EPTMentioning #nolynch beginning of day only really hurts town. All you get is an entire day of "to lynch or not to lynch, that is the question" discussion that detracts from scum hunting (or you get early agreement from everyone and we jerk off for an entire day). Again, its an option to keep in the pocket, but no, this is absurd, especially since we can just no lynch another day.
[T][I]OT vs The Mods Mafia - Page 58
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12083 Posts
Mentioning #nolynch beginning of day only really hurts town. All you get is an entire day of "to lynch or not to lynch, that is the question" discussion that detracts from scum hunting (or you get early agreement from everyone and we jerk off for an entire day). Again, its an option to keep in the pocket, but no, this is absurd, especially since we can just no lynch another day. | ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12083 Posts
On July 08 2015 13:46 Cixah wrote: On what grounds is it stupid? You've done nothing but distance yourself from GB on d1 and d2, which I can see as being planned in the case of him get lynched in order to make yourself look better. The end of day 2 and lack of posting on either night content nor leading town during those times does you NO favors. 1) End of Day 2 shenanies would be stupid if I were scum. Like, so goddamn retarded for me to make that kind of scene, when it's highly unlikely that other people would actually follow (because lol inactivity or otherwise). 2) I did respond to you and sonib. lel If this was written by asmo I would completely lynch him over how bad the reasoning here is, imo. You get a pass because GB was pushing you as the alternate bandwagon + Show Spoiler + (it's still entirely possible you and GB were wifoming the shit out of this but eh, rather remote possibility) | ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
rip | ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
who makes NLing more retarded cuz if he's survivor or something along those lines it'd be 5-1-2 -> 4-1-2 aka MYLO for free if he's traitor like claimed we're actually in mylo today (assuming 3 other scum). which is why i would say the smartest thing to do today would be to vote him out before we go into silly scenarios where we can't afford to anymore. best case he was scum fakeclaiming to get some free coasting in and we in this. tldr policy lynch while we still can | ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
| ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
but im not because poooooooooolicylyyyyyyyynchtraaaaaaaaaaaaain i hyped it it better become a train now | ||
|
plotspot
800 Posts
On July 08 2015 10:04 jcarlsoniv wrote: Why I think LT looks scummy GB flipped red, see previous big post on LT lol. And to address your earlier post: It's really not that absurd. You believed Cixah's claim based on the fact that it was "so sketchy it makes sense" (paraphrasing). But as soon as GB came in and did a last minute claim, you wanted to pull some major shenannies. I mentioned how content he was with plotspot's original claim and how it hasn't sat right with me. The main thing giving me pause is that I find it hard to believe LT would be that dumb. He's either stupid town or really stupid scum. plotspot, on the other hand, has done fuck all except for random speculation all game. At least I have an idea of what LT's reads are... plotspot I have no fucking clue what he thinks about other people in the game. As I've typed this out, I've decided that if I had to choose between the two, I'd go with plotspot. He's more likely scum solely based off of pure feigned activity. there ain't shit to read yo Actually, if you don't believe my claim, there's no way I'm scum here. Cixah has the most suspicions about him from everyone else. No one dared townreading him. If I was scum with GB, I'd surely done everything possible to cement Cixah's status as scum. Like, how difficult is it to cast down suspicion on his claim or his general play if I just parrot GB? But I didn't. I went the way of high resistance and hard-defend and ride with him when you guys were still wondering what is what. Why, pray tell, would I do that as scum? I voted GB in a phase where everything was still undecided and stayed with it to the end . If I was scum with GB, why would I consolidate with Cixah at a critical juncture? | ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12083 Posts
On July 08 2015 20:06 Dandel Ion wrote: That said BM is pretty scummy and I'd be on #teamtolk here but im not because poooooooooolicylyyyyyyyynchtraaaaaaaaaaaaain i hyped it it better become a train now Totally fine with this as well. I was going to vote plot, but fking BM's "slip" is retarded as all fuck and reeks of bandwagon. | ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12083 Posts
| ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
And i understand that but honestly things like thoughts and feelings will just get in the way of who needs to be done today. | ||
|
plotspot
800 Posts
On July 08 2015 20:04 Dandel Ion wrote: dunno assuming 3 mafia in a 13p game is not a slip but it seems you all are forgetting about the yung coastlord who claimed 3p. who makes NLing more retarded cuz if he's survivor or something along those lines it'd be 5-1-2 -> 4-1-2 aka MYLO for free if he's traitor like claimed we're actually in mylo today (assuming 3 other scum). which is why i would say the smartest thing to do today would be to vote him out before we go into silly scenarios where we can't afford to anymore. best case he was scum fakeclaiming to get some free coasting in and we in this. tldr policy lynch while we still can This is nice and considers 100% of the cases.^^ | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
-I honestly don't think LT is that stupid. -I agree that a no lynch is not a good idea today. And the fact that LT immediately stands up against a no lynch when it seems like people want him dead today shows in LT's favor. However, I have also reaffirmed my thoughts that plotspot is very likely scum. On July 08 2015 20:06 plotspot wrote: Actually, if you don't believe my claim, there's no way I'm scum here. Cixah has the most suspicions about him from everyone else. No one dared townreading him. If I was scum with GB, I'd surely done everything possible to cement Cixah's status as scum. Like, how difficult is it to cast down suspicion on his claim or his general play if I just parrot GB? But I didn't. I went the way of high resistance and hard-defend and ride with him when you guys were still wondering what is what. Why, pray tell, would I do that as scum? I voted GB in a phase where everything was still undecided and stayed with it to the end . If I was scum with GB, why would I consolidate with Cixah at a critical juncture? Why would you do that as scum? Because then you could make this very simple post in your own defense and hope you'd be done with it. But the fact of the matter is that you made a very sketchy claim D1 and you've done absolutely nothing of value since. Like, I don't even know if you have any reads on anyone. All you've done is ride along with the chaos. ##vote plotspot Also, I'm generally not someone who does a lot of set up speculation (mostly cuz I'm not sure what a "balanced" comp would be in any given game), but I want to throw in my two cents. If scum got an extra KP in GB's nuke, wouldn't town also get an extra KP somewhere? Watcher, tracker, and martyr seem like fairly weak town roles (unless I'm misunderstanding their strength) - I would kind of expect town to have extra KP somewhere. | ||
|
ComaDose
Canada10352 Posts
| ||
|
ComaDose
Canada10352 Posts
| ||
|
Dandel Ion
Austria17960 Posts
if we do have both it kinda makes sense to have weak protection and no KP imo | ||
|
plotspot
800 Posts
my play is absolutely NAI, whatever anyone says, and I actually sided with Cixah and vote a mafia who used his (Cixah's) inexperience to get on his throat. What were you doing? Noodling with the rest? Asking wave for advice? Soniv I think you're in some serious tunnel or confirmation bias if you think I am scum when I don't even know whether I am town or scum. I have you as town. Oh is this an pocket attempt? I have Cixah as town. Oh is this a scum plot I decided on earlier with GB? I have soniv and Cixah as town. Am I parroting LT? Am I following some sort of town sentiment? I have most of my reads together, the rest of the townies are good material for interaction observation, I don't disclose them now. I disclosed my townread the day before when it was necessary to go firm with it. Lol riding chaos, lol doing nothing. All my spammy chatty posts with Dandel, BM or the HF theory were just silly night post banter if you noticed, because no real relevant info ever leaks there. | ||
|
plotspot
800 Posts
You don't consider observing and misdirection of scum some sort of a skill a townie should have, do you? For you it must be clear; I want everyone's read, I want no shenanigans, I want to know what your claim means, I want to consult wave, I want to take no responsibility if things go wrong. | ||
|
ComaDose
Canada10352 Posts
| ||
|
ComaDose
Canada10352 Posts
| ||
|
plotspot
800 Posts
| ||
| ||
