play to defend you.

You believe that mafia is likely to be among those who defend you without pushing something of their own.

Now you argue using "but if x flips town it makes him look bad" when it's an argument nobody is able to use reliably at this point.

I find it impossible at this point to believe anything you say.

On August 13 2015 04:42 prplhz wrote:

does he make reads as scum?

like hopeless isn't really playing so i'm trying to figure out if that's because he is scum or because of something non alignment indicative

On August 13 2015 02:20 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
I'm gonna go make a nice list post because it feels like we're just regurgitating the whole Ruxxar thing over and over again and I don't want to lynch him so it'd be great to discuss others too.

raynpelikoneet - clear town, detailed evaluations even if I think they're wrong on ruxx, and his early strong townread on me is something I don't think he would've done as mafia.

Trfel - After reading his filter I really don't know. What irks me is that he seems to just be going for the lowest hanging fruit (Chez, Ruxx, Deconduo) and his (presumably) reason to scumread me felt weak and without critical thought, and I have higher expectations than that for Trfel. He's also been inactive for Trfel standards. What makes me reluctant is that tonewise he does feel very much like townTrfel. He feels confident, but not overconfident in his reads in a way that I've come to know of townTrfel.

Rsoultin - Probably town? Some of the uncertainty in her posts feels weird as I'm used to her pushing her thoughts strongly, Rayn had a nice post on it earlier and she's been the same way with Ruxx. On the other hand she's come forth with a bunch of her own opinions and there's plenty of smileys to go around.

Damdred - I currently have no idea. Need more time.

ruXxar - Already detailed.

Palmar - Has given some reads, has not given reasons for them but has been so blatant about that fact that there would basically be no scum motivation to make them, but he's done so little that it's not much to go off.

prplhz - Hasn't done anything.
Deconduo -
VisceraEyes - Despite claiming that I meta'd him (when my points were actually all things I'd generally consider mafia traits) Rayn pointed out that he's done them as town so I'm not left with much. Cockyness suggests town.

Hopeless1der - Useless and doesn't care.

Chezinu - ?????????, he's called out Ruxxar before it was cool (after Vivax, but before Rayn) and discussed the Chezinu rule a bunch. He's made a cryptic post or two but they seem to be more setup related than reads related. Not a clue.

Vivax -

Something that worries me about my own reads is that a lot of it is tone based. Though I'm very confident in the Ruxx one it's much less so on other players. Feedback on any you agree/disagree with is appreciated.