Assassination Mafia! - Page 7

On May 16 2015 02:33 KelsierSC wrote:
I already gave reasons why I scumread the people I put on my list. Writing it again because you are too lazy to read filters seemed a waste.

On May 16 2015 07:14 KelsierSC wrote:
I'm torn between Onegu, Oats and Obi.

my read on oats I am not particularly confident in, it was mainly based on his sniping of me around EOD and his voting of me and rudeness.

with obi I think he's mafia but some other people think he's town, I don't really feel confident on this.

With onegu he hasn't offered anything memorable to the game and has a minimal contribution, I liked the case that HtS brought up against him and I think that the vote EOD looks poor for him as he was deliberately not on either of the two town wagons , like palmar.
Another more long term reason is that it will give me more information about obi and the state of the game right now, if onegu is mafia it probably means we have hit more mafia due to his lack of resistance to the lynch and his apparent low morale.

##vote onegu

On May 16 2015 07:14 KelsierSC wrote:
I'm torn between Onegu, Oats and Obi.

my read on oats I am not particularly confident in, it was mainly based on his sniping of me around EOD and his voting of me and rudeness.

with obi I think he's mafia but some other people think he's town, I don't really feel confident on this.

With onegu he hasn't offered anything memorable to the game and has a minimal contribution, I liked the case that HtS brought up against him and I think that the vote EOD looks poor for him as he was deliberately not on either of the two town wagons , like palmar.
Another more long term reason is that it will give me more information about obi and the state of the game right now, if onegu is mafia it probably means we have hit more mafia due to his lack of resistance to the lynch and his apparent low morale.

##vote onegu

On May 15 2015 03:31 Half the Sky wrote:
14/60

A few points - Xatalos shot was not a bad one IMO (I mean seriously, he's fallen off again) although seeing his flip would have been really nice. I really do hope there is a coroner around this game.

My take on Onegu:

Argument between him and rsoultin - based on tone as I said before D1, I was seeing both town and scum tendencies in him. I was very torn that he's going after Rasputin, although basd on meta a key thing that made Rasputin scum was her tendency to hesitate for a post or two when people scumread her. She has adapted her scumgame well, but this game given the reasoning she's had particularly her long novel on n1, really makes me believe she's town.

Yeh the formatting of her posts has hurt my head sometimes, but her reads are pretty clear even if she doesn't use the exact language to scumread someone (ie this person is scum).

The key argument against Onegu regarding the case on Rasputin - to put it in one sentence - is that he's using ONE scumtell on her (instead of multiple that there are, and that he IS aware of, per our experience in NSM7) and a key scumtell I haven't seen is her hesitation for 1-2 posts before she responds if she is scumread. It's hard to articulate, but I haven't seen it here, and he's ignored that particular tell.

Separate from this argument, he's been pushing LS, who I also don't like this game at all either (but that's a separate issue) though I see he's claiming a blue role as well.

I'd say my biggest issue with Onegu is that he's really sparse with the scumreads. There are 4 scum remaining so if LS is blue, who is he scumreading now?

Basically your lynch isn't a bad one at this point.