EPTI see that you said you were willing to shenanigan onto Shining or JarJar before the blue claim, but only them. So the blue claim wasn't enough to get you to go for either of your other scumreads, who both had votes? Shining especially would have been a good choice at the time.
Newbie Mini Mafia LX - Page 7
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
I see that you said you were willing to shenanigan onto Shining or JarJar before the blue claim, but only them. So the blue claim wasn't enough to get you to go for either of your other scumreads, who both had votes? Shining especially would have been a good choice at the time. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
Do you have any questions for me? I'm still working back through the posting leading up to the lynch. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
On January 09 2015 11:57 Tubesock wrote: Bah I can't read. You're asking at eod. I was town reading Celestial then as we had an exchange when he said he was going to jarjar. Jar being my listed #2, I didn't really care about it. Tube, you wanted me to ask you questions. Please answer them. How does this matter? You called out Gumdrop at least twice and Shining for wasting their votes leading up to the lynch. But you didn't bother saying anything to Celestial. Am I misunderstanding something? | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
On January 09 2015 12:15 Half the Sky wrote: The only question I have at this point in time for you is to confirm your scumreads and/or nulls. You said a number of people were being scummy in a recent post. I know you are scumreading Celestial and LS possibly but whom else? Tonight I am able to stay up a bit late until 4am, or another 45 mins, so if either you have something for me, please let me know. I'm off work tomorrow thank goodness. I'm actually doing vote analysis right now and comparing people's reads/reactions to their post-lynch explanations. To be honest, I'm struggling with paranoia...and uncertainty on whether or not decisions were made because of people being new, or because they were scum. My only strong town read right now is you...which at this point in the game I think is rather sad. A few others I'm not interested in lynching right now, but bah. Preliminary...Gumdrop, Celestial...still deciding on JarJar, Shining, LS whether I think they're scum or just bear closer watching. Silver is a null for me cause she's just a general question mark this game. Tube is null cause some things I find weird, but I can see him being super tunneled cause we all suffer from it sometimes and his posts do read that way...his posting has been pretty good, too. So null. But this is all just preliminary. I'll have something more concrete waiting for you (and everyone else) when you wake up. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
She's brand new to mafia. Her very first game. I'm just treating her as an inactive right now because I can't get anything from an AFK vote anyway and she's posted so little. Regardless, she's definitely not in my top scumreads that would make her a potential lynch tomorrow unless everyone goes stark raving mad and decides to vote you and ExO as scum or something. Then I'd be willing to settle on just about anyone else lol ><. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
Belatedly, though, I'm not really sure what is in-character for him in mafia games. We played a little on the much more inactive site. I know he likes votes, numbers, real evidence and not so much what people say cause people can lie. But how that translates into an active game from an inactive one, or compares to how we treat each other normally...it's hard to say. Silver's always friendly to me? But we're friends. So that is kind of a given. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
I won't lynch the following tomorrow under any circumstances: HTS ExO (lesser town read, but still a town read) Those I would prefer not to lynch from strongest to weakest: JarJar (despite the OMGUS moment at his case, was consistent on his reads leading up to the lynch, and voted sensibly) Tubesock (appeared tunneled, took responsibility afterwards, solid posting before and after) Silver (complete null) Shining (suspicious, don't like the lying, but his defense was otherwise convincing and he's improved in Day 2. willing to give him more time) Gumdrop (suspicious, but he hasn't posted hardly at all. the only thing that doesn't make this a policy lynch is the point I asked him to clarify on EoD...and I'd like to see his answer before lynching him) On to lynchables: LS - <3 you, dude, but I think you're a solid lynch + all actives you townread (with the exception of shining at null), and all inactives you null read (scum WW as "worst inactive") - thanks to ExO (I think) for turning me on to this gem + only reaction to WWs soft claim was to ask him to claim + sudden rage after flip and saying you tunneled him...where? your reads put him as basically the worst of your nulls + meta point: afraid of lynching blues in all prior games -Celestial- - not personal either, but you're my top choice + all three lynchwagons were scumread by you in your last Day 1 list post, with waffling back and forth on LS afterwards + kept saying WW lynch felt wrong, yet reacted to blue claim saying it wasn't enough to convince "us" (weren't you already convinced given your posts?) + more about WW lynch feeling wrong, but did nothing about it i.e. tried to get others to vote JarJar with you or change your vote to other two scumreads LS and Shining + lesser point, but you never mention my static vote on WW despite Shining case until I question you...why didn't it come up before in your WW lynch feels wrong posts? Will place the vote here tomorrow morning, all things remaining equal. If anyone wants links to the posts behind those points, please ask. (Was going for readability.) | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
For kicks and giggles later (I don't even need this before EoD but others may be more curious) could you give us your equation at some point? I was wondering how to "quantify" my reads, as well, cause settling on feels to determine the weight of the behavior seems very subjective. (Probably would use more inputs than just what the dead voters voted, though.) Thanks! | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
What do you think about Celestial's can't be assed to do anything when he is saying WW is a bad lynch, and Shining and LS both were scumreads of his at the time, HTS? Also, re: Celestial's case on me, it could be summed up as: - Blue-hunting first few posts (pretty sure no one thinks that but him at this point; correct me if I'm wrong) - Keeping vote on WW (already explained) Meh, no reason for me to even respond to it. Will say that there is a ton of words there to repeat the same things, though. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
##Vote: Celestial Time for work. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
Came home to change for the going-away. Fortunately. @Celeste if Scum (as I suspect) Great move. Hard-claiming doc where any sensible doc won't CC, and you can pick off an unsensible one Night 2. @Celeste if Town You deserve every ounce of condescension before and that will continue coming your way for hardclaiming doctor with a strong counterwagon and over 8 hours to go. Truly an idiotic move. I hope your save is worth it. Truly. You're fing useless to us now and even if scum doesn't kill you Night 2 town is likely to Day 3. Thanks for throwing the game. Bah >< I have to treat his claim like it's the truth. ##vote: friggin LS LS, dude, if you have a case on anyone make it now. I'll try to get back from the going-away soon enough to review it. -_- | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
1. assumes that you are town, and I'm already scumreading you 2. assumes that Celestial is telling the truth, which I'm not sold on, and 3. also applies to Tubesock and myself, so why single out ExO? I'll admit that I mostly just skimmed your case, and I'll look closer later, but that point above is not and never will be good enough for me to lynch a current townread. I will take the time to review your posts when I get back, though. I was less certain of you than Celestial. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
| ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
On January 10 2015 04:54 LightningStrike wrote: Then look at it after I get lynched then? Also lynch Celestial after lynching me after I flipped as town please? If he's still alive Day 3, LS, regardless of who is lynched today it'll take an act of God to keep me from emulating a bulldozer on his ass. -_- Frankly. If you believe ExO is scum, build a good case, man. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
Seems everyone is content with an LS lynch. I am, too, so can't complain. | ||
|
rsoultin
Netherlands15308 Posts
HTS, Tube...have either of you ever known LS to have deep reads or strong cases? My issue with him is how he reacted to the blue claim more than anything else. It doesn't line up for me. I know this could be a massive buss, but the silence is starting to give me doubts >< Anyone else even in the thread right now? | ||
| ||
