TL Mafia LXX: Guardians of the Galaxy - Page 23

On March 23 2015 08:24 Toadesstern wrote:

if only this would last longer than 12 hours

On March 23 2015 08:30 Damdred wrote:
Could always shennany on Rayn and hope he's the rb so viv can shoot LS XD trololol

On March 23 2015 08:31 Toadesstern wrote:

I was about to ask to get shot during night but with all the cop claims and whatnot that seems pretty unlikely atm... I'm legit scared of mafia trying to put me in any kind of lylo that involves vivax and me, on purpose.

On March 23 2015 09:10 Eden1892 wrote:

bitch please i was n1'd in my first newbie game while the doc was knowingly rb'd

On March 22 2015 21:14 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Can we start by ticking off the people who are clearly town and the reasons for them just to make sure we're not missing anything?
Vivax - Confirmed town by virtue of 21 pages of posting in a short amount of time, tryharding even after he didn't need to anymore to get off a shot, and working to solve the game.
Rsoultin - Confirmed town by virtue of 26 fucking pages of filter as well as Eden's rock hard... townread on her.
Toadesstern - Confirmed town by virtue of counterclaiming vig in a situation where it makes no sense for scum to do so, actively, strongly and genuinely pushing the initial claim, and afterwards coming to the realization that his push was probably town and work towards solving the game.
FecalFeast - Went after SL without trying to bury him. Has been trying to figure the game out, made a strong and detailed case against LS.
Trfel - Can't be scum with Superbia who looks pretty scummy already, plus checked LS with the orb which caused him to concede.
Artanis[Xp] - Making lots of observations that are difficult to make as scum, 20 pages, very fluid reads.
Damdred - Wall of texts in the kind that he only makes as town. Have never seen him make anything even remotely similar as scum.
Eden1892 - Has been actively trying to solve the game and seems to be even more motivated with the current turn of events. Generally being a town hero the past night.

Anything you don't find very convincing here?

ExO_ I can't possibly see as mafia on further reflection. Let's look at what we have to assume for this to be true:
- ExO_ seeded being the cop in several posts prior to claiming
- ExO_ fakeclaimed cop with a green check on someone then argued the target was the godfather instead of just claiming a red check
- ExO_ didn't bother to look at the role he was fakeclaiming to see whether it was an alignment cop or role cop
- ExO_ brought the argument to rsoultin when he wasn't directly under pressure at the time, putting himself in the hot seat just to try to maybe get a jailer claim mislynched

Does that sound like anything resembling a good plan to anybody? How about instead ExO_ is the real cop, didn't realize he was only an alignment cop due to getting a check that used the same name as a specific role, and claimed to force someone he thought was fakeclaiming to explain themselves? Yeah Eden that makes a lot more sense.

On March 23 2015 09:14 Damdred wrote:
Yes for example LS was tracked to hf not to vivax. If he is the rb how did vivax not shoot?

On March 23 2015 09:35 Toadesstern wrote:
I am actually about 190% certain onegu is no mason and I've already said so 3 times.

The question about Onegu is wether or not he did it to draw shots or to fakeclaim to not get lynched as lurker wh does nothing.
You can make an argument that he's more likely to be town because Rayn said he's not mason with Onegu. Would mafia!rayn just go along and claim mason, happy about suddenly being townread by everyone and their mom?

We literally had him as orange / heavy red before the mason claim, about to lynch him, Onegu claims Rayn is his buddy and suddenly everyone is townreading Rayn. And that made sense.
But this just doesn't seem coordinated between Onegu and Rayn at all... unless this is some crappy wifom "look I wouldn't do this as mafia" but that's pretty convoluted.
Pretty sure they're just not mafia together

On March 23 2015 09:40 Eden1892 wrote:

i'm cool with it

man how fucking awesome would it be if sicklucker is actually onegu's masonbro?

On March 23 2015 22:22 Damdred wrote:
i'm really not and that was meh to read

On March 23 2015 22:26 Vivax wrote:
I have a secret about Artanis id like to share.