XXX Mini Mafia: A Night of Debauchery (18+) - Page 5

On March 13 2015 20:27 Eden1892 wrote:
onegu y u no vote damdred

On March 13 2015 20:44 Eden1892 wrote:

not good enough, what is wrong with my case

On March 14 2015 18:19 Palmar wrote:
Marv and I could both shoot rsoultin for different reasons

On March 14 2015 20:07 marvellosity wrote:
like the fact you are so hyperaware of your meta to a degree invalidates it.

the best meta is when someone could actually not do the things they do as mafia. Like say LS. He's basically not capable of playing like he has this game as mafia. Or I cannot post at 3 times the rate of my most posty ever scumgame. Like 3x the rate, and look at how productive i got yesterday. is that possible? maybe in some wizard world, but it would be incredible difficult.

but if you're hyperwaware of your bussing meta and nothing you've done is difficult to replicate

you are 100% able to do fuck all and make weird/contradictory voting decisions. if you're town you had every reason to vote jat. he was a liar and your townreads were pushing him...

On March 14 2015 20:22 marvellosity wrote:
you guys can lynch prp.

I will have nothing to do with it.

On March 15 2015 08:20 Eden1892 wrote:
anyway right now I'm at Palmar, ray, marv for my mafia pile, with a strong strong emphasis on Palmar and ray over marv.

• Koshi and LS are claimed blues and have both been pretty townie besides to me. Don't think this needs explanation. I would say there's maybe a <0.1% chance LS is mafia and has me totally fooled but his stuff around his roleclaim seemed so part-and-parcel LS that I refuse to consider this possibility seriously.
  
• I've finally come around to Damdred recently - the commentary (however brief) about him wanting to change his playstyle really rings true to me. It kinda hits a soft spot for me and I know this probably isn't the "best" reason to anybody else, but it's what connects the most for me.
  
• I think prplhz is pretty townie because he's done a lot of research outside the game, like Damdred said. It is very, very difficult to reconcile him being mafia with JAT, and then researching JAT's games to see that JAT doesn't townread people as town and then saying as much in the thread and then doing nothing with it. That sequence just doesn't make sense to me from a mafia standpoint.
  
• I think Onegu is very probably town for the VT thing, and I kinda want to lynch him regardless, because after having multiple games ruined for me last night because of stupid townseal/pseudoseal bullshit, I'm really sick of people just doing shit like only claiming VT as town and then not actually playing the game. I'm not trying to single out Onegu here or insult him or anything, but I'm here to play mafia, not "come up with a creative and plausible way to signal town every game in lieu of just playing like a good townie," and whether he means to do it this way or not, that's how it comes off. His actual play this game hasn't been impressive. It just sucks because I want to win and lynching a guy I think is probably town to punish him for the VT thing isn't going to help me win.
  
• I only really have marv in my pile due to POE, as I say things about other people that I'm thinking I realize that he's already said quite a few of those things so that alone means he's probably not mafia. I just have enough respect for marv's scum game not to write anything off - but I don't really have any interest in pursuing this.
  
• I'm not sure how well ray could have actually buried me like Damdred is saying, and it becomes a lot easier to explain JAT's decision to try to get ritoky lynched if his counterwagon is mafia and also a wagon which basically only existed at that point due to inertia. The thing holding me back here is that JAT is stone-cold about busing and I feel like he probably could have found an excuse to be on ray earlier - but then, he did appear to be quite busy with irl things during the first half of d1 if I remember right, so maybe that's why. ray's questions about my thought process with the blues at the beginning of d2 also didn't really make sense to me, and my (admittedly likely confirmation-biased) thought here is that he didn't realize that I didn't actually know too much because he doesn't have the same information we do. I felt like what I said made perfect sense, and it seemed like ray was looking to interpret it in a way such that I "knew too much" even though I didn't.
  
• Just c/p what I said earlier about Palmar here.

On March 15 2015 09:47 Eden1892 wrote:

My thought process if ray is town is that the mafia were probably just afk/pseudo-afk on whatever wagons they were on - and prplhz is someone whose activity profile at the time fit the bill perfectly. But it's really hard to reconcile his early comment about jat with him being jat's teammate. afaik prplhz hasn't played enough games with jat to be able to have read his early townreads as indicative of anything, which means it's very unlikely that mafia!prplhz would have even thought to notice that in his partner, let alone go research it to confirm, let alone bring it up in essence just to bring it up.

Like there's nothing that says it 100% couldn't have happened, but that's something I feel would be very unlikely to catch mafia!prplhz's attention in the first place.

On March 15 2015 10:36 Koshi wrote:
I am still bugged out why rsoultin died.

Damdred/Palmar also possible. Even though I read Damdred 101% town.


I am just killing Palmar tomorrow. And so should everybody else.

On March 16 2015 01:22 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I still want the answer to how Damdred goes to checking rsoultin.
I don't care about it on night but the next day i will.

If we discount Damdred for now lynch Onegu.

On March 16 2015 03:42 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Can you point out the last game i couldn't read you?
All you've been saying in this game is "rayn is town yadda yadda" and it feels like an overplay.

I don't care about prplhz atm. Why should i read you town?

On March 16 2015 07:26 raynpelikoneet wrote:

I don't care if i have read you wrong or right (in fact in neat and tidy i read you right when koshi was as ass).
You have nothing to say except "rayn is town".
That makes you scun.