? what kind of math is that. 1+2+2= 5 not 6.
Assuming so far: me 2 shots left, you 1 shot left, TT 2 shots left.
That's 5/8, so it's 3 CB for both Sulfurus and Shockey. One of them must have shot and the other defended, because they both went in N2 with 2 CB each.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

August 07 2015 00:58 GMT

#183

Humm hopefully we hear from Sulf and Sho soon so we can try and piece together what happened.

I was going to make a start on that but I'll wait till I get home.

For now what we know is that 5 players took shots ( i think we can rule out anyone loading, though its possible they just failed to send in an action) but only 3 players died. So either 2 shots hit players who were defending or they were meant for targets already being shot.

More to come...

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 07 2015 01:21 GMT

#184

I meant 5 my phone has small buttons.

yep cool stuff

Sulfurus

United States166 Posts

August 07 2015 03:09 GMT

#185

I shot

Damdred

15669 Posts

August 07 2015 04:08 GMT

#186

Who did you shoot sulf

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

August 07 2015 04:48 GMT

#187

On August 07 2015 12:09 Sulfurus wrote:
I shot

Would like to know who as well... Oh maybe he shot me ^.^ That might explain why he didn't just come out and say it...

Still that would mean Sho defended. Interesting, what prompted you to defend Sho?

Also I find it a little interesting that Damdred survived.

He clearly stated he would be shooting and did, and 2 of the people who died last night said they would shoot Damdred. I did as well but didn't shoot.

So lets assume FF shot Obi, and we know Damdred shot FF... maybe Obi shot Onegu? If so why Onegu over Damdred who he said he would... Ehh it's wifom but I can't help but wonder if Obi didn't shoot Damdred because they are mafia...

The real question is who did Onegu shoot? I suppose we'll have to wait till post game for that one.

Also for now I think it's safer to assume Damdred is town based on Obi saying he'd shoot Damdred. That wifom though...

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

August 07 2015 05:27 GMT

#188

So trying to look at how this game might play out...

We are in 4/1. Everyone has KP.

Mafia has either 1 or 2 cannonballs, and If town stops shooting then needs at least 2 nights to load.

If mafia has 1 CB then has 3 defends left + 3 loads needed.

If mafia has 2 CB then has 2 defends left + 2 loads needed.

A mafia with 2 CB is probably a higher priority target for town to deal with.

So that would potentially be Myself, Plotspot, or ShoCkeyy

A Mafia with 1 CB, wants town to shoot town because they have to play this out a week if nobody else shoots.

Obv the players left, Damdred, Sulf.

Obi said he'd shoot Damdred + Show Spoiler +

he didn't but yea he was also scum

, and Sulf is being generally townread by everyone.

So clearly Town needs to decide who is most likely to be scum out of Myself, Plotspot or ShoCkeyy.

I'd shoot Shockeyy.

Now can we all agree to stop shooting and load for a day?

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

August 07 2015 05:27 GMT

#189

Ohhh!

Or better yet.

Can we assign either Damdred or Sul to shoot tonight?

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

August 07 2015 05:36 GMT

#190

I'd also be agreeable to defending over loading, but I already used one of mine...

ShoCkeyy

7815 Posts

August 07 2015 09:41 GMT

#191

I defended, also I'm currently at a company retreat in Austin, TX so I've been limited to internet. Either way, who was targeting Obi last night? I think we can get a lot of info out of the person who shot obi and what his reasons were for shooting him. It just depends if he wants to come out and say if he did or not.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

August 07 2015 10:37 GMT

#192

Do you have any opinions on the game without knowing who shot Obi?

plotspot

800 Posts

August 07 2015 12:24 GMT

#193

Like, I don't know. Whoever comes out now and claims having shot Obi is extremely suspicious (easiest bus claim ever), you won't find that person, yea maybe Sulf or one of the dead shot him, but who knows, it doesn't matter, I grant that townies can be a bit secretive in this game. Lying is absolutely not a mafia trait here. It's proven that I've "lied" about my NA last night, TT has "lied" twice, Onegu "lied" about his N1 action and we don't know whether he really shot someone N2 either and flipped town. It's more like decision swings not being proclaimed to the thread, which is fine and in essence not any different than anyone who didn't proclaim any NA in the thread.

[UoN]Sentinel

United States11320 Posts

August 07 2015 17:19 GMT

#194

Deadline might be up to an hour late today.

Tictock

United States6052 Posts

August 07 2015 19:32 GMT

#195

Such Game...

Very active...

Anybody have ideas or opinions about who is the last scum?

...no?

Fine I'll do it myself.

I'm aiming my cannon right at ShoCkeyy