PYP: Pick Your Protoss Mini Mafia - Page 3

On January 26 2015 21:43 Palmar wrote:

This is so wrong it hurts.

On January 26 2015 22:19 Palmar wrote:
that's kind of his thing as mafia, just be so boring that I want to cry.

On January 26 2015 22:45 Superbia wrote:


So what does it mean?

On January 26 2015 22:56 IAmRobik wrote:

He might just be worn out from the last mafia game he played where he try-harded and didn't want to do it 2 games in a row.

On January 26 2015 23:09 Superbia wrote:
Who cares? Marv still hasn't done shit this game. He's mafia.

Get mad in QT or something. You're probably dying next.

On January 26 2015 23:12 Superbia wrote:
You remind me of me when I was scum one game and town was going after my team mate because he had been lurking. I also hard pushed a policy lynch to try to ensure team mate lived.

On January 26 2015 23:15 Superbia wrote:
The push on Marv is absolutely relevant but you choose to ignore it for no reason. It is astounding that you're literally saying you're willing to give him a pass d1 and are even essentially hard-defending him for no fucking reason.

On January 26 2015 23:17 Superbia wrote:
Oats, what's your opinion on mderg?

On January 26 2015 23:41 Palmar wrote:
Like I want to sort of murder Oats. Not because I don't think marv is mafia, but Oats' defense of him is just so blatantly wrong that it could be TMI.

Like no one on earth thinks that disinterested lazy marv is more likely to be town than mafia, and certainly not to the point of defending him as hard as Oats has.

If Oats was town I'd think his thought process was much less certain of marv's alignment. Like it's basically inconceivable to me that Oats can be this certain marv isn't mafia with as little information as marv has given us. There is obviously a case to be made for marv being town and disinterested, but it's not a strong enough case to act like oats does. Much more reasonable approach would be.

"chill guys, let's see if marv picks up. If he doesn't we gotta lynch him I suppose"
"look, he might just be disinterested and town. I don't know"

These kind of semi-hedged bets on his alignment make a lot of sense from a town perspective. It's exactly how you think when you're town. You're never certain of anything but you try to fit things to general rules.

Oats, on the other hand, is basically chainsaw defending marv for absolutely no good reason.

On January 26 2015 23:44 Palmar wrote:

And I haven't?

On January 26 2015 23:49 Palmar wrote:


I initially called marv scum for this post. It's a super weak tone read. This sort of "I'm not going to work with you guys to show I'm independent, but I'm still not gonna be a complete asshole about it". Like it's the in between of "fuck you guys, Imma do my own thing" and "here's our plan and how we make it work".

like the point about it partially conflicting with someone has nothing to do with the game at hand and there is no need to even mention it.

---

the reason I'm explaining this is because marv reacts very starkly to me thinking he's mafia. One of his responses is, and probably what he'd normally do, is to simply clam up and make sure he doesn't give up his team. Which me might well be doing here.

He has done it before, in fact he has soft-claimed mafia twice after I figure him out on day 1 and just stopped trying. He tryharded last game and got carried by town-baddies. I don't think he'd be inclined to doing it again.