|
On August 03 2015 10:25 rsoultin wrote:
eh maybe i'm just conceited and don't understand a ksc kill over me lol ><
Any nightkill analysis at this point is WIFOM. Maybe scum thought Kelsier was unlynchable since even I was townreading him.
IF you analyse nightkill, palmar should shoot ME since I'm the only one who starts his wagon in this game.
Best course of action is still to lynch boxerfred. I just want to be right in one of my cases tho
|
Boxerfred is basically PoE, yes + voting behaviour.
Anyway, I get a feeling that he is town, but there is nothing strong in his filter that reinforces that. I mostly see him as null.
I mean, he certainly is defending himself, but I don't see him putting too much work to point out a better lynch. He goes into Palmar mode to scumread rsoultin which kinda makes me feel that he could be sheeping someone that could possibly be mislynched?
Then there is Scott casting suspicions on Onegu unnecessarily. Argh.
|
If it wasn't for hopeless' check on Scott, I'd be forcing a lynch on him right on.
I have two WIFOM reasons to believe that we still could have a godfather role, which is
1) Hopeless died night 1 instead of being roleblocked. For some reason, I think Mafia wouldn't kill him as I was casting doubt on his claim. It would have been better to kill an almost confirmed town and roleblock him.
2) I remember HtS being annoyed by people in Himalaya that talked about not believing that she would put a godfather with a Miller and a framer in a game. She said something in the lines of "people that hosted with me should know the way I balance" and that she didn't see a problem with a framer AND a godfather
So, yeah, I'm trying to fight the WIFOM within me
|
On August 03 2015 12:50 scott31337 wrote:
So is Onegu 100% named town in your opinion?
Yes. He parked his vote on a team mate day1. I find hard to believe Onegu is scum here
|
|
|
On August 03 2015 13:20 rsoultin wrote:
we only have one blue role (hopeless) without onegu
half the other players here have nearly been lynched without ever claiming anything
the likelihood that onegu isn't named vt is pretty small imo, and we can be fairly certain after 3 nights without a shot that there's no vig. he's being lazy and not playing but that's not really any different than most of the town games i've seen him play
gb, hopeless died n2 after clarity/slam and ft were both dead. killing him actually makes it more likely that there's no gf or anything to interfere (rb) with the cop role, rather than less
i'd argue that there's nothing balanced about named vt/cop against framer/miller (lots of cop hate) and any form of a second mafia role, but that's setup wifom mixed with personal opinion
the fact of the matter is hopeless was shot and he wasn't really a great target unless his role was dangerous...or the move was specifically to deny information that would be given by shooting a more prominent player
it's just so very unlikely that scott is scum?
You mean you believe Mafia has just one role (framer)?
|
|
|
On August 03 2015 23:06 Palmar wrote:rsoultin
Other than the reaction test and Rayn's point, why?
|
On August 03 2015 23:12 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On August 03 2015 23:10 GlowingBear wrote:On August 03 2015 23:06 Palmar wrote:On August 03 2015 23:04 GlowingBear wrote:
Cool
Who do we lynch? rsoultin Other than the reaction test and Rayn's point, why? Part tone Part PoE But mostly it's just reaction test sheeping rayn so meh? I'm not 100% certain of who is the mafia. I mostly just know who it isn't.
Well, Palmar, if you are town because you couldn't hammer both your team mates, doesn't it make rsoultin more likely town because she probably won't push her scum partner clarity since day one, and won't lynch clarity when boxerfred was pratically dead?
Won't Onegu be most likely town because he parked him vote on his scum partner plus he had the balls to claim named VT?
Same to obi?
Wouldn't boxerfred be an objectively better lynch?
|
On August 04 2015 00:08 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I don't think Palmar is calling Onegu scum, GB.
He is saying Onegu is a good lynch when he is most likely town. Is that so, why saying that snickers lynch was bad?
|
For some reason my English skills is getting worse and worse and I can't explain why
I think my brain is regressing
|
Boxer you do realise you're scumreading people for their votes when you votes outside the scum wagons on both d1 and d2, right?
|
Boxer what do you think about us lynching you to get the doubt out of the way in LYLO so people can proper reevaluate their townreads?
I mean, nobody will be comfortable to lynch their townreads when they have you on the back of their heads.
|
On August 04 2015 14:34 boxerfred wrote:Show nested quote +On August 04 2015 06:49 GlowingBear wrote:
Boxer what do you think about us lynching you to get the doubt out of the way in LYLO so people can proper reevaluate their townreads?
I mean, nobody will be comfortable to lynch their townreads when they have you on the back of their heads. Do we have enough lynches for OWS AND Palmar or only for one of them?
Only one of them.
|
Welcome, moron palmar!
I expect you to do stuff, unlike the player that replaced out
|
On August 03 2015 23:24 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On August 03 2015 23:12 Palmar wrote:On August 03 2015 23:10 GlowingBear wrote:On August 03 2015 23:06 Palmar wrote:On August 03 2015 23:04 GlowingBear wrote:
Cool
Who do we lynch? rsoultin Other than the reaction test and Rayn's point, why? Part tone Part PoE But mostly it's just reaction test sheeping rayn so meh? I'm not 100% certain of who is the mafia. I mostly just know who it isn't. Well, Palmar, if you are town because you couldn't hammer both your team mates, doesn't it make rsoultin more likely town because she probably won't push her scum partner clarity since day one, and won't lynch clarity when boxerfred was pratically dead? Won't Onegu be most likely town because he parked him vote on his scum partner plus he had the balls to claim named VT? Same to obi? Wouldn't boxerfred be an objectively better lynch?
You could start answering this since the 4 days weekend is over
|
You know what?
I'm voting rsoultin
If she is scum and survives I will have to listen to palmar saying how bad we are forever
If she is town and we lynch scum Palmar in LYLO, I can say how good my case on Palmar was (and it was very good)
If she is town and we lynch town Palmar I can call him bad every future game we play together
|
|
|
It seems like a good lynch for the reasons I've brought.
+ I actually feel she is scummy tonewise
|
Obi, I've said that throghout the whole game
Why are you so annoyed that I am willing to lynch you? Will the game end if that happens?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
