Newbie Student Mafia IX - Page 40

On May 05 2015 07:41 Half the Sky wrote:


After he answered my last case post - I was willing to leave him alone. Right now, I'd say a weak town read. I am looking for the quotes of where he answered my latest concerns.

On May 05 2015 07:34 Superbia wrote:
Celestial did she really pick a fight with y0su? She did not reach ANY conclusion with that post.

Sum up what she has done today in one sentence and then tell me it's townie.

On May 05 2015 07:42 -Celestial- wrote:


I'd say that quotes like this are pretty aggressive:
"Your last two posts indicate to me you aren't reading the thread at the very least, or not considering/ignoring context"
"It's circular reasoning that quite frankly not only makes my head spin, but makes me wonder if you're coming up with a read for the sake of coming up with a read."

And she was pushing fairly hard for some justifications from y0su's very vague 'feeling'.


One sentence? She's played it safe by following up on things said prior.

I dislike that there's nothing particular bold in there, but I don't find it to be particularly alignment indicative either. She could either be mafia taking refuge in posting a few things and leaving it there or a townie willing to pick at a few things that are ongoing and wait for the first lynch before going for something a bit more aggressive when she has more information.

On May 05 2015 07:43 Half the Sky wrote:


And I'm not going to flip mafia. You're looking for a mislynch here. You are saying my reads are wrong, Anyone can say anyone's reads are bullshit but you haven't clarified why.

I'm getting complete scum vibes from prplhz, and I've refuted him and ritoky (who I'm less sure of being scum), last I had a weak townread on him. I don't have a problem with people scumreading me, I have a problem though with how people do it. I could see ritoky's thought processes more clearly and I was able to iron out, not with prplhz. And much less with you right now.

On May 05 2015 07:43 disformation wrote:
Not changing my vote.
Superbia is just looking like he wants to confuse the hell out of town.

On May 05 2015 07:43 Superbia wrote:


This is not town play. She's mafia or a PR. Straight up.

On May 05 2015 07:45 Half the Sky wrote:


Superbia, this is about as simple as it gets. If someone looks scummy, you question it. If your concerns resolve, you move on. If not, you push for their lynch.

Why are you making something more complicated than it needs to be?

On May 05 2015 07:46 Superbia wrote:


This guy is probably mafia.

On May 05 2015 07:49 Half the Sky wrote:


I explained to ritoky the same thing I explained to you - first off, this is D1. There is definitely a world in which D1, no one has flipped, and two townies have different perspectives where they reach different conclusions on people. I already beat ritoky to death why I'm not townreading him as hard. He is definitely NOT a lynch, let alone a number one lynch.

The push on me is at best OMGUS, but you are really appearing desperate to get a lynch off, and I already explained the passive game, assuming you mean my activity.