Newbie Student Mafia XI - Page 9

I've said this before. I can't emphasize how important this is. He's been lurking and posting "I'm not scum, I'm a mislynch" instead of explaining why he isn't scum or doing actual scumhunting. This isn't a townie mindset at all.

Hm, what caused the change? He says that a cop check on himself is bad because he is town, but then says that he shouldn't be lynched until he gets cop checked.

I don't think I should need to say why this is incorrect, but here goes anyway:
1. If he is in fact town, the cop check comes back green, and it's generally not good for the cop to claim a green check
2. There might not even be a cop
3. Imagine if everyone was given the right to wait for a cop check instead of getting lynched

This isn't townie at all, he's making reasons to not lynch him that he knows are bad and that he already directly contradicted.

This is Kickstart's first post back. And he didn't give a single reason for these reads.Adds a vote on Rels.
And then he switched his vote to Sulfurus, with no reason at all? What happened to Rels?

His wagon lost momentum. But Kickstart doesn't say why he doesn't want to lynch Rels any more, he doesn't say why Sulfurus is scummy until much later.

He's not interested in actually pushing Sulfurus, but complaining about getting lynched for false reasons and inactivity. I don't see him being interested in catching scum.

His read on ruXxar doesn't make any sense. It's in these two posts."So, ruXxar is scummy for all of these reasons. Oh wait, but this could also be a new town player. Sulfurus is scum though because I don't feel he's a new town player trying to figure things out."

.....

That said, his read on Oatsmaster isn't inherently bad, though I disagree with it.