[M][N]Holy Guardians Chapter 1 - Page 90

Post a Reply

Prev 1 88 89 90 91 92 121 Next

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

June 11 2015 13:54 GMT

#1781

On June 11 2015 22:49 Onegu wrote:

Show nested quote +

NHM is onegu rule. Damdred has many more reasons.

Like this just feels to me like you're trying to dissuade me from voting NHM and to vote Damdred. Which is fine I guess, but I have bias against voting for Damdred because he's one of the only people who still thinks I'm town, plus his activity has been better than I expect from a mafia Damdred.

Uuuuuggghhhh.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

June 11 2015 13:55 GMT

#1782

You raise an interesting point about him switching his read on you opportunely if true, I'll have to go look at that.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

June 11 2015 13:55 GMT

#1783

...so that I can opportunely switch my read on him. Huehuehue

milo109

466 Posts

June 11 2015 13:58 GMT

#1784

Scott your posts about the NKs was extraordinarily dumb if you're town.

Fidei86

United Kingdom2116 Posts

June 11 2015 14:03 GMT

#1785

Which are you referring to milo?

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

June 11 2015 14:45 GMT

#1786

On June 11 2015 22:54 VisceraEyes wrote:

Show nested quote +

Like this just feels to me like you're trying to dissuade me from voting NHM and to vote Damdred. Which is fine I guess, but I have bias against voting for Damdred because he's one of the only people who still thinks I'm town, plus his activity has been better than I expect from a mafia Damdred.

Uuuuuggghhhh.

Pocketing

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

June 11 2015 14:47 GMT

#1787

Fidei, you think I'm mafia for giving up after my scumread on GG was proven to be wrong. I think you should be reading me as town for that, and here's why: as mafia, after leading a mislynch I should be thinking about some form of dmg control. After all, several people had intimated suspicion of me up to that point, I should be doing something like trying to mass post or lead town or SOMETHING to pick up the pieces from the GGTemplar lynch. Not AFK out of frustration, right? That's a townie thing, no matter how you slice it. Like you could WIFOM that I did it because.....why? Why would I just disappear after very vocally and very wrongly push on GGTemplar? It's not like I can just "skate" at that point because I spent the whole cycle making people look at me and my posts. It makes no sense from a mafia perspective.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

June 11 2015 14:48 GMT

#1788

On June 11 2015 23:45 Onegu wrote:

Show nested quote +

Pocketing

And I'm a notoriously easy pocket too. That's what sucks about it.

Damdred

15669 Posts

June 11 2015 15:09 GMT

#1789

Smh.

Oneg pushes me d1 wastes his vote to fo so, only talks about me during the night (or days in scum a lot)
First thing he does next day is vote not-damdred

Ehat do I do? I say that's scummy and vote him for a bit.

Then bs about omega rule starts coming up

Damdred

15669 Posts

June 11 2015 15:13 GMT

#1790

Anyway it rests on damdred followed a thread sentiment onto one at start of d2 when it had been thread sentiment for about the whole game.

Thebsame could be said about oneg though Il not sure its alignment indicative where lots of people said ibwas scum and then he voted me and said reasons.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

June 11 2015 15:30 GMT

#1791

On June 12 2015 00:09 Damdred wrote:
Smh.

Oneg pushes me d1 wastes his vote to fo so, only talks about me during the night (or days in scum a lot)
First thing he does next day is vote not-damdred

Ehat do I do? I say that's scummy and vote him for a bit.

Then bs about omega rule starts coming up

Yeah, this is the thing that I get hung up on with regard to Onegu. He claims his reads are all good and that he's the best player in the game, etc etc, but then he uses some lazy ass metric that doesn't even make sense to determine all his scumreads?

It's offset by the fact that Onegu was playing with a death wish if he's mafia for the first couple days. That's the only problem I can see with Onegu being mafia here - it's not even like people weren't talking about him D1 - people WERE talking about him, which is the basis of his retarded rule.

milo109

466 Posts

June 11 2015 15:32 GMT

#1792

On June 11 2015 17:39 scott31337 wrote:
If Tictock dies -

## Damdred/VE/Fiei86

If I die -

Tictock/Onegu/Milo

if Onegu dies -

Damdred/Milo/VE

If Damdred dies -

NHM/Onegu/Fidei86

If VE dies

Damdred/Milo/Fidei

If Milo dies

Damdred/VE/Onegu (doubtful)

If Fidei dies

Onegu/

If NHM dies

Why do I keep forgetting about NHM?

NHM needs to die.

This is inviting mafia to get a mislynch by choosing the world they aren't in, killing the person that indicates it.

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

June 11 2015 15:41 GMT

#1793

On June 12 2015 00:32 milo109 wrote:

Show nested quote +

This is inviting mafia to get a mislynch by choosing the world they aren't in, killing the person that indicates it.

Yeah I didnt like that post...

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

June 11 2015 15:41 GMT

#1794

Whats a Omega rule?

Fidei86

United Kingdom2116 Posts

June 11 2015 15:52 GMT

#1795

On June 11 2015 23:47 VisceraEyes wrote:
Fidei, you think I'm mafia for giving up after my scumread on GG was proven to be wrong. I think you should be reading me as town for that, and here's why: as mafia, after leading a mislynch I should be thinking about some form of dmg control. After all, several people had intimated suspicion of me up to that point, I should be doing something like trying to mass post or lead town or SOMETHING to pick up the pieces from the GGTemplar lynch. Not AFK out of frustration, right? That's a townie thing, no matter how you slice it. Like you could WIFOM that I did it because.....why? Why would I just disappear after very vocally and very wrongly push on GGTemplar? It's not like I can just "skate" at that point because I spent the whole cycle making people look at me and my posts. It makes no sense from a mafia perspective.

You didn't push the KS lynch, Damdred did. But point taken.

Fidei86

United Kingdom2116 Posts

June 11 2015 17:04 GMT

#1796

Okay so I misread your post. And maybe you misread mine? I wasn't calling you scum for leading on GGT, I was calling you scum because you abandoned your push on Chocolate to lead one on GGT, only after GGT started pushing on TT (who is also my top scum read). And also because I find it extremely disconcerting that you have said some version of "I'm town" basically every other post.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

June 11 2015 18:35 GMT

#1797

On June 12 2015 02:04 Fidei86 wrote:
Okay so I misread your post. And maybe you misread mine? I wasn't calling you scum for leading on GGT, I was calling you scum because you abandoned your push on Chocolate to lead one on GGT, only after GGT started pushing on TT (who is also my top scum read). And also because I find it extremely disconcerting that you have said some version of "I'm town" basically every other post.

I didn't so much abandon my push on Chocolate as I widened my search, and I thought I nabbed GG. It's really not complicated - I was giving him a chance to come in and PROVE that he's town through action or posting or something, and GG was (from my perspective) claiming mafia with every post. So it was a thing where I became MORE certain about GG than Chocolate, so that's where my push went. You'll see though that as the day progressed and he did nothing, my scumread on Chocolate made its way back into my filter.

Saying "I'm town" is not alignment indicative, I get that you don't like it or whatever, but I do it as town and mafia in equal portions. You have to look at my play, and my pushes, and my reasoning to determine my alignment. This game I think it should be pretty obvious, and that's why I say it.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

June 11 2015 18:39 GMT

#1798

Ritoky's reads also played into it, because he died. Like, I was suspicious of Chocolate and Ritoky made a note that if Chocolate is mafia then GGT is probably mafia with him. That's what made me start scrutinizing GGT in the first place, and ultimately scumread him based on our interactions. Look at how he goes from having NO read on me and chocolate to suddenly having a scumread on me after I scumread him for (what I perceive to be) good reasons. That CEMENTED my read of GGT - he started using things that had happened D1 to say I'm mafia when NOT EVEN HOURS BEFORE had said that he filtered me and nothing stood out as suspicious. He was fabricating reasoning to be suspicious of me, in spite of the fact that he was town, and that made me scumread him.

It IS (generally speaking) all in my filter. And my filter isn't inconsiderable, all things considered.