On July 05 2015 22:42 WaveofShadow wrote: So...who would actually be afraid of me considering most people think I'm shit after last game?
Probably people who weren't in the last game
I'd go GB Maybe even over 6ah today
Not a bad thought. And this helped me remember why I disliked GB D1. He pegged us both as town, me actually a bit moreso than you, I think. And he voted you for mayor on the position that you wanted 6ah lynched.
On July 04 2015 01:28 WaveofShadow wrote: I am inherently untrustworthy of you because of this you know, GB.
Got them chills that some scum are content to call me shit for last game and others will be planning on kissing my ass just to separate themselves.
I don't care. I think you're town and you've got a scumread on Cixah too
I did as well at the time (and I got more uneasy later on). I remember asking GB why he'd vote you over me based on the same criteria, but I don't recall getting an answer.
His start of D1 looked scummy to me, he did some townie contribution, LT fingered him town, GB largely disappeared again. (taking a page from LT's book) I'm beginning to think a GB, LT scum team could be likely.
On July 05 2015 22:42 WaveofShadow wrote: So...who would actually be afraid of me considering most people think I'm shit after last game?
Probably people who weren't in the last game
I'd go GB Maybe even over 6ah today
Not a bad thought. And this helped me remember why I disliked GB D1. He pegged us both as town, me actually a bit moreso than you, I think. And he voted you for mayor on the position that you wanted 6ah lynched.
On July 04 2015 01:28 WaveofShadow wrote: I am inherently untrustworthy of you because of this you know, GB.
Got them chills that some scum are content to call me shit for last game and others will be planning on kissing my ass just to separate themselves.
I don't care. I think you're town and you've got a scumread on Cixah too
I did as well at the time (and I got more uneasy later on). I remember asking GB why he'd vote you over me based on the same criteria, but I don't recall getting an answer.
His start of D1 looked scummy to me, he did some townie contribution, LT fingered him town, GB largely disappeared again. (taking a page from LT's book) I'm beginning to think a GB, LT scum team could be likely.
On July 06 2015 00:53 WaveofShadow wrote: I have reason to doubt LT and 6ah are scum now actually. They could still be but right now GB is number 1
And I could totally see why a town GB would vote me over you BTW, to me its more that he didn't take an obvious explanation for it.
Why do you think LT is scum
It's a bit hard to say that LT is scum right out. I'll say he's definitely floating away from confirmed town.
He has generally been playing with a town attitude, I think. His activity is pretty high, which argues in favor of his towniness. But he's put himself into this big loud town position from the start, making sure everyone knows it right away. Shouting the loudest about being confirmed townie (say something long enough and loud enough, eventually people start to believe it).
On July 03 2015 00:20 Lord Tolkien wrote: As no one trusts the obvious townie, I could settle for you then.
Are you suggesting that you're obvious townie?
Uh. Obviously? I am the towniest town that has ever townied this town. And anyone who doesn't townread me is the scummiest scum that has ever scummed this mafia game.
I would like to here more from him in regards to who the BEST lynch today might be, rather than who mayor should be.
You, because you're questioning obvious town.
In all seriousness, we're just over half a day into the game. If you have strong reads, I'm calling bullshit, because there's nothing to base any lynch accusation on right now besides lulz and hunches.
So he's super town, and anyone who doesn't see that is scum, but anyone with hard reads at this point is bullshitting.
Very content to just accept plotspot's claim of "you'll just have to believe me, I can say my role text".
On July 03 2015 00:19 Lord Tolkien wrote:
Also, Amnesiac claim what. That role PM.
On July 02 2015 23:26 plotspot wrote: It's like the only role you're allowed to recite with impunity. Can't have it all in the specific rules book. Would be too cluttering.
Hrmmmm. Ok then.
Actually, I wonder. This might make you the best candidate for mayor D1.
Dismissing immediately any reason to question the claim
On July 03 2015 00:50 Lord Tolkien wrote:
As for the claim, I'm willing to believe it. There's very little reason for scum to claim an unaligned role this early and draw intense scrutiny to themselves in such a manner. It doesn't even win them town points, because apparently he can still be scum. It might be a ploy to win credit to become mayor to prevent a scum-lynch D1, but lets be real.
1) That's shockingly shortsighted because by pure random chance, it's unlikely that town lynches scum because we're headless chickens right now (and are not electing obvious town to mayorship *cough*), and 2) Better for scum not to draw such intense scrutiny to themselves, and 3) he hasn't even mentioned it (unless you think I'm somehow scum partners with him since I brought it up, but that is also a stupid line of thought).
Like, right now I have no reason not to believe it, because it basically just mean's he's null for 1-2 days (I think?). Which again, since I believe it, makes him a very possible candidate for mayor.
But then kind of flipping it back on Wave
On July 03 2015 02:34 Lord Tolkien wrote: eads, I'm calling bullshit, because there's nothing to base any lynch accusation on right now besides lulz and hunches.
On July 03 2015 01:34 Cixah wrote: I still like asmo for mayor but Plot could be maybe a legit choice.
My reads on soniv still stand, he's pretty much the only person I can see as hard town atm, Wave is trying to make more sense of it though I do wish he would reconsider on me as I only have town's best interest. I do not like VE's or Mordek's posting but that's just D1 stuff from here. LT's posts have some reason to them, but still feel very alternate agenda to me. I would like to here more from him in regards to who the BEST lynch today might be, rather than who mayor should be.
Time for work, I'll be reading but probs not posting too much till I get home or after 6pm my time.
I like this. Doesn't mean you're not scum, but still.
Too much focus on roleclaiming and mayor shit. Guess what? Mayor elections don't win us the game ladies.
So you're telling me,
1) we shouldn't analyze the guy who just claimed "I might be green or red, but idk right now"
If LT has already decided that plot's claim is fine, then there should be no more need for discussion on it in his mind.
On July 03 2015 02:38 Lord Tolkien wrote: Anyways, I've decided. I'm putting Wave in OT Mafia, Episode I, category for now until he sobers up.
Also Soniv, I would probably peg you town, but you're questioning my obvious townie status. How dare you question my inane, jocular statement.
As for GB, I've played a few mafia games with him, and I'm fairly certain I know how to read him.
Do you have any leaning for GB then? I don't think I've played with him before, but his filter is pretty devoid of anything. If it weren't for that first post, he'd probably be null on my radar like the other lurky people, but that first one just makes me think "ugh, fuck you".
@VE - I need more to go on than that.
As you say, there's little to go on right now.
However,
On July 02 2015 11:07 GlowingBear wrote: By the way, I'm not voting Asmodeus
On July 02 2015 11:22 Cixah wrote: Can't give power to people who don't want it, won't give power to people who do want it. This is worse than anything else we could have discussed in our d1.
All euros read scum to me right now. Soniv is town, wave might be town. Let's party friends we've got so much more time to play games today!
Let use hear from so euros tho. Dandel. What is your favorite type of shower and is it the one you use to wipe all the scum off your face?
Can you explain those townreads?
The actual serious posts he's done so far indicate, to me at least, he's trying to gauge some reactions.
It's been awhile though, so I'll look back at those mafia games I played with him.
Also, don't trust his reads on me. Because I distinctly remember when he tried to defend me in that HS mafia game, when I was fucking around so hard and trying to get bussed D1.
On July 04 2015 05:21 Lord Tolkien wrote: GB is leaning town.
Fk no.
On July 04 2015 06:25 Lord Tolkien wrote: I'm talking about GB that sentence sonib.
1) GB posted the most townie things after I gave him a VERY VERY SLIGHT town lean read (on plotspot bandwagon, etc). Also arguing about wave.
2) I'm relying on my meta of GB. I've only played 1 game with you, and you were a breadcrumbing blue role. pfft. can't tell nuthin from that.
GB did post some townie things, I agree. But it wasn't a lot, and he was content to disappear once he had been generally accepted. It wasn't enough to convince me, but apparently it was enough to convince LT.
Towards the end of the day, LT seemed about as wishy washy on the lynch as I was - he was ok with dandelyolos onto HF or myself, or asmo or 6ah lynches as the town had been looking at them.
On July 04 2015 06:14 Lord Tolkien wrote:
If we're going yolo, I'm not opposed to Sonib. I'd rather see other people go down, but eh.
[B]On July 04 2015 09:18 Lord Tolkien wrote: Probably 6ah or asmo.
Maybe holyflare because he's still memeing after his other mafia game ended.
If GB flips red, I know who I would look to next. Otherwise, if GB doesn't flip red, then LT is more likely to just be a sad, confused townie.
I've been extremely busy, that's why I'm not posting much. I still have to catch up with the thread, I'm at page 21. I've been taking a look at the thread but no more than this.
Wave, a martyr dying in the night and you assuming you were protected AND basing that baseless wifom to scumread me because I could be AFRAID of you is extremely opportunistic
On July 06 2015 02:13 Bill Murray wrote: tolkien it's not 100% he died saving someone more like 15%
1) Why on earth would mafia shoot mordek lol, when he was also pretty clear that he would be afk for IRL reasons, (and with higher priority town shots available), and his post after death basically confirms it was saving someone. Then you take his breadcrumb post at night and it's like 95% that wave's confirmed town.
The 5% is the probability of human stupidity, either that mafia would shoot mordek (or randomly shot) or mordek saved coma over wave. But either situations are...highly improbable.
On July 03 2015 01:34 mordek wrote: Is that role claim of his actually a thing? This situation really screwed me last time lol
Can you elaborate what you mean or what happened last time?
I'm not familiar with mafia and what to expect of blue roles. Like the number to expect etc. someone fake Claimed medic and I didn't know too many blues had already been claimed and confirmed.
ok THIS POST gives himself away however so your 95 percent is utter shit
On July 06 2015 02:13 Bill Murray wrote: tolkien it's not 100% he died saving someone more like 15%
It is 100% because he confirmed it in thread with his death post (which he absolutely shouldn't have done lol, but he's new so)
It may not have been me, but considering the conversation at the time and the fact that mordek seemed to confirm after people were suspcting I had been saved, I would assume so, hence the '95%' confirmed town.
On July 06 2015 02:49 GlowingBear wrote: I've been extremely busy, that's why I'm not posting much. I still have to catch up with the thread, I'm at page 21. I've been taking a look at the thread but no more than this.
Wave, a martyr dying in the night and you assuming you were protected AND basing that baseless wifom to scumread me because I could be AFRAID of you is extremely opportunistic
Is it?
On July 04 2015 01:28 WaveofShadow wrote: I am inherently untrustworthy of you because of this you know, GB.
Got them chills that some scum are content to call me shit for last game and others will be planning on kissing my ass just to separate themselves.
EPT
