Game of Thrones Mini Mafia

On April 20 2015 02:20 Koshi wrote:
What do I have to do to not get lynched?

On April 17 2015 08:51 GlowingBear wrote:


I didn't like this post because it sounded very forced and it is useless when he started to inquire WoS for talking about unrelated and not game-solving focused posting. Feels like an unsuccessful effort to appear natural


Uncalled for, Unreasonable justification just to call himself a town. Uncharacteristic since his common town stance is "leave it to me, I've got all figured out!"



Unreasonable ranting, specially towards a game that is slow but nothing bad to call it terrible and to omgus for fun. Just an excuse to vote.

Conclusion: SL is Mafia

On April 20 2015 06:48 Koshi wrote:

Why is Palmar mafia VA?

Shouldn't he be null?

On April 20 2015 07:42 sicklucker wrote:
inc hf bus.

Gb will probably come back with something weak later. But remember this moment when he froze and ran away from the thread

On April 20 2015 08:27 Koshi wrote:
Damn. At this rate I will never get lynched. I like it.

/bows to Mr. Vayne


Tbh playing and not getting lynched feels pretty good.

On April 20 2015 23:03 Koshi wrote:
No. I read it and it is just a plynch. Which might have changed when artanis came back around EoD. Which is when Artanis became null. So GB his case doesn't make any fucking sense if you take into fact that people can change their reads.

Anyway. Sicklucker is a townhero. Never scumread.

On April 21 2015 02:46 WaveofShadow wrote:
VA
I mean...probably lynch this guy.
The sad part is he has actually done more than Koshi in this game with a smaller filter since he has actually provided reads (though mediocre). Again trying to ignore meta here so based on his play alone in this game he has proven to be completely disinterested and unhelpful, but again not as much as Koshi so while I'd lynch him, he actually probably ends up lower priority.
Verdict: probably lynch

On April 21 2015 06:06 Koshi wrote:
Dnu. Oats looks best bet out of the lurkers. Not sure though. He got votes fast.

On April 21 2015 05:33 GlowingBear wrote:
Fuck this
I want to lynch SL first
If impossible, I want to lynch HF
If impossible, I'll lynch Koshi
I will lynch no one else.

I'm pretty certain this is the scum team + Koshi is intentionally trying to piss WoS off, reinforcing the argument that Koshi is mafia with them.

On April 18 2015 13:29 GlowingBear wrote:


The wrong thread is strong in this one

On April 21 2015 02:51 WaveofShadow wrote:
Onegu
The fact that in just 2 minutes of conversation with him I was able to make him all but forget about all of his reads/change his mind truly does not suggest mafia despite his below-par play. Pretty easy townread here imo.
Verdict: do not lynch

Oats

Comes in to thread every so often, snipes at people and disappears. Does not actually appear to have any stake in this game at all, no proper reads, no proper motivation. I'm unsure where he could even be townread at all to be honest (though I'm not considering meta here, and have no desire to).
Verdict: would lynch

On April 21 2015 06:39 Koshi wrote:
Because why is Onegu not talking about his scumread getting lynched? Instead quoted a post of the counterwagon and said "this looks strange"

Onegu is totally different from town Onegu on multiple fronts.



1) scum Onegu is on scum Oats and wants away.
2) scum Onegu is on town Oats and wants to leave.
3) Town Onegu is not liking his own lynch and wants to go to GB. But why?


Onegu filter around GB:








So why is he posting things about GB? meh.

On April 19 2015 04:34 Vivax wrote:
HF and SL both acting scummy since EoD by insisting on false representations of me + all the other stuff me and Wave said, him saying that anyone not voting LS was scummy etc., he should know better than that.

IIRC he also said he didn't post cause strategy and this night he said he didn't post cause busy, so what now?


SL shows zero distrust towards people who afkd on Artanis and didn't post shit at EoD and instead says I'm afraid to hammer people when I couldn't and instead kept pushing my preferred lynch.

This seems like the sort of push where he'd either say that me not hammering is scummy, or as displayed during the night he says I spitevote people, which means that if I hammered he'd probably say I'm scummy for hammering somebody I wasn't pushing. Really sketchy stuff especially since he was one of the people being afk most of the time and then instantly joining HF on LS and blowing into the same trumpet with him regarding people who didn't vote LS, skipping over the stuff they already said in my case.

Wave is most likely town, I'll go with Oats being town, and with Artanis being town cause the latter showed many preferences at EoD and pretty much wanted to vote the same people as me. I just wonder why he was so trusting of HF cause given how he played out D1 that's something I don't see as rational.

On April 21 2015 06:39 Koshi wrote:
Because why is Onegu not talking about his scumread getting lynched? Instead quoted a post of the counterwagon and said "this looks strange"

Onegu is totally different from town Onegu on multiple fronts.



1) scum Onegu is on scum Oats and wants away.
2) scum Onegu is on town Oats and wants to leave.
3) Town Onegu is not liking his own lynch and wants to go to GB. But why?


Onegu filter around GB:








So why is he posting things about GB? meh.

On April 21 2015 05:48 Holyflare wrote:
yeh gb's list is like 3 townies

On April 21 2015 07:52 Holyflare wrote:



^ remember this for when people scummy switch to me in like 5 minutes

On April 23 2015 03:27 GlowingBear wrote:
It matters. He had the same reads as you.
Why would SL, who has the same reads as you, but has not even 1/10 of your leadership, dies instead of you?

On April 24 2015 00:00 Koshi wrote:

Hmm? I don't actually think GB is more mafia than you. I am voting town to end the game.

On April 23 2015 23:59 Holyflare wrote:
you've made less than 1 page in this game in 96 hours

On April 24 2015 02:59 Koshi wrote:

What? I am not.

On April 21 2015 02:46 WaveofShadow wrote:
VA
I mean...probably lynch this guy.
The sad part is he has actually done more than Koshi in this game with a smaller filter since he has actually provided reads (though mediocre). Again trying to ignore meta here so based on his play alone in this game he has proven to be completely disinterested and unhelpful, but again not as much as Koshi so while I'd lynch him, he actually probably ends up lower priority.
Verdict: probably lynch

Sicklucker
Ugh.
He just looks so ass, but there are so many things in his filter that make more sense from a sicklucker town point of view. The main thing I currently have a problem with is the pushing of the vig angle. I actually have decent answers for GB's accusations against him even though he doesn't address them particularly well himself and whether or not he articulates himself well, they make sense to me. For example this section of GB's case is probbaly what GB himself describes as the most egregious infraction:

The thing I see here is not dissonance at all though, he's simply framing it from an outside point of view in the final sentence. I see nothing in his thoughts that suggest a disconnect from that the entire game, which honestly worries me just a little bit more. I'm going to come right out and say this because I truly don't think it makes a difference in this game at all.

SL himself could very well be the vig and thus actually knows what's going on, or he could also be scum, and knows exactly what's going on. The fact that he is consistently pushing a view that nobody else in this game shares suggest extraneous knowledge, or of course, just weird/bad/terrible/etc play from town but I think the former might make more sense here, and I'm not sure I see it as scumplay, especially when considering that SL has been very active and engaging throughout the game. The GB vs. SL fight struck me at one point as very town vs town which I mentioned earlier. I'd keep an eye on him here because I think ultimately he probably comes off looking a little worse than GB but still probably town.
Verdict: would not lynch

On April 24 2015 03:21 Koshi wrote:
WoS is anybody even townreading you?

Like...

Where do you even get the nerf to complain after playing this game?

I have cared in games 3 times as much as you are doing now.

I had people in my games who cared 3 times as less as I am doing now.


I just played. Rarely I blamed players. Sometimes balance. lol.


You just don't play and mass blame people.

Terrible.

Who calls me

Terrible.


u suck bro

On April 24 2015 03:51 WaveofShadow wrote:

Stop whinging.
Obviously when it comes down to it I'll switch to GB, not that I'll like it.
I doubt it's as simple as loafery/vivax being the last two though. (Though admittedly it'll be kinda hilarious if true)