|
On April 19 2015 14:48 The Shining wrote:
I guess by page 7 I should've expected you guys to be a bit more serious. My bad.
Trfel, any time I've played with you as town, you're able to have a light joking presence. Take, for instance, scumming the slot you replaced in right from the start in our last game. I'm surprised you of all people didn't see the lightness in my post. It's a light toneread but I don't see your normal towniness. Won't necessarily scum you right away though since you mentioned the thread was slow. You're at least trying to push conversation, which town needs right now.
The validity of your read on Bourne? Like I said, he's a newbie that just got mislynched to lose a game for town. His posts aren't indicative to me, as I could easily see them coming from the perspective of a newbtown whos main thought right now is to avoid being put in that position again.
it's more like page 4 on page 7 in a sense
|
Hey veterans here.
What is your experience about inactive players that come to thread with post stating their reason for inactivity and haven't posted at all.
How many times they have been scums? I mean just inactivity on day1 gives them like "free" day. Less posts, less scumhunting on them.
|
|
|
On April 20 2015 01:03 TheBloodyDwarf wrote:
Hey veterans here.
What is your experience about inactive players that come to thread with post stating their reason for inactivity and haven't posted at all.
How many times they have been scums? I mean just inactivity on day1 gives them like "free" day. Less posts, less scumhunting on them.
it's null for me at least
i can give you my reasoning though... the game started last night and i was asleep the entire time other than waking up in the middle of the night playing neverwinter with my friend for a few hours before going back to bed. try to read something out of that LOL
i mean im not even giving my reasoning for my vote because if you want to really learn you need to look at why im voting for trfel in the first place and ill give you a hint it's not his large post. it's not just a tone read either.
|
On April 20 2015 00:32 Damdred wrote:
What do you think of truffle ignoring me ls Okay, Damdred. Now that LightningStrike has answered, what is your answer?
And Bill Murray, could you please provide a reason for your vote?
|
i dont give reasoning to scum why would that help the town? you would only be able to adapt better.
|
On April 20 2015 01:17 Bill Murray wrote:
i dont give reasoning to scum why would that help the town? you would only be able to adapt better. First, because you are wrong and I am town. Voting without explanation is really bad because if you are wrong (people are wrong very often in mafia), you aren't open to discussion. So you're intentionally limiting yourself from information you could have.
Second, and more importantly, because other people here are town, regardless of my alignment. And everyone needs to be able to figure out your alignment, which can't be done if you don't provide reasons for your votes.
Anyway, I need to head out now.
|
I am not scum, give me your reasoning Bill, I'd love to vote trfel. He is trying a bit too hard.
|
my reasoning is that 1) he is trying to scumandeer the game
a. this could be as town, referred to as spotlighting
b. this could be as scum, which i think it is here
2) he ends the RQS early
a. this is hypocritical of him given his last post (where he assaults me for stifling information)
b. his head is up his own ass regarding this which is a reason he is cancerous and toxic to the town (big posts suck)
3) for having spotlighted, he is already giving excuses
a. he said he had to go before
b. he actually STUCK AROUND to see if anyone said anything about him before saying he had to go again
TL:DR don't be apologetic if you're spotlighting.
|
spotlighting=scumandeering
his last post admittedly has me a little unsure of my vote because his "i am town" kind of rings true to me in tonality
you can say i slip here but when i flip itll be the same as last game
|
... Trfel I've made several posts toward you. One in particular about bou read you did. And you never responded towards that.
Also you feel like you are forcing the New players into town reading you by using all of the null helpful stuff. So yea, you aren't playing really town sided atm just Trfel siding to me.
|
PS I'm Vanilla Townie and we need a massclaim in all likelihood. If scum don't CC power roles we will likely have around a 60% chance to win
|
On April 20 2015 00:58 Bill Murray wrote:
im not reading that post trfel although i bet it is VERY TELLING
|
There is 1 role that should be claiming. Cop.
|
If you are a pr don't claim. Scum knows the setup already play like normal town.
|
This is probably not going to be a high postcount game.
|
DO NOT CLAIM PRs. Why would cop claim without a redcheck? Even WITH a redcheck, cop should be able to case and push a lynch and only resort to claiming as a last minute thing.
Damdred slight town lean for calling out Trfel on using null arguments/posts to try and build town cred. He's analyzing the game, somewhat, though he's been pinging Trfel a lot. Damdy, what do you think of Bill?
Where are the rest of the players? 
|
On April 20 2015 01:22 Bourneq wrote:
I am not scum, give me your reasoning Bill, I'd love to vote trfel. He is trying a bit too hard.
Why does trying hard = scum?
|
Because this is a different trfel than from the last game I just came from where he was town.
And making a huge post like that and trying hard to look like town seems forced and not genuine, like it comes from a scum perspective. It could be motivated from both alignments as I've stated before but I am getting a scummy vibe.
Obi why do you not think this will be a high postcount game?
|
It just doesn't seem like it's going to be high activity.
It's kind of a disheartening start but maybe it's just because it's the weekend. W/e.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
