|
I think it's legit it's based around small things though that are hard to quantify.
Like oneg just isn't playing carefree has none of his usual town traits hasn't true to make any plays. Hos only read on 27nb followed thread sentiment to an extent and then basically for no reason he said he didn't have it anymore but continues voting for 27nb anyway. Nb hadn't done anything more than she had previously imo and didn't deserve the flip of you are hard Scum reading someone.
Fuba had two really bad posts if,an remember. He super over explained his vote on Geript and doesn't even believe that Geript is Scum but is just a keeping to sheep. His next post h puts Scum on Yamato for over explaining his vote on geript? It's extremely hypocritical to an extent and he's not really Scum hunting being actively involved and jus hopping on a lynch and leaving
|
On May 24 2015 05:01 geript wrote:
Because I'm town. Because people at best are using lazy awful meta. Because HF is just calling me a liar when im not; in the worst it's a difference of opinion/PoV. Yam's "case" is anything but.
This is hardly the specifics I was looking for.
I think the best point on you is the one that sandroba brought up about your bunnies read and how you wanted it to be both a joke and serious at the same time. Explain that to me.
Also, who is mafia? Cuz it probably isn't sandroba based on the fact that 2 of my top scum reads are the 2 votes on him. Find me a mafia to lynch if I am not lynching you.
|
Respond to my points ritoky
|
On May 24 2015 05:05 Damdred wrote:
I think it's legit it's based around small things though that are hard to quantify.
Like oneg just isn't playing carefree has none of his usual town traits hasn't true to make any plays. Hos only read on 27nb followed thread sentiment to an extent and then basically for no reason he said he didn't have it anymore but continues voting for 27nb anyway. Nb hadn't done anything more than she had previously imo and didn't deserve the flip of you are hard Scum reading someone.
Fuba had two really bad posts if,an remember. He super over explained his vote on Geript and doesn't even believe that Geript is Scum but is just a keeping to sheep. His next post h puts Scum on Yamato for over explaining his vote on geript? It's extremely hypocritical to an extent and he's not really Scum hunting being actively involved and jus hopping on a lynch and leaving
well i like the fuba read quite a bit. i was getting similar feels from him where he was just floating into lynches rather than actively seeking lynches on scum targets. plus i am a sucker for hypocrisy making people mafia.
the onegu one. to me he is literally doing nothing all game long. for some people that is alignment indicative, for onegu i am not sure. i have seen him doing a whole lot of nothing as both alignments. you have a tone read there and you don't think nb did anything to alter his read, i don't have those same feels.
i don't know if these should be the lynches today though, i think they should be high on the list tomorrow. i am interested as to why your focus fell here though. do you not like geript/nb/sandroba lynches? i am not used to you targeting inactives day 1 as either alignment.
also you had a town read on FF, still have it?
|
Thanks for bothering to read my case on Sandroba where that's literally fully explained! Thanks for reading all of my previous posts where I've commented on this shit. Do you really need me to tell you that Yamato's argument boils down to "he's doing one thing he did in a scum game once" without comparing it to any of my town games. For example, when I hardcore tunneled somebody for a read on Rayn that made him 100% scum all D1 and most of N1. Btw, HF was in that game. Or how about the fact that yam is 100% sure of me when he hasn't read me as anything but town. Or how HF is basically saying "he's totes mcgoats lying" when at worst it's a difference of opinion (really I'm right though not that anyone's actually bothered to look). Or how about Sandroba whose case on me boils down the same argument they use on ancient aliens to "you did this thing that I'm at best misconstruing and therefore find super scummy so you're mafia."
None of those are things that make me anything. A lot of my town play is replicated in my scum play and vice versa. Like right now people clearly aren't reading let alone thinking about anything I'm writing or have written.
|
Seriously. Please continue to be lazy and ask me to find scum when I've posted my thoughts pretty clearly.
Literally zero fucks given at this point. Like don't bother asking me shit if you haven't bothered to actually read what I've already written.
|
i read your shit. it didn't convince me.
i do like how you don't give a shit about getting my vote though. that's either cuz you're resigned or town...kinda wanna lynch nb over you now.
|
On May 24 2015 05:05 Damdred wrote:
I think it's legit it's based around small things though that are hard to quantify.
Like oneg just isn't playing carefree has none of his usual town traits hasn't true to make any plays. Hos only read on 27nb followed thread sentiment to an extent and then basically for no reason he said he didn't have it anymore but continues voting for 27nb anyway. Nb hadn't done anything more than she had previously imo and didn't deserve the flip of you are hard Scum reading someone.
Fuba had two really bad posts if,an remember. He super over explained his vote on Geript and doesn't even believe that Geript is Scum but is just a keeping to sheep. His next post h puts Scum on Yamato for over explaining his vote on geript? It's extremely hypocritical to an extent and he's not really Scum hunting being actively involved and jus hopping on a lynch and leaving
If it makes you feel any better, I don't really like my posting so far either. I'm also incredibly unsure of my reads. It's almost as though I'm working from a lack of information or something.
However, I'm not being at all hypocritical. Given that I have a total of one post that actually says anything, I summarized my thoughts on geript (who if I'm being honest, I really don't want to lynch anymore, but don't really have an alternative). Yamato, on the other hand, has at least a full page of posts, about half of them revolving around geript. I said I found it odd that given how much he's already talked about geript, it's strange that he feels the need to elaborate on why he's going along with HF's wagon. Like, he's been on it for a significant portion of the game. It rubbed me the wrong way, and I mentioned it. Now that I've had more than 20 minutes to think about it, it probably means nothing at all.
|
fuba what are your town reads?
|
On May 24 2015 05:19 ritoky wrote:Show nested quote +On May 24 2015 05:05 Damdred wrote:
I think it's legit it's based around small things though that are hard to quantify.
Like oneg just isn't playing carefree has none of his usual town traits hasn't true to make any plays. Hos only read on 27nb followed thread sentiment to an extent and then basically for no reason he said he didn't have it anymore but continues voting for 27nb anyway. Nb hadn't done anything more than she had previously imo and didn't deserve the flip of you are hard Scum reading someone.
Fuba had two really bad posts if,an remember. He super over explained his vote on Geript and doesn't even believe that Geript is Scum but is just a keeping to sheep. His next post h puts Scum on Yamato for over explaining his vote on geript? It's extremely hypocritical to an extent and he's not really Scum hunting being actively involved and jus hopping on a lynch and leaving well i like the fuba read quite a bit. i was getting similar feels from him where he was just floating into lynches rather than actively seeking lynches on scum targets. plus i am a sucker for hypocrisy making people mafia. the onegu one. to me he is literally doing nothing all game long. for some people that is alignment indicative, for onegu i am not sure. i have seen him doing a whole lot of nothing as both alignments. you have a tone read there and you don't think nb did anything to alter his read, i don't have those same feels. i don't know if these should be the lynches today though, i think they should be high on the list tomorrow. i am interested as to why your focus fell here though. do you not like geript/nb/sandroba lynches? i am not used to you targeting inactives day 1 as either alignment. also you had a town read on FF, still have it?
Firstly FF is really towny I think. He's one of the people I'm most sure of here.
I don't think I like a 27nb lynch today, I liked her yesterday today it's been a bit worse but I don't think I would lynch today.
Sand and Geript I'm not sure, sands absence is a bit worrying at this jubcture but I still think when he was in the thread the way he went about things I liked. I wouldn't lynch him today at All.
Geript is a bit different. I think he's taken a lot of heat for inconsistencies in some of his reads and not trying to jeep up with things and just dropping them. However (here comes the pitchforks), I remember Geript doing almost exactly this as town before.
Impeial mafia Geript got,lynched for some of the same things. His outbursts and spoke things remind me of alythern mafia where I pinged him out early as town (he was town). Some of the frustration and anger seem genuine. Granted there are problems with Geript I think hf pointed out things with merit.
I kinda want to give him more time as I get better then longer I am in the game with him reading him.
And Yea I generally don't go for lurkers early, unless something really sticks out to me. I caught gobble in a game he was lurking because I saw something that was scummy/caught,my attention.
Fuba has caught my attention and wouldn't engage me. Even though hew as here
|
IM here catching up. I am a terrible lynch btw. I claimed VT that obv means I am VT...
|
HF, rso, you, kinda VA
(those not on the list aren't necessarily scummy to me, just really unsure... not that I'm not unsure of the ones on the list either XD)
|
On May 24 2015 05:43 Onegu wrote:
IM here catching up. I am a terrible lynch btw. I claimed VT that obv means I am VT...
never again -.-
|
On May 24 2015 05:43 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On May 24 2015 05:19 ritoky wrote:On May 24 2015 05:05 Damdred wrote:
I think it's legit it's based around small things though that are hard to quantify.
Like oneg just isn't playing carefree has none of his usual town traits hasn't true to make any plays. Hos only read on 27nb followed thread sentiment to an extent and then basically for no reason he said he didn't have it anymore but continues voting for 27nb anyway. Nb hadn't done anything more than she had previously imo and didn't deserve the flip of you are hard Scum reading someone.
Fuba had two really bad posts if,an remember. He super over explained his vote on Geript and doesn't even believe that Geript is Scum but is just a keeping to sheep. His next post h puts Scum on Yamato for over explaining his vote on geript? It's extremely hypocritical to an extent and he's not really Scum hunting being actively involved and jus hopping on a lynch and leaving well i like the fuba read quite a bit. i was getting similar feels from him where he was just floating into lynches rather than actively seeking lynches on scum targets. plus i am a sucker for hypocrisy making people mafia. the onegu one. to me he is literally doing nothing all game long. for some people that is alignment indicative, for onegu i am not sure. i have seen him doing a whole lot of nothing as both alignments. you have a tone read there and you don't think nb did anything to alter his read, i don't have those same feels. i don't know if these should be the lynches today though, i think they should be high on the list tomorrow. i am interested as to why your focus fell here though. do you not like geript/nb/sandroba lynches? i am not used to you targeting inactives day 1 as either alignment. also you had a town read on FF, still have it? Firstly FF is really towny I think. He's one of the people I'm most sure of here. I don't think I like a 27nb lynch today, I liked her yesterday today it's been a bit worse but I don't think I would lynch today. Sand and Geript I'm not sure, sands absence is a bit worrying at this jubcture but I still think when he was in the thread the way he went about things I liked. I wouldn't lynch him today at All. Geript is a bit different. I think he's taken a lot of heat for inconsistencies in some of his reads and not trying to jeep up with things and just dropping them. However (here comes the pitchforks), I remember Geript doing almost exactly this as town before. Impeial mafia Geript got,lynched for some of the same things. His outbursts and spoke things remind me of alythern mafia where I pinged him out early as town (he was town). Some of the frustration and anger seem genuine. Granted there are problems with Geript I think hf pointed out things with merit. I kinda want to give him more time as I get better then longer I am in the game with him reading him. And Yea I generally don't go for lurkers early, unless something really sticks out to me. I caught gobble in a game he was lurking because I saw something that was scummy/caught,my attention. Fuba has caught my attention and wouldn't engage me. Even though hew as here
Fuba is here now.
Also I have a completely different read on FF. He has consistently underwhelmed me over the course of the game. Like he has been taking a backseat in convos that I feel he would normally try to push to the forefront of.
|
On May 24 2015 05:45 fuba wrote:
HF, rso, you, kinda VA
(those not on the list aren't necessarily scummy to me, just really unsure... not that I'm not unsure of the ones on the list either XD)
Oh, and I think I have a town read on prplhz as well.
|
And sorry for the doublepost, but I'm only here for about 10 more minutes. I'm on my lunch break and it took 10 minutes after I got my food for them to bring me my drink -_-
|
Fuba who would you lynch today.
Rit how isn't he pushing things that are interesting to him forward? His case on me isn't that bad it's built around a meh event but it's applicable
|
Day 1 Vote Count
geript (5): sandroba, Holyflare, rsoultin, yamato77, prplhz, fuba
27ninjabunnies (2) prplhz, sandroba, Onegu
sandroba (2): Fecalfeast, geript, 27ninjabunnies
Damdred (2): Holyflare, rsoultin, Fecalfeast, VayneAuthority
VayneAuthority (0): yamato77
Holyflare (0): rsoultin
Fecalfeast (0): prplhz
rsoultin (0): Onegu
Not voted (2): Damdred, ritoky
Currently, geript is set to be executed. Day 1 ends in at 22:00 GMT (+00:00).
The voting thread is located here.
Posting after the deadline and before the flip will result in a modkill.
|
On May 24 2015 05:55 Damdred wrote:
Fuba who would you lynch today.
Rit how isn't he pushing things that are interesting to him forward? His case on me isn't that bad it's built around a meh event but it's applicable
he gave that crappy lurker read post, i don't really pay much attention to people's cases on you since i trust me more; but most importantly he has sat outside of the primary sandroba vs geript debate and really steered clear of interacting with HF at all. these are things i would have expected a town FF to do and he has not done at all. he is about to end day 1 with no real substantive stances on geript, sandroba, or HF after they have dominated the past 20 pages. that is what is underwhelming me.
|
On May 24 2015 05:55 Damdred wrote:
Fuba who would you lynch today.
Rit how isn't he pushing things that are interesting to him forward? His case on me isn't that bad it's built around a meh event but it's applicable
I don't know. There's something about geript's response to being the lynch that makes me uncomfortable about actually going through with it.
Possibly 27nb? I don't like how within 15 minutes, she'd apparently forgotten whether or not her onegu read went from null->town or from town->null. Though that pay just be different phrasing than I would expect.
I've spent nearly all of my time so far trying to come to a conclusion about geript, so my thoughts on most other players are little more than tone reads or "I thought that, they think that, so they're probably town"-reads.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
