I think I've misunderstood some of (his?) posts and I can't get a read on him in game. This is the only game I've played with him. Don't know him very well. Someone said something about not reading him well for a long time.

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 08:37 GMT

#518

On January 18 2015 17:34 DarthPunk wrote:

Show nested quote +

Nah you are good now. Like 6 months to a year ago no way.

How long have you guys played this game?!

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 08:39 GMT

#520

Small dog. Usually barks really loud. Reminds me of how he started the game, then backtracked when people got on him.

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 08:41 GMT

#521

On January 18 2015 17:39 geript wrote:

Show nested quote +

Looks like 2 years

Dang. I don't want to play you ever if your mafia lol

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 08:46 GMT

#525

lol she might not like me for that one. She can get fixated at times and generally doesn't like it when people straight up lie to her. Carries grudges sometimes. Can get frustrated easily.

To get brownie points for that I'll say she is one of my favorite people to have a conversation with and is pretty funny. Also super smart and stuff! lol

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 08:47 GMT

#527

Ok I can see how playing with people who haven't played for very long could get you guys frustrated then. Hopefully we all improve in time...lol

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 09:13 GMT

#535

On January 18 2015 17:54 The Shining wrote:
Geript - Town lost the game in the last Newbie by lynching Jar Jar D3. I was set to be lynched D1 before WW's lynch picked up speed. I'm addressing it because you said I was more nitpicky in that game. I would probably agree with you but the fact is I'm not a fan of D1, never have been. First D1 in my 1st TL game, we lynched a blue role. I still don't really like how that tasted. I'm much better at vote analysis and seeing if people's N1/D2 play and reactions stay consistent.

I'm also not really sure why my argument against the setup is weird. When I read JJ's post, I checked the OP to see if there was a Doc/Cop setup. It took me a few seconds. I found it weird that JJB went on a Google search with this info instead of checking himself. What would stop him from checking all the possible setups when mentioning the setup being the reason he couldn't think of a plan? Only thing I could come up with is him possibly knowing the setup and not being interested in the alternatives. I won't put much weight on anything concerning setups after my balance theory regarding Doc and Vet(which was right btw) wasn't listened to but I still definitely felt it worth mentioning. Putting any thought out there is better than staying quiet any longer.

Ya I didn't address this lol This will probably make me look kind of bad. I actually did read the 3 different types of town roles... lol I initially went there before I did the analysis on the whole no lynch thing (I can send you a link for it if I figure out how to do that with excel!) I looked back today and saw that cop/medic is really a thing lol. I could see why Shining and Rsoultin would scum me on this, because it definitely was pretty bad that I went off thinking that cop and medic couldn't be a role after literally reading the three roles lol

I don't see how Shining picking up on the cop/medic thing makes him mafia. His BS meter probably just went off because he read the rules before the game started.

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 09:18 GMT

#537

On January 18 2015 18:11 Breshke wrote:
I don't get why jarjar being present in the thread and responding to questions means he couldn't be mafia?

Rsoultin said he is competitive so wouldn't he still try if not try harder as scum because he needs to stay alive.

Good question on the being present in the thread and responding to questions thing. I feel like that is generally something everyone does?

I would disagree with this, at least from my limited experience. At least based on my only game, if town mislynches town 3 times then town is equally screwed as long as medic doesn't save anyone. My last game we had 3 straight mislynches and we were done. I think this game has the same number of players.

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 09:20 GMT

#538

I'm sure there will be some more questions when I wake up tomorrow. I'll try to answer them and piece together something of substance for us before voting time.

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 20:03 GMT

#645

OK read up and stuff.

Questions:

Geript: does GB usually contribute better than in this game? His filter isn't as high quality as yours but he definitely appears to be scumhunting IMO.

Damdred: Was the vote for GB reactionary? Or was it really because he was "boring"? Is boring enough to lynch him? Have you read DP's filter yet? He's already given the reaction you claimed to be looking for.

Rsoultin: What are your thoughts on LM now that he's posted some more?

Let me know if you have questions for me. I'll probably be on here for about 30 more minutes looking for things.

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 20:27 GMT

#658

On January 19 2015 05:09 rsoultin wrote:

Show nested quote +

^ What makes me think JJB is town. Dude, please explain your mislynches response when Breshke asked if scum couldn't try hard if they were competitive, too?

Pin in LM. Sometimes I will not state my thoughts aloud if I think that will cause someone to play differently than they otherwise would, especially when I'm still trying to get reads on certain players.

LOL. I was about to post a reply to that. I can't tell if LM didn't understand my reasoning or just wanted to "not understand it" to help his case.

Based on the number of players, if town mislynches 3 straight times town loses. Just like if we lynch mafia 3 straight times mafia loses. That is equal. As a member of either team, I would equally not want to be lynched.

That was my thought process. Lets look at day 1 mislynch vs lynching mafia. Mislynch would kill 2 people (1 day and 1 night unless there is a medic and medic is lucky enough to save the right vet/towny person). The number of people would be 8 to 3, causing a large spark in mafia's favor. IF mafia is lynched instead, the number is now 9 to 2. A large spark in towns favor. Those proportions also are a relatively equal deal in terms of influence IMO. If we mislynch day 1, town has to:
1: get a good enough read to garner enough votes to overrule 3 mafia votes.
2. get over losing one of their best players on our team
3. get over pressure of mislynching twice after being completely wrong on day 1

We are already at a disadvantage after cool getting modkilled.

For all of those reasons I would be equally despondent if I am lyched day 1 as either town or mafia. Hopefully that was less mumbo jumbo lolz

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 20:34 GMT

#665

On January 19 2015 05:12 Damdred wrote:
I never put a vote on GB what are you talking about jarjar?

No I haven't read dps filter

Your right. I thought you voted for him but that was geript...lol Sorry about not making sense in my questions towards you. I think that was strike two lolz

How come about the DP filter? Did he just give you a townie vibe? Or do you think you wouldn't be able to tell if he's scum and it isn't worth going through?

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 20:41 GMT

#678

On January 19 2015 05:37 rsoultin wrote:
Pssht JarJar you just validated Breshke's argument against you xP That being try-hard is not alignment indicative.

LOL this is why I would never try to be a lawyer xD

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 20:54 GMT

#693

On January 19 2015 05:46 GlowingBear wrote:
Jar jar
Who is scum and why?

You could convince me that damdred is scum with a slightly better argument. I don't know him. I don't know why he answered mine and now DP's questions about not reading DP's filter. Being a little wish-washy on you probably isn't enough for my vote though. I think that's why you asked this question.

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 20:55 GMT

#696

On January 19 2015 05:45 geript wrote:

Show nested quote +

If you can't read 2 of my posts and know that I'm town, then there's really nothing I could ever say that would change that. I'm buddying up to DP because he's the only good player who I'm sure is town and can get an honest opinion on.

How do you know DP is town? Was it something he did? It does appear like he's scumreading after reading his filter.

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 20:56 GMT

#697

EBWOP: scumhunting not scumreading

jarjarbinks

569 Posts

January 18 2015 21:08 GMT

#722

GB:

My three people I would vote as mafia are you damdred and LM.

1. LM
2. Damdred
3. GB

I don't like damdred's last posts.

jarjarbinks