On March 31 2015 01:09 WaveofShadow wrote:
And you think LS as scum clearly outlines a terrible plan that looks very mafia so aligned in thread, JAT?

Of any player in the game, I would think LS would be the most likely to do this as mafia.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 16:11 GMT

#2624

On March 31 2015 01:10 LightningStrike wrote:

Show nested quote +

It makes sense for me since I a investigative role and there is like 1% chance that there is 3 town investigative roles and 2 is the most I seen in most games and considering we got pms it seem a little to much I think knowing I almost lost at MYLO in a pm game in Office Mini taking out scum!sicklucker on the final day as a Cop.

Given BH's role suggests there are 3 separate investigative roles that are not your own, why is BH mafia and not one of those other 2 roles (Sherlock, Moriarty)?

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 16:13 GMT

#2626

Could Moriarty please claim to me in PMs? Or if you do not think I am town, claim to jat.

And if you think neither of us are town, then I can't help you.

And if you're mafia you're probably not going to claim but that will make BH look better by extension.

The reason I choose Moriarty is because *usually* baddies are baddies in Greymist games, even though mafia will be given fakeclaims.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 16:15 GMT

#2628

On March 31 2015 01:14 LightningStrike wrote:

Show nested quote +

Slam is town since he been very serious this game and who was the other one that claimed because I don't remember seeing another claim after BH's and Slams.

BH's roleclaim explicitly mentions there are two other investigative roles that he will receive results for - Sherlock and Moriarty.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 16:19 GMT

#2637

On March 31 2015 01:18 rsoultin wrote:

Show nested quote +

it's more interesting that half the game has pmd me and you haven't

It isn't.

On March 30 2015 08:25 justanothertownie wrote:
I will stick to my general pm game policy -> I won't pm anybody unless I have a very urgent reason to do so. I will answer if pmed though so feel free to do so if you want.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 16:20 GMT

#2641

The Bank protects its assets

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 16:32 GMT

#2644

On March 31 2015 01:29 ObiWanShinobi wrote:

Show nested quote +

I thought we already discussed the fact that flavor isn't indicative in any way.

A kind soul pointed out to me that, by and large, in Greymist games baddies are usually baddies.

So (and I am happy for someone to prove me wrong with some examples) it would indeed be at least somewhat indicative.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 16:35 GMT

#2648

Essentially I think anyone in the game should be townreading at least one of justanothertownie and me, and I think a claim, privately, would be a very useful thing, especially as people are discussing BH being the lynch tomorrow, whom Moriarty is to an extent tied to.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 16:40 GMT

#2650

I don't really disagree, I've stated to more than one person in PMs that lynching BH without at least one, and probably both, other roleclaims is quite a bad idea indeed.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 22:05 GMT

#3037

Hi, I've been out all evening. If anyone has any pressing questions they want answered, pop me a PM.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts

March 30 2015 22:14 GMT

#3038

ok ignore that obviously.

Chezitwo

United States553 Posts